Rank every comic book film - where do the Spider-Man films fit in?

[Picard Sisko]

This thread is to rank every comic book movie you have ever seen (or at least the ones you can think of as you are writing it). Put all the Spider-Man films in bold so they stand out. Here is my list:


1. Spider-Man 2 - 9.5
2. The Dark Knight - 9.5
3. The Avengers - 9.0
4. X2: X-Men United - 9.0
5. Spider-Man - 9.0
6. Iron Man - 9.0
7. Batman Begins - 8.5
8. X-Men: First Class - 8.5
9. Superman II - 8.5
10. The Amazing Spider-Man - 8.5
11. The Dark Knight Rises - 8.5
12. X-Men - 8.0
13. Hellboy - 8.0
14. The Incredible Hulk - 8.0
15. Kick-Ass - 8.0
16. Batman Returns - 7.5
17. Superman - 7.5
18. Captain America: The First Avenger - 7.5
19. Batman (1989) - 7.5
20. 300 - 7.0
21. Hellboy II - 7.0
22. V for Vendetta - 7.0
23. Thor - 7.0
24. Iron Man 2 - 6.5
25. Spider-Man 3 - 6.0
26. X-Men: The Last Stand - 6.0
27. Daredevil: The Director's - Cut 6.0
28. Hulk (2003) - 6.0
29. Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer - 5.5
30. X-Men Origins: Wolverine - 5.0
31. Fantastic Four - 5.0
32. Blade - 4.5
33. Superman Returns - 4.0
34. The Fantastic Four (1994) - 4.0
35. Catwoman - 4.0
36. Ghost Rider - 4.0
37. Blade: Trinity - 3.5
38. The Punisher - 3.5
39. Sin City - 3.5
40. Batman Forever - 3.5
41. Ghost Rider: The Spirit of Vengeance - 3.0
42. Elektra - 3.0
43. Superman III - 3.0
44. Captain America (1990) - 3.0
45. The Amazing Spider-Man (1977) - 3.0
46. Batman and Robin - 2.5
47. The Punisher: War Zone - 2.5
48. The Punisher (1989) - 2.0
49. Return of the Incredible Hulk - 2.0
50. Superman IV 1.0 51 Supergirl - 1.0

[Spiderdevil]

The Dark Knight
Spider-man 2
The Avengers
Spider-man 1
Iron Man
X-Men-Fist Class

[Picard Sisko]

In the poll, I meant to ask what are your favorite comic book film(s) of all time... but oh well lol

[TheSpectacular]

THE BEST OF THE BEST

The Dark Knight- 9.5/10
The Amazing Spider-Man- 9.5/10
The Avengers-9.5/10
Captain America: The First Avenger- 9.5/10
Spider-Man 2- 9.5/10
X-Men: First Class- 9/10

REALLY GOOD

Thor- 8.5/10
Batman Begins- 8.5/10
The Incredible Hulk- 8/10
Spider-Man- 8/10

ALRIGHT

X2: X-Men United- 7.5/10
Spider-Man 3- 7/10
X-Men: The Last Stand- 6/10
Daredevil- 6/10

THE CHASM OF DESPAIR

Fantastic Four- 5/10
X-Men- 5/10
Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer- 4.5/10
Green Lantern- 4/10

FARTHER INTO THE CHASM OF DESPAIR

The Dark Knight Rises- 3/10
X-Men Origins: Wolverine- 3/10
Iron Man- 3/10

THE UNREACHABLE DEPTHS OF THE CHASM OF DESPAIR

Iron Man 2- 1/10

[Picard Sisko]

I'm surprised nobody else picked Spider-Man 2 as one of their choices.

[Anno_Domini]

This is going to be great in a Spider-Man thread

[spider-neil]

1. TDK trilogy* (I know, it's cheating)
2. SM2
3. X:FC
4. IM
5. X2
6. ASM
7. SM
8. S:TM
9. Blade 2
10. Dredd 3D

If I'm not allowed to cheat,
1. TDKR
2. TDK
BB wouldn't figure in my top 10

[ThePhantasm]

1. Batman: Mask of the Phantasm (10)
2. Batman Begins (9.5)
3. The Dark Knight (9.5)
4. Batman (1989) (9.5)
5. Spider-Man 2 (9.0)
6. The Dark Knight Rises (9.0)
7. X2 (9.0)
8. X-Men: First Class (9.0)
9. The Avengers (8.0)
10. Spider-Man (8.0)
11. Superman Returns (8.0)
12. Superman The Movie (7.5)
13. Superman II (7.5)
14. The Shadow (7.0)

After that... eh they all start running together...

[Picard Sisko]

Originally Posted by Anno_Domini

This is going to be great in a Spider-Man thread

i knew YOU would love it, Anno.

