Clemens, Pettitte, McNamee asked to testify to Congress

[Spidey-Bat]

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080104/...ngress_clemens

WASHINGTON - Roger Clemens and Andy Pettitte were asked Friday to testify before a congressional committee on Jan. 16, along with their former trainer, Brian McNamee.

Also invited to appear before the House Oversight Committee were former Mets clubhouse attendant Kirk Radomski, whose allegations were a central part of last month's Mitchell report on doping in baseball. Former All-Star second baseman Chuck Knoblauch also was asked to speak to the panel.

A day earlier, the committee is to hear testimony from baseball commissioner Bud Selig, union leader Donald Fehr and former Senate majority leader George Mitchell

McNamee told Mitchell he had injected Clemens with steroids and human growth hormone during the 1998, 2000 and 2001 seasons. Clemens, in an interview to be broadcast by CBS's "60 Minutes" on Sunday, said McNamee injected him with vitamins and painkillers but not performance-enhancing drugs.

Pettitte admitted McNamee injected him with HGH twice while the pitcher was recovering from an injury.

The panel also convened a March 2005 hearing, when Mark McGwire refused to say whether he had used performance-enhancing drugs. Sammy Sosa said he had never knowingly used illegal performance-enhancing drugs. Rafael Palmeiro denied using drugs but tested positive later that year for a steroid.

Clemens is done.

[NewYorkSpider]

Yeah, Clemens is screwed. He should have came out like Pettite did last month. Now he's going to be charged with perjury.

[E. Nygma]

Originally Posted by NewYorkSpider

Yeah, Clemens is screwed. He should have came out like Pettite did last month. Now he's going to be charged with perjury.

Only if he lies!

We all know he's telling the truth, and that B12 is administered through injections with a needle

[Nightmare]

I cant wait to see them up there stumbling over themselves. Just like Mcgwire and Palmeiro

[kane9321]

this is gonna be fun..you can lie to mike wallace, but ya cant lie to congress

[NewYorkSpider]

Is anyone watching "60 Minutes" with Roger Clemens right now. You can tell in his face that he's lying. It's so hilarious when he gets asked a question, cause he just says "it didn't happen". He also hesitates with some of his questions.

[Dark Donnie]

Posted this in the other thread

Clemens Sues for Defamation

[ChrisBaleBatman]

I think he's telling the truth.

It's sad, how far down this country as gone. It's supposed to be Innocent until proven guilty.

How do you prove your innocent where evidence doesn't exist?

I mean, you can prove guilt by having incriminating evidence...but how do you prove innocence?

If you ask me, Clemens is being treated unfairly. There's no evidence, no smoking gun, no paper trail, no seller's to coroberate...just an angry little man who was scared to go to jail, and probably was co-herced into saying what he said.

Clemens seemed nervous last night, which makes sense when you consider the situation he's in.

And, he's doing what everyone said he was supposed to. He's suing! He's filing a suit! Yet, right now...everyone over at ESPN is railroading him on him filing a suit.

And B12 does get administered through injections too. Tons of athletes get it. Tons.

[E. Nygma]

Originally Posted by ChrisBaleBatman

I think he's telling the truth.

It's sad, how far down this country as gone. It's supposed to be Innocent until proven guilty.

How do you prove your innocent where evidence doesn't exist?

I mean, you can prove guilt by having incriminating evidence...but how do you prove innocence?

If you ask me, Clemens is being treated unfairly. There's no evidence, no smoking gun, no paper trail, no seller's to coroberate...just an angry little man who was scared to go to jail, and probably was co-herced into saying what he said.

Clemens seemed nervous last night, which makes sense when you consider the situation he's in.

And, he's doing what everyone said he was supposed to. He's suing! He's filing a suit! Yet, right now...everyone over at ESPN is railroading him on him filing a suit.

And B12 does get administered through injections too. Tons of athletes get it. Tons.

Is that you Rocket?

[Spidey-Bat]

Originally Posted by ChrisBaleBatman

I think he's telling the truth.

It's sad, how far down this country as gone. It's supposed to be Innocent until proven guilty.

How do you prove your innocent where evidence doesn't exist?

I mean, you can prove guilt by having incriminating evidence...but how do you prove innocence?

If you ask me, Clemens is being treated unfairly. There's no evidence, no smoking gun, no paper trail, no seller's to coroberate...just an angry little man who was scared to go to jail, and probably was co-herced into saying what he said.

Clemens seemed nervous last night, which makes sense when you consider the situation he's in.

And, he's doing what everyone said he was supposed to. He's suing! He's filing a suit! Yet, right now...everyone over at ESPN is railroading him on him filing a suit.

