TDKR Oscar Chances? - Part 1

[weezerspider]

Originally Posted by Anno_Domini

Imo, it is when the films simply haven't been seen to already say they can win just like that. Things can very well surprise you, or they may not even be in the running for Best Picture as well.

I'm not saying they are for sure, but I'm making an EDUCATED GUESS. A film written and directed by a guy who has been nominated TWICE for Best Director and Best film who the Academy seems to like seems to be a better educated guess and more possible outcome than a film in a genre the Academy has a bias against, and a director who, beloved and well received, has yet to receive much from the Academy. Same goes for a film in the same series that has won 17 Academy Awards and is directed by a Best Director and Best Picture winner.

I'm not saying The Hobbit and Django Unchained are DEFINITELY going to be better received by the Academy than TDKR. I'm simply making an EDUCATED GUESS on what the Academy most likely will think. Its ridiculous to see this is as silly. Is it silly to say The Patriots, with a three-time Super Bowl winning QB and coach has a better shot at winning the Super Bowl NEXT year than the Browns who suck this year even though no games have been played by the 2013 squads? NO, its an educated guess. TDKR isn't the Browns of the Academy Awards(though the Superhero genre might be), but the same concept can be applied. Also, I've personally seen the rest of those films on that list and while TDKR is my personal choice over a few of them, I think almost all of them are much more what the Academy looks for.

[CapedCrusader14]

Originally Posted by Kane52630

Nah, that award is going to Life of Pi. I'm fairly certain at this point.

Ugh, the trailer didn't make me very interested.

[Kane52630]

Well the movie was amazing, anyone who's seen it can back me up on this.

[kvz5]

Satellite Awards nominations:

http://www.indiewire.com/article/com...cleHeaderPanel

Visual Effects
STEVE BEGG, ARUNDI ASREGADOO, ANDREW WHITEHURST SKYFALL COLUMBIA PICTURES
RICHARD STAMMERS, CHARLEY HENLEY, MARTIN HILL PROMETHEUS TWENTIETH CENTURY FOX
BILL WESTENHOFER LIFE OF PI TWENTIETH CENTURY FOX
MICHAEL LANTIERI, KEVIN BAILLIE, RYAN TUDHOPE, JIM GIBBS FLIGHT PARAMOUNT PICTURES
DAN GLASS, GEOFFREY HANCOCK, STEPHANE CERETTI CLOUD ATLAS WARNER BROS.
CHRIS CORBOULD, PAUL FRANKLIN THE DARK KNIGHT RISES WARNER BROS.

Art Direction & Production Design
RICK CARTER, CURT BEECH, DAVID CRANK, LESLIE MCDONALD LINCOLN DREAMWORKS/TOUCHSTONE
NATHAN CROWLEY, KEVIN KAVANAUGH, JAMES HAMBIDGE, NAAMAN MARSHALL THE DARK KNIGHT RISES WARNER BROS.
NIELS SEJER A ROYAL AFFAIR MAGNOLIA PICTURES
DAVID CRANK, JACK FISK THE MASTER THE WEINSTEIN CO.
SARAH GREENWOOD, NIALL MORONEY, THOMAS BROWN, NICK GOTTSCHALK, TOM STILL ANNA KARENINA FOCUS FEATURES
EVE STEWART, ANNA LYNCH-ROBINSON LES MISÉRABLES UNIVERSAL

[jacobed]

I'd say it deserves visual effects. The award doesn't just go to the best cg which TDKR had amazing cg but it also includes live action stunts and I'd say that it easily had the best live action effects of the year

[redfirebird2008]

Originally Posted by kvz5

Satellite Awards nominations:

http://www.indiewire.com/article/com...cleHeaderPanel

Inception was nominated for 11 and won 3. TDK was nominated for 6 and won 1, although one of the nominations was a throwaway (Best Blu-ray Disc). That category doesn't even exist anymore.

[joker1524]

Well The Hobbit sure is getting mediocre reviews

[kvz5]

Guild Screening:

THURSDAY, DECEMBER 6, 2012 at 7:30PM
WRITERS GUILD THEATER
135 SOUTH DOHENY DRIVE
Parking available at the theater.

THE SCREENING WILL BE IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWED BY A DISCUSSION WITH:
DIRECTOR/CO-SCREENWRITER/PRODUCER
CHRISTOPHER NOLAN

THE FILM’S STAR
CHRISTIAN BALE

COMPOSER
HANS ZIMMER

[Macrotus]

^ I wonder if they're taping that Q&A, and if that is for the forthcoming Ultimate Collection?