[Spiderdevil]

Anno's top 5 will all be batman movies,followed by watchmen

[Oscorp]

Originally Posted by Spiderdevil

Anno's top 5 will all be batman movies,followed by watchmen

Because those are his favourites, nothing strange about that.

I didn't realise I could vote for more than one film. My list use to be different because I keep changing my mind. Though the top 3-4 should be pretty stable from now on I think. Anyway, here's my list at this moment:

1) The Dark Knight
2) The Amazing Spider-Man
3-4) The Dark Knight Rises / Batman Begins (tie)
5) The Avengers
6) Iron Man
7) Captain America
8-9) Spider-Man / Spider-Man 2 (tie)
10) X2 / X-Men: First Class (tie)


Spider-Man 3 - somewhere far below, though definitely not Ghost Rider bad.

[Climperoonie]

I can do top ten, don't think I can remember all of the comic book films I've seen off the top of my head.

1. The Amazing Spider-Man
2. The Dark Knight Rises
3. X-Men: First Class
4. The Avengers
5. Batman Begins
6. Iron Man
7. Captain America: The First Avenger
8. Kick-Ass
9. V For Vendetta
10. X2

So yeah, TASM is the only Spider-Man film which makes my top ten, although it does top it.

[Picard Sisko]

Originally Posted by Oscorp

Because those are his favourites, nothing strange about that.

I didn't realise I could vote for more than one film. My list use to be different because I keep changing my mind. Though the top 3-4 should be pretty stable from now on I think. Anyway, here's my list at this moment:

1) The Dark Knight
2) The Amazing Spider-Man
3-4) The Dark Knight Rises / Batman Begins (tie)
5) The Avengers
6) Iron Man
7) Captain America
8-9) Spider-Man / Spider-Man 2 (tie)
10) X2 / X-Men: First Class (tie)


Spider-Man 3 - somewhere far below, though definitely not Ghost Rider bad.

I wish you could vote over again. Oh well.

I watched the Dark Knight again, and although it is a spectacular film, I don't think it has as much re-watch value as I thought. I think that goes with any film though, but if I'm not in the mood, I just can't watch it. Spider-Man 2 I can easily watch, especially since it explores several generes: action/adventure, drama, romance, comedy, and even some horror. TDK is the better "film," but I think Spider-Man 2 is the better "comic book movie."

BTW thanks for sharing your lists and voting, guys!

[Joe]

Refer to siggy.

[Picard Sisko]

Originally Posted by Joe

Refer to siggy.

[AF3619]

Originally Posted by Picard Sisko

what is siggy?

[Picard Sisko]

Originally Posted by AF3619

what is siggy?

He means his signature.

[AF3619]

Originally Posted by Picard Sisko

He means his signature.

thanks

[hopefuldreamer]

I'll just do my top 20:

1. Watchmen
2. The Dark Knight Rises
3. Batman Begins
4. The Dark Knight
5. 300
6. The Amazing Spiderman
7. Spiderman 2
8. Spiderman
9. Thor
10. X-Men
11. X-Men: First Class
12. Batman 89
13. Superman 2
14. Superman: The Movie
14. Captain America: The First Avenger
15. Iron Man
16. X-Men 2
17. Sin City
18. Daredevil
19. Blade
20. Fantastic 4

[Anno_Domini]

Originally Posted by Picard Sisko

i knew YOU would love it, Anno.

You're right. I love polls asking a favorite CBM in a thread specified to one particular character. It's not like we don't have actual areas talking about all CBMs in general where you could place this poll, oh wait...

true, there hasn't been any flame wars yet, but I suspect there could be in time.

Originally Posted by Oscorp

Because those are his favourites, nothing strange about that.

This.

Although, I wouldn't exactly place Batman Begins in the top five if I bring up ratings into the picture.

The Dark Knight Rises - 10/10
The Avengers - 10/10
The Dark Knight - 9/10
Watchmen(Ultimate Cut) - 9/10
Spider-Man 2 - 9/10

[GENERAL RAAM582]

1.) The Dark Knight
2.) The Avengers
3.) Watchmen
4.) The Dark Knight Rises
5.) Spider-Man 2
6.) Batman Begins
7.) Iron Man
8.) The Amazing Spider-Man
9.) Captain America
10.) X-Men 2
11.) Spider-Man
12.) Batman
13.) The Incredible Hulk
14.) Iron Man 2
15.) Thor

[Anno_Domini]

Edit

[Anno_Domini]

Wait, we could vote for more than one?

[Picard Sisko]

Originally Posted by Anno_Domini

Wait, we could vote for more than one?

Yeah.

[Picard Sisko]

Originally Posted by Anno_Domini

You're right. I love polls asking a favorite CBM in a thread specified to one particular character. It's not like we don't have actual areas talking about all CBMs in general where you could place this poll, oh wait...

I wanted to see the CBM rankings from the perspective of Spider-Man fans. I am aware of the other threads for CBMs in general.