The SuperHeroHype Forums  

Go Back   The SuperHeroHype Forums > Captain America > Captain America: Civil War

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 09-29-2016, 03:47 PM   #26
auditor
Side-Kick
 
Join Date: Nov 2013
Posts: 351
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

That was not a criticism of the movie though. Iron Man isn't supposed to be enlightened like superman. In a future movie Iron Man can right his wrong and forgive Bucky, and then ask for forgiveness for himself for trying to kill Bucky.

auditor is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-29-2016, 07:39 PM   #27
harryoscop
Banned User
 
Join Date: May 2014
Location: Norman Osborn's basement
Posts: 25,496
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Quote:
Originally Posted by Flint Marko View Post
"Blackmail" is when you demand money or property from someone in return for not revealing compromising or injurious information about that person. That didn't happen in any form. Tony's exact quote is:

"Might be dangerous, but I'm going to tell Aunt hottie that you're going on a field trip...."

Please explain to me how that's blackmail. Tony never mentions anything about revealing his secret identity or anything malicious to Aunt May, just that he's going on a field trip.

If you have problems with the character's inclusion then that's fine, but this is not a valid one. To keep insisting that Tony "blackmailed" Peter is looking for problems where there aren't any.

In regards to putting Peter in danger... remember how he singlehandedly took down Falcon and Winter Soldier, went toe-to-toe with Cap, and figured out how to take down Giant-man? Clearly Tony knew he could hold his own in what was a glorified wrestling match ("my plan was to go easy on them", "do what we discussed, web them up"), and he made the right call.
He demanded Peter come to Germany with him or he tell Aunt May he's Spider-Man. That's the definition of blackmail: Forcing an individual to do something for you in exchange of you not releasing/revealing damaging information. Why do you think Peter said "Don't tell Aunt May"?? Peter didn't even want to go to Germany hence "I can't go to Germany!" "I got homework..."

harryoscop is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-29-2016, 09:02 PM   #28
Flint Marko
Bring me Thanos
 
Flint Marko's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 15,298
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Quote:
Originally Posted by harryoscop View Post
He demanded Peter come to Germany with him or he tell Aunt May he's Spider-Man. That's the definition of blackmail: Forcing an individual to do something for you in exchange of you not releasing/revealing damaging information. Why do you think Peter said "Don't tell Aunt May"?? Peter didn't even want to go to Germany hence "I can't go to Germany!" "I got homework..."
Nope. He didn't demand that Peter go to Germany, nor did he say he was going to tell Aunt May that Pete was Spider-man. He just said he was going to tell her "that he's going on a field trip". Try again.

__________________
Quote:
"Kevin Fiege built this in a cave! With a box of scraps!."
Flint Marko is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-29-2016, 09:40 PM   #29
Doctor Octopus
Banned User
 
Doctor Octopus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 4,422
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Quote:
Originally Posted by Flint Marko View Post
Nope. He didn't demand that Peter go to Germany, nor did he say he was going to tell Aunt May that Pete was Spider-man. He just said he was going to tell her "that he's going on a field trip". Try again.
Agreed. It also not seriously done since Peter web his hand to door and Tony smile. It all light hearted.

Doctor Octopus is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-29-2016, 09:41 PM   #30
harryoscop
Banned User
 
Join Date: May 2014
Location: Norman Osborn's basement
Posts: 25,496
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Quote:
Originally Posted by Flint Marko View Post
Nope. He didn't demand that Peter go to Germany, nor did he say he was going to tell Aunt May that Pete was Spider-man. He just said he was going to tell her "that he's going on a field trip". Try again.
Except the movie clearly illustrates that was Stark's intent with Peter's "Don't tell Aunt May". Try again (after I finish my Homework. )

harryoscop is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-29-2016, 10:14 PM   #31
MyDudeSpidey
Marvel's
 
MyDudeSpidey's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Somewhere you're not
Posts: 3,564
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Quote:
Originally Posted by harryoscop View Post
Except the movie clearly illustrates that was Stark's intent with Peter's "Don't tell Aunt May". Try again (after I finish my Homework. )
I think the "Don't tell Aunt May" was in regards to Tony taking him to Germany, not that he was going to reveal his secret identity to her.