And B12 does get administered through injections too. Tons of athletes get it. Tons.

Clemens may be innocent. If he is, he is going out about this the wrong way. He took 5 days to respond to the Mitchell investigation. He had his YouTube video (a ****ing YT video!) several weeks after. Then almost a month later he appears on 60 minutes.

On top of this, look at the stats. He was awful at the end of his tenure in Boston, and then becomes amazing. In 2004 he had an incredible year with the Astros and he was over 40. No strict work out can do that alone.

Another thing, Brian McNamee had to tell the truth. If he didn't, federal prosecutors would have charged him. Here's what the idiot said:

"What did McNamee gain by lying?"

"Evidently not going to jail," Clemens says.

How does lying get him out of going to jail if lying was going to get him prosecuted?

[Dark Donnie]

Originally Posted by Spidey-Bat

Clemens may be innocent. If he is, he is going out about this the wrong way. He took 5 days to respond to the Mitchell investigation. He had his YouTube video (a ****ing YT video!) several weeks after. Then almost a month later he appears on 60 minutes.

On top of this, look at the stats. He was awful at the end of his tenure in Boston, and then becomes amazing. In 2004 he had an incredible year with the Astros and he was over 40. No strict work out can do that alone.

Another thing, Brian McNamee had to tell the truth. If he didn't, federal prosecutors would have charged him. Here's what the idiot said:


How does lying get him out of going to jail if lying was going to get him prosecuted?

He wasn't awful im sure his run support was terrible. He had a mid 3 ERA, but still pitched 6 CG and 2 SHO's

[Nightmare]

Wow what a phone conversation. Mack Amay kept saying over and over to Clemens "Tell me what you want me to do"

[NewYorkSpider]

Very interesting phone conversation between Clemens and McNamee. They bring up a good point about McNamee never saying "you took steroids" in the conversation or "yes it is" when Clemens says that it wasn't the truth. McNamee sounded like he was very sorry in the conversation that this was effecting Clemens family.

[Spidey-Bat]

He had an ERA of 4 or higher in '93 and '95. His last year he 3.6 ERA, but 1.3 WHIP and 106 BB. He was breaking down.

[E. Nygma]

McNamee and Clemens conversation was so bland. Neither guy blatantly came out and said "i never took steroids" "you never took steroids" "i took steroids" "you took steriods". It was a pretty wasted convo.

[E. Nygma]

and they dont argue the whole time......McNamee never defends his claims. I'm not so sure he didn't know that he was being taped.

[NewYorkSpider]

Clemens repeatedly said "I want the truth to come out". How come McNamee never said "you know it's the truth" or "you know you did it"? Clemens still hasn't proved to me he didn't take steroids, but the conversation brought up good points for both Clemens and McNamee. Clemens knew he was being taped, so he wasn't as pissed. McNamee on the other hand swore multiple times and got angry.

[ChrisBaleBatman]

Clemens may be innocent. If he is, he is going out about this the wrong way. He took 5 days to respond to the Mitchell investigation. He had his YouTube video (a ****ing YT video!) several weeks after. Then almost a month later he appears on 60 minutes.

His lawyers advised him no to. He's got to listen to his lawyers, that's they're jobs...to advise him.

On top of this, look at the stats. He was awful at the end of his tenure in Boston, and then becomes amazing. In 2004 he had an incredible year with the Astros and he was over 40. No strict work out can do that alone.

I disagree, in a way. Not just strict work outs...but incredible drive, and talent...which Clemens has. His numbers are great, but not to the point that Barry Bonds was in how it ballooned.

Another thing, Brian McNamee had to tell the truth. If he didn't, federal prosecutors would have charged him. Here's what the idiot said

He was caught up in a Federal case. He was screwed. Which, funny enough, sounds like he probably was coerced...they told him to tell the "truth" as a get out of jail card. I mean, c'mon...if they sway you into letting you know what they wany, you can give it to them.

How does lying get him out of going to jail if lying was going to get him prosecuted?

He was already going to jail. Then, after he got caught up in his own little storm...the Mitchell investigators were told who he was, and they went to talk to him and to cut a deal.

So, yeah...lying would have helped get him out of jail, since he was already looking at doing time.

[Spidey-Bat]

Originally Posted by ChrisBaleBatman

His lawyers advised him no to. He's got to listen to his lawyers, that's they're jobs...to advise him.

Awful advice. I've heard some people in the legal business on TV say he should have filed the suit Dec 14.

I disagree, in a way. Not just strict work outs...but incredible drive, and talent...which Clemens has. His numbers are great, but not to the point that Barry Bonds was in how it ballooned.