[Dragon_316ca]

[Batman jr.]

Biggest chances imho:

-Music
-Cinematography
-Bale
-Caine
-Anne

[Batman jr.]

Originally Posted by weezerspider

I'm not saying they are for sure, but I'm making an EDUCATED GUESS. A film written and directed by a guy who has been nominated TWICE for Best Director and Best film who the Academy seems to like seems to be a better educated guess and more possible outcome than a film in a genre the Academy has a bias against, and a director who, beloved and well received, has yet to receive much from the Academy. Same goes for a film in the same series that has won 17 Academy Awards and is directed by a Best Director and Best Picture winner.

I'm not saying The Hobbit and Django Unchained are DEFINITELY going to be better received by the Academy than TDKR. I'm simply making an EDUCATED GUESS on what the Academy most likely will think. Its ridiculous to see this is as silly. Is it silly to say The Patriots, with a three-time Super Bowl winning QB and coach has a better shot at winning the Super Bowl NEXT year than the Browns who suck this year even though no games have been played by the 2013 squads? NO, its an educated guess. TDKR isn't the Browns of the Academy Awards(though the Superhero genre might be), but the same concept can be applied. Also, I've personally seen the rest of those films on that list and while TDKR is my personal choice over a few of them, I think almost all of them are much more what the Academy looks for.

Sometimes, no a lot of the time, the academy awards ARE not educated guesses.

I mean: Avatar gets nominated for best picture, Halle Berry, Hilary Swank & Gwyneth Paltrow have won oscars, but John Hurt & Gary Oldman haven't.

[kvz5]

Better quality of the Nolan FYC ad:

[Donut]

Originally Posted by kvz5

Better quality of the Nolan FYC ad:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JfUM5...834BD4AAFA4850

[Pfeiffer-Pfan]

If only they would consider... but we all know they won't.

[regwec]

Originally Posted by Batman jr.

Biggest chances imho:

-Music
-Cinematography
-Bale
-Caine
-Anne

I don't think it has any right to beat Skyfall on cinematography. Les Miserables will win music.

[Donut]

One award this movie can get is an Razzie Award. Worst death for Miranda. Lewis or whoever else they pick will win best actor. It wont be Bale

[BatLobsterRises]

Nolan really rocks the scruffy, yet dignified look, heh.

[JackWhite]

Originally Posted by Donut

One award this movie can get is an Razzie Award. Worst death for Miranda. Lewis or whoever else they pick will win best actor. It wont be Bale

I still liked her as Talia, but she didn't have enough time as Talia to really make an impact; besides her reveal which was done very well. But yeah, that death scene was just so awkward.

And after watching TDKR again last night, I still wish there was some way Bale could at least get a best actor nod for his performance. He won't, but dammit Bale, you were just absolutely brilliant in Rises!

[Tequilla]

Originally Posted by regwec

I don't think it has any right to beat Skyfall on cinematography. Les Miserables will win music.

I would say Killing Them Softly and The Master should be the real competition to TDKR (i still havent seen Life of Pi , but i believe it will be in the discussion). Altought Skyfall has some beautifull grading , most of the setups are as conservative as cinema gets. Deakins winning an award for a work like this , would seem very very strange. One of the greatest dps of all time should get recognition by great works , not simpler eye-popping image.

But...Avatar won this category once. So , every movie probably has the right to claim one.

[Fudgie]

Originally Posted by Donut

One award this movie can get is an Razzie Award. Worst death for Miranda. Lewis or whoever else they pick will win best actor. It wont be Bale

Heh last time a Nolan Batman movie was at the Razzies was for Katie Holmes as Rachel.

[I SEE SPIDEY]

This is the first time I really liked Bale in the role but I don't think it's good enough work to merit am oscar nom. I mean if the oscars didn't suck it wouldn't be good enough.

[Mr. Wooden Alligator]

It definitly merits consideration for Cinematography and the Visual Effects.

[Raoul Duke]

for best picture, director and screenplay? zero. it's a great, yet incredibly sloppy action film.

i think pfister may get some recognition for the cinematography though.

[I SEE SPIDEY]

Originally Posted by Raoul Duke

for best picture, director and screenplay? zero. it's a great, yet incredibly sloppy action film.

i think pfister may get some recognition for the cinematography though.

Honestly it wouldn't be the worst movie the Academy could nominate, I mean they nominated The BlindSide for goodness sake and Bullock actually won for her surface level performance.

If by some stroke of luck Rises got a nom it wouldn't come close to being the worst nominee ever.