__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kevin Feige
Now we better not screw it up.
MyDudeSpidey is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-29-2016, 11:45 PM   #32
harryoscop
Banned User
 
Join Date: May 2014
Location: Norman Osborn's basement
Posts: 25,496
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Quote:
Originally Posted by MyDudeSpidey View Post
I think the "Don't tell Aunt May" was in regards to Tony taking him to Germany, not that he was going to reveal his secret identity to her.
Hmm, good point...?

harryoscop is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-30-2016, 01:08 PM   #33
Doctor Octopus
Banned User
 
Doctor Octopus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 4,422
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

No blackmail there.

Doctor Octopus is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-05-2016, 08:14 PM   #34
frostanon
Side-Kick
 
Join Date: Jan 2016
Posts: 37
Thumbs up Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Quote:
Originally Posted by ThePhantasm View Post
everybody says the MCU doesn't have great villains, but Tony is one of the greatest comic book movie villains of all time
This.

frostanon is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-10-2016, 08:33 AM   #35
3dman27
super-hero wannabe
 
3dman27's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: in the middle of a superhero adventure
Posts: 40,434
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Spider-man had a point about somebody in the wrong thinking he's doing good

__________________
to me superheroes are to americans what the myths of the greeks and romans are to them[deemar 325]
avatar by philly phanboy and drakon
3dman27 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-11-2016, 05:48 PM   #36
metaphysician
Not a Side-Kick
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Posts: 11,233
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Quote:
Originally Posted by 3dman27 View Post
Spider-man had a point about somebody in the wrong thinking he's doing good
Yep. He just was talking to the wrong guy about it.

metaphysician is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-12-2016, 12:33 PM   #37
Pink Ranger
Happy Mothers' Day
 
Pink Ranger's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Toronto, Ontario
Posts: 32,906
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Tony Stark is a vain narcissist with an addictive personality. Therefore, when he tries to redeem himself, he assumes a position of moral superiority and everyone has to follow him down the rabbit hole, whether it's his best friend, an American hero or a teenage boy from Queens.

__________________
Mandroid. Mercenary. Scientist. Ninja. Each one a specialist. Together they are ...

ELIMINATORS!
Coming January 31, 1986, to VHS and video CD
Pink Ranger is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-18-2016, 06:42 AM   #38
ARA
Side-Kick
 
Join Date: Sep 2014
Posts: 36
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

The movie hardly acknowledges Tony's mistakes. Like, you'd think that him building Ultron would be a way bigger deal. But no, no one aside from him cares.

ARA is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-18-2016, 06:40 PM   #39
metaphysician
Not a Side-Kick
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Posts: 11,233
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Well, it kind of makes sense. All the Avengers already know who Tony is, and what his flaws are. They've kind of accepted that Tony is Tony. Its Tony who is the one with the neurotic megalomania that leads him to obsessively overcorrecting.

metaphysician is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-20-2016, 01:14 PM   #40
BullMcGiveny
Probably Disagree
 
BullMcGiveny's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2012
Posts: 2,940
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Did the UN accept that Tony is Tony, too?

BullMcGiveny is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-20-2016, 05:23 PM   #41
metaphysician
Not a Side-Kick
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Posts: 11,233
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

I suspect they are suffering from almost as much "make a bad solution to a problem out of irrationality" as Tony is. Which is to say, somebody sold them on the idea of "All our panicky fears would be fixed if we just controlled the Avengers", and they haven't been forced to admit that this solves absolutely nothing and largely just makes things worse.

metaphysician is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-21-2016, 04:34 AM   #42
BullMcGiveny
Probably Disagree
 
BullMcGiveny's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2012
Posts: 2,940
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Eh, that doesn't really explain it.

You'd expect someone to have more questions about where Ultron came from.

BullMcGiveny is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-06-2017, 07:44 AM   #43
Steamteck
Side-Kick
 
Steamteck's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts: 1,362
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Quote:
Originally Posted by auditor View Post
That was not a criticism of the movie though. Iron Man isn't supposed to be enlightened like superman. In a future movie Iron Man can right his wrong and forgive Bucky, and then ask for forgiveness for himself for trying to kill Bucky.