They are. Strict workouts don't get you 106 BB to 68 BB in one season.

He was caught up in a Federal case. He was screwed. Which, funny enough, sounds like he probably was coerced...they told him to tell the "truth" as a get out of jail card. I mean, c'mon...if they sway you into letting you know what they wany, you can give it to them.

He told the truth about Pettitte. Why does he lie about Roger?

He was already going to jail. Then, after he got caught up in his own little storm...the Mitchell investigators were told who he was, and they went to talk to him and to cut a deal.

So, yeah...lying would have helped get him out of jail, since he was already looking at doing time.

If he had to lie to get out of jail, wouldn't he lie by saying Clemens DIDN'T take steroids? Clemens isn't going to begin this massive campaign to prove him wrong. It would be much easier for him to get away by lying that Clemens didn't take steroids than if he lied saying he did.

[ChrisBaleBatman]

Wow what a phone conversation. Mack Amay kept saying over and over to Clemens "Tell me what you want me to do"

Clemens laywer did state that he was worried that McAmee was trying to set up Clemens, so if Clemens had said "I want you to come with me on Monday", could have been seen as Clemens trying to force him, coherce him, or trying to buy him back to hold against him in court. As witness tampering, which is why they released the tape now because of the reports coming out about witness tampering.

That phone conversation helped Clemens, I think.

He had an ERA of 4 or higher in '93 and '95. His last year he 3.6 ERA, but 1.3 WHIP and 106 BB. He was breaking down

Or having an off-year. Supposedly, even when he stopped using...he still got better, if you believe McAmee.

Clemens repeatedly said "I want the truth to come out". How come McNamee never said "you know it's the truth" or "you know you did it"? Clemens still hasn't proved to me he didn't take steroids, but the conversation brought up good points for both Clemens and McNamee. Clemens knew he was being taped, so he wasn't as pissed. McNamee on the other hand swore multiple times and got angry.

There was a part in the conversation...near the beginning...where Roger tells McAmee "there's so much out there that's just untrue".....and if you listen for it, McAmee whispers "I know, I know."

The whole "tell me what you want me to do" smelled as if McAmee wanted Clemens to force him to do something. Remember, Clemens had his lawyers there holding him back from saying stuff, so not screw themselves over in court.

And..Clemens said he'll testify infront of Congress...and not use the "I cannot answer" reply everyone on ESPN said he was going to do.

[ChrisBaleBatman]

Awful advice. I've heard some people in the legal business on TV say he should have filed the suit Dec 14.

Maybe. But, I doubt the lawyer thought it'd be this big a **** storm. His lawyer, did say the blame is on himself and not Roger.

They are. Strict workouts don't get you 106 BB to 68 BB in one season.

C'mon, you have guys who have off seasons...where suddenly they're off they're game. Or, we'll have dudes that have a great year...and never get back on it. Injuries, that we don't know about could affect things. And the offense.

I think his workouts keep him in shape to perform, and not breakdown to pieces at his age.

He told the truth about Pettitte. Why does he lie about Roger?

Because Clemens is big fish. If you check the Mitchell Report, Clemens is the biggest one. Pettite is not a Hall Of Famer, and not a 7-time CY Young Award Winner. The Mitchell investigators had to know about Clemens and Pettite being friends, so it's not hard to imagine them pushing him toward there. I'm not saying they forced him to lie...but maybe they hinted at it. Investigators who hold a cookie over your head always want more, and I'm thinking they wanted more than just Andy.

If he had to lie to get out of jail, wouldn't he lie by saying Clemens DIDN'T take steroids? Clemens isn't going to begin this massive campaign to prove him wrong. It would be much easier for him to get away by lying that Clemens didn't take steroids than if he lied saying he did.

Dude...he cut a deal. He was facing jail time, and they came to him wanting information. He said he didn't know anything, and then they fell on him harder for information...letting him know he had a deal on the table.

If you think about it, he must have been desperate. He wanted to get out of jail time, and knew by telling the investigators what they WANT to hear would get him out.

[ChrisBaleBatman]

If he wasn't injury prone, and not had left New York for 3 or 4 years...he probably would be more recognizable.

There was point where he seemd like Griffey, breaking down some seasons.

[Matt]

Am I the only one who finds it disconcerning that there has yet to be an investigation as to why we were given false information to go to war and the people who championed this false information (Bush, Cheney, Rove, Rumsfeld, Powell, etc) have not been subpeona'ed to testify under oath, but major league baseball players are testifying about steroid use?

[ChrisBaleBatman]

Yes.

That's ****ing scary, how real and down to earth a statement that is.

[Addendum]

And I need something more conclusive before I say he cheated