View Single Post
Old 11-21-2017, 01:13 PM   #38
Join Date: Sep 2017
Posts: 384
Default Re: Deborah Ann Woll IS Karen Page

Originally Posted by guitarsingerguy View Post
This isn't DC we're talking about here. Ewwww, salty! Seriously though, I think Marvel is smart enough to realize it's way too soon for Frank to have any romantic relationship. He had just finished (or so he thought) killing all the people responsible at the start of the season. As far as I'm concerned, that's the equivalent of Frank having just buried his wife. He loved her too much to go slinging his skull covered penis around the tv MCU. Besides, what are they upset that Claire is gonna be the only female being tossed around between the Defenders, so they've gotta add Karen to the rank of MCU ho too?!
Here's what I have to say about Karen's part on The Punisher. First off, she was only in four episodes, but I think we got a nice dose of Karen extending her reporting ventures and learning how she’s been dealing with Matt's supposed death at the end of The Defenders. You can tell she still feels the pain of losing Matt. Even though she never once mentions Matt's or Foggy's names, it always looks to me like the two men are on her mind whenever she's on-camera. Karen is definitely putting on a mask whenever she's around Frank, hiding from him and burying herself in her work to escape the pain. Karen's grief over Matt also provoked a more reckless side of her.

But while I like Karen, I like Deborah Ann Woll and what she brings to the role, I don't like the plot she was given in The Punisher.

In Daredevil season 2, Karen's bond with Frank was definitely one that felt like a big brother-little sister thing. It was a bond that was made of mutual respect and understanding. But that doesn't translate to the spin-off. Like, the connection between Karen and Frank here is not the same thing as that which we got in Daredevil season 2. Sure, there was some very touching stuff like when Karen hugged Frank at her apartment, there were other parts about their interactions in The Punisher that made me facepalm. For instance, Frank's outburst to Micro that "Karen is family" in episode 9, or the scene on the elevator in episode 10. Those scenes, to me, felt so out of place, especially since Karen’s name doesn't even come up in episodes where she doesn't appear. Like, Frank only cares about Karen if she's in danger or he needs to use her to get information. Their interactions instead came off like corny Kastle fanfic.

And Karen seems more like a plot device in The Punisher. Yeah, that's her role. Her contributions to the A-plot extend solely to providing Frank with information that allows him to identify Carson Wolf as one of the conspirators and also get access to Micro. Her other contribution was to provide a resolution to the Lewis Wilson B-plot. I think Lewis's plot was interesting. But having him send a manifesto to the Bulletin seemed like an excuse to try and give Karen some more presence, plus satisfy the dreams of a certain section of the Kastle fandom.

Don't get me wrong, I do understand why Karen Page was used instead of Claire Temple to bridge The Punisher with Daredevil and the rest of the Netflix shows, as she had developed a bond with him. So it makes sense for her to show up if only for that purpose, but it also kinda slows the pacing down. I love Karen and I want to see her get developed even a little bit (obviously they weren't going to do much with Karen given the heavy focus on Frank's past, which she has no attachment to), but this show did nothing for her. She doesn’t really share any personal or meaningful conversations with Frank as she’d done in Daredevil, making her addition to the show feel a little awkward.

I will add one more thing: it's still pretty clear Karen's path is geared towards her and Matt getting back together romantically in Daredevil season 3. Her state of suffering in The Punisher, conveyed primarily in her clothing choices, only clarifies how much Karen still loves Matt, in the romantic sense. Her fears and concerns for Frank’s well-being ("Where does it end, Frank?") come from a place of her own personal loss (and echo similar remarks we've seen Claire and Foggy give to Matt).

dmcreif is offline   Reply With Quote