I also hope we get to see him hand Cap back his shield.

__________________
It isn't that there are too many idiots in the world, its the lightning is improperly distributed
Mark Twain
Steamteck is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-30-2017, 02:38 PM   #44
Ceies
Newbie
 
Join Date: Mar 2017
Posts: 14
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Is it really an issue, that Tony brought in Spiderman who's a minor? I mean sure, it's not exactly the right thing to do, but then again he gave Peter specific orders to keep his distance and use his webbs. Plus despite Spidey beng reluctant to join him, noone can argue that he wasn't enthusiastic about it, so 'blackmailing' is not really the word to put it.
Plus it really wasn't supposed to be an actual fight. Those were friends, and Tony didn't really expect it to get so much over board. You can pretty much see it in the mood of the fight. If anyone, Captains team goes way over board, something Tony couldn't have expected and even Cap didn't really see coming. I'm not even talking about Rhodey, cause that was an accident, but... well Ant-Man's fuel truck could have gone pretty wrong and Cap and Ant-Man just brushed it off with a little joke and a raised eye brow. Ant-Man pulling the wires out of Tony's suit in midflight could have gone all kinds of wrong, and the only person who actually wanted to make this a serious fight was Wanda (who actually told other characters to get more serious and don't pull their punshes). Even Black Panther, while being all serious and out for revenge only really went for Bucky...

And in the end it was Cap who - knowing that Spidey's quite young - dumped that container on him. So... yeah...

To me it looks hypocritical to look at Tony bringing in a minor and call this child endangerment, irredeemable, or I don't know 'Tony screwing up again', while it at best is maybe a bit irresponsible, especially considering Spider-mans skill set and orders, while not even looking at Cap throwing and igniting a fuel truck into a friends face and only raisng an eyebrow in astonishment, when the whole thing blows up. It was quite lucky that T'Challa and Widow jumped out in time... So how is Tony being the bad guy and Cap the good here. Either we accept that both didn't really expect a serious fight and it went way over board... or we have to hold them equally responsible for their screw ups...

Ceies is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-30-2017, 06:04 PM   #45
metaphysician
Not a Side-Kick
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Posts: 11,233
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Pretty much. To the extent Tony deserves the blame for the fight, he deserves it not because he brought Peter to it. He deserves it because the fight shouldn't have happened in the first place, because he shouldn't have submitted to Ross' authority in the first place. That doesn't change if he happens to not recruit a minor.

metaphysician is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-01-2017, 02:22 AM   #46
Ceies
Newbie
 
Join Date: Mar 2017
Posts: 14
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

So... it would have been better, had Ross sent his UN-Forces to kill Cap and Bucky as he originally planned? Making this a quarrel within the Avengers was definitally the better outcome than having a bunch of superheroes fight UN-Forces on an airport where they have no business to be, to steal a plane, to help their wanted fugitive friend escape custody. I'm imagining this statement to the public...

Tony wasn't given much a choice here. Had Cap sent Bucky back to custody, asked Tony for help and gone to Siberia with the Avengers instead of only Bucky, that would have been preferable. It takes two for a fight, so why's it all on Tony, when Tony's the one who was literally given the choice: Bring them in alive, or we'll bring him in dead (and since we can't really defeat him, probably send hundred soldiers to their doom).

Cap had just as many chances (if not more, since he wasn't blackmailed) than Tony to not fight him, yet somehow it's all Tony's fault that they ended up fighting.

Ceies is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-01-2017, 03:15 AM   #47
dax
Side-Kick
 
Join Date: May 2014
Posts: 502
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Cap didn't force Tony to fight him at all. He knew that Tony wouldn't listen to him even when he told him that Zemo was behind the UN bombing and is about to awaken multiple Winter Soldiers in Siberia because typical Tony thinks he knows better than Cap. Cap also knew that Team Iron Man won't allow him or his team to leave so they could stop Zemo from releasing the Winter Soldiers so yes, it's Tony's fault that the Avengers are now fighting each other because he signed the Accords out of guilt and convinced a few others to do the same.

dax is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-01-2017, 04:20 AM   #48
Ceies
Newbie
 
Join Date: Mar 2017
Posts: 14
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

@dax yet Tony proves you wrong, cause apperently, since he actually managed to find evidence to clear Bucky and arrived in Siberia to help only shortly after Cap and Bucky arrived there. Despite first having to ask Falcon for the way. (Kinda unbelievable, but that's what happened, isn't it?)
And Cap actually didn't know that. Cap's initial reaction was: Let's call Tony and tell him!
But Falcon didn't want that. So Cap let Falcon talk himself out of calling Tony. But they KNEW that they'd meet Tony eventually, whether they called him or not. That's why they got the team, because they knew, Tony was going to stand in their way. But instead of even trying to prevent that, or trying to talk to Tony, he just ran straight into him.

And I really don't see, why Rhodes signing (who believed in the accords even after he got hurt) or Widow signing, who does her own thing most of the time, or T'Challa's father dying speaking in favor of the accords, is suddenly all Tony's fault.
Tony had a whole bunch of reasons to sign them, and he even told them to Cap, yet Fan's always narrow it down to 'he feels guilty.' Well at least he feels guilty... Can't say the same for Cap after Lagos. Or any time, really... Because yeah, Ultron might have been mostly Tony's screw up. But Lagos was on the whole Team, Hulk and Iron Man fighting in Avengers 2 was on Scarlet Witch and the whole Team...
And wrecking that Police Corp to save Bucky was on Cap... Principle of minimum force?
But, yeah... Tony was a bit guilty, that's part of why he signed, but not all of it.
there's also:
- he believes in the Accords. He thinks they are the right thing.
- government delegates of 100+ nations, the general public, the media and families of past victims demanded accountability and oversight and some sort of consequences
- they weren't really given a choice. Yeah, Tony actually said that if they didn't sign something worse would come
- they could apparently be amended later on.
Tony basically wanted to meet the UN halfway... Cap didn't want to compromise... which would have been okay, had he not been under time pressure.

But Widow and Rhodes signed for their own reasons. And T'Challas father was actually among the most outspoken supporters of the accords. So blaming Tony for the accords is just childish. And blaming a political discrapency for losing friendships even more so. Politics are to each their own. For Cap to stop trusting Tony and thinking he'd sell them out, just because they disagreed on a political debate (albeit an important debate to their personal lives) is childish.
Especially when the debate is so new and he hardly had time to even think about it, let alone read the papers. As much as Tony acted out of guilt, Cap acted because his dead love told him to plant himself like a tree once.
And then surprise... Tony gets one single hint, that Cap might actually be right with Bucky being innocent and he btrays his political believes to come help a friend. Who would have guessed that would happen? Pretty much everyone who knows Tony, because Tony tends to be a loyal friend. And he also tends to place his own selfish desires (and protecting a friend is a selfish desire - hello Cap) above the law.

The whole incident came at a very bad timing. Cap didn't want to sign, because he had a bunch of issues with them, which was okay... But what should he have done? Bide his time and wait for those issues to be resolved. With Tony, Widow, Vision and Rhodey there were enough people on the 'UN-governed Avengers team' To just look for a while how it worked and make his decision later on. Noone would have been able to force him to sign, and as long as he didn't break the Accords. Then Bucky happened and Cap instead of doing what he should have done: either calling Tony or Vision to help out (apparently Rhodey got clearance to interfere later on), or if he had to do it himself, make Bucky surrender to the officials himself, instead of helping him escape, beating down the police and wrecking a tunnel.
Then he got arrested, and suddenly he had given the officials everything to put him under preassure. That's not on Tony, that's entirely on him.
Just like later, when he refuses to sign again and instead escapes custody he's now a wanted fugitive himself.... So Kudos to him, but that's not on Tony either. And again there was a way to deescalate the situation: Bringing Bucky back into custody. Or at least call Tony to deal with the Winter Soldiers and not do anything for a while. And way to escalate it: Taking matters into his own hands. And again, the savest hands are our own, so instead of letting the thing be solved by a team of UN-approved Avengers that would have been entirely capable of dealing with the problem - he decides he wants to do it himself.
Meanwhile Tony has to literally beg Ross not to send a killing commando after Bucky. But Tony's untrustworthy, so nobody calls him to tell him what's really going on.
And in the end, Bucky and Cap alone... (yeah, as if they'd have a chance against five winter soldiers who Bucky said were even stronger than him) get away... And look who appears to help a little later...

What happens after that, is a different matter, because at that point it gets personal and stops being political.

The thing is... Tony most of the film was only reacting to things going on around him. It's a Captain America film, because not only does the plot continue from Winter Soldier, but most of all, Cap is the driving force, next to the bad guy, Zemo. The films action gets mostly driven by Cap and Zemo. The only time Tony's actions gets actually relevant to the plot, is when he decides to help his friend out in Siberia.

Before that, yeah, he was in favor of the accords. But the accords were mostly driven by politicians like T'Challas father, or Ross. They'd have happened anyway. the UN-Bombing would have happened, Cap would have gone to Bucharest. Bucky, Cap, Falcon, Black Panther and the Police would have destroyed the city a little more and fought a little longer, because maybe no Rhodey to come in and stop them. But in the end Cap and Falcon would still have surrendered to the officials, Bucky too... Because they are not actually bad guys, are they. Zemo would have come in and activate the Winter Soldier programming, Cap and Falcon would escape custody, to find out about the Sibrian Winter soldiers. At this point had Tony not been with the Accords they would have probably called him for help who knows, so maybe the plot would have changed there. But let's assume they wouldn't (because they didn't call him in Captain America Winter Soldier either, despite the main problem literally being a computerprogram), and then at the airport, instead of meating a bunch of old friends who start with a little talking and bickering and don't really want to hurt each other, they would have found UN-forces with killing orders. That would be the only difference to the plot, had Tony not been pro-Accords...

It's a Captain America film. He's the driving force. He's the one who decides to get involved with Bucky - because he is his friend. He's the one who decides not to bring Bucky back into custody, after he escapes. He's the one who decides not to confide in Tony, when he should have. He's the one to go to Siberia. Tony most of the film runs behind him and tries to stop Ross from actually shooting Cap, or putting him in a prison.


Last edited by Ceies; 04-01-2017 at 04:30 AM.
Ceies is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-01-2017, 04:22 AM   #49
Capsfan
Banned User
 
Join Date: Dec 2016
Posts: 571
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Tony didn't listen because Bucky killed many innocent people in Berlin which Tony saw himself and had no clue whatsoever about triggers. And after that Cap escaped with him without any word to Tony or Natasha. Why the heck Tony is supposed to believe Cap after all this? After Bucky shooting him in the face? So, while I agree that Tony was responsible, I fail to see how it was only his fault alone.

Capsfan is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-01-2017, 04:35 AM   #50
Capsfan
Banned User
 
Join Date: Dec 2016
Posts: 571
Default Re: i thought Tony was trying to REEDEEM his mistakes

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ceies View Post
So... it would have been better, had Ross sent his UN-Forces to kill Cap and Bucky as he originally planned? Making this a quarrel within the Avengers was definitally the better outcome than having a bunch of superheroes fight UN-Forces on an airport where they have no business to be, to steal a plane, to help their wanted fugitive friend escape custody. I'm imagining this statement to the public...

Tony wasn't given much a choice here. Had Cap sent Bucky back to custody, asked Tony for help and gone to Siberia with the Avengers instead of only Bucky, that would have been preferable. It takes two for a fight, so why's it all on Tony, when Tony's the one who was literally given the choice: Bring them in alive, or we'll bring him in dead (and since we can't really defeat him, probably send hundred soldiers to their doom).

Cap had just as many chances (if not more, since he wasn't blackmailed) than Tony to not fight him, yet somehow it's all Tony's fault that they ended up fighting.
Completely agree. While I'm a huge fan of Cap, I really don't like when people try to say it was all Tony's fault. I don't need Cap to be this flawless ideal to love him. In fact, I love him the most in CW, where he makes mistakes and acts a little selfish as every over human being. It's a very interesting side of him and it helps dimensionalising the character.

Capsfan is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:18 AM.

monitoring_string = "dee460792f24517621e3ca080805de7e"



Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SuperHeroHype.com is a property of Mandatory Media, LLC, an Evolve Media, LLC company. ©2018 All Rights Reserved.