Spider-Man Elimination Game Suggestion Box

[Themanofbat]

Hello,

Since many of you are familiar with Quentin Beck's Spider-Man Elimination Game, and since he's always asking for suggestions for a new round, I figured a Suggestion Box Thread might be a good idea.

Here are the previous games done...

Round 1: Villains
Round 2: Grade B Villains
Round 3: Goblins
Round 4: Peter's Family and Friends
Round 5: Villains named after Animals
Round 6: Villain Teams
Round 7: Allies
Round 8: Allies Part 2
Round 9: Story Arcs
Round 10: Costumes
Round 11: The Final. All top 10 winners battle off.
Round 12: Doesn't exist... never happened... either deleted by mods or the game was never played.
Round's 13 to 16 were just random villains and characters.
Round 17: Writers
Round 18: Clones
Round 19: Best Single Story Issue
Round 20: C Listed Supporting Characters
Round 21: Best deaths
Round 22: Best gadgets
Round 23: Best Spidey Artists Round 1
Round 24: Best Spidey Artists Round 2
Round 25: Best Alternate Spideys
Round 26: Lamest Joke Character
Round 27: Best Spider-Man Centenial Issue
Round 28: Best Stan Lee story arc
Round 29: Best Spider-Man One Shot
Round 30: Best Spidey Video game
Round 31: Best Member of the Sinister Six/Seven
Round 32: Best Spider-Man '67 episode Season One
Round 33: Best Spider-Man '67 episode Seasons 2 & 3
Round 34: Best Spider-Man & his Amazing Friends episode Season One
Round 35: Best Spider-Man & his Amazing Friends episode Seasons 2 & 3
Round 36: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season One
Round 37: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season Two
Round 38: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season Three
Round 39: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season Four
Round 40: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season Five
Round 41: Best Character introduced in Untold Tales of Spider-Man
Round 42: Best Spooky Character Spider-Man Team-Up
Round 43: Best Spider-Man 1 Movie Scene
Round 44: Best Spider-Man 2 Movie Scene
Round 45: Best Spider-Man 3 Movie Scene
Round 46: Best Villain for Spider-Man 4
Round 47: Best Secondary Spider-Man Comic Title
Round 48: Best Steve Ditko ASM Cover
Round 49: Best Jazzin' Johnny Romita Sr. ASM Cover


Feel free to toss in your own ideas or modify any ones that are in here.

Cheers...

[Norman Osborn]

Have we ever done a "Women in Parker's Life" game?...we must have?

Gwen Stacy
MJ Watson
Aunt May
Spider-Woman
Betty Brant
Gloria Grant
Debra Whitman
May Parker (Daughter...no one ever said this was strcitly an ASM game)
Jean DeWolfe
Jessica Carradine (sp?)

[Red]

I wish someone would make me a suggestion box for the Superman Elimination Game

[Kraven]

I liked Mister J's idea a few Elimination games back, I think it was artists, that sounded cool.

[Themanofbat]

Originally Posted by tom123

I liked Mister J's idea a few Elimination games back, I think it was artists, that sounded cool.

Here would be the list to use, and you can't include Romita Sr nor Ditko, because it would just be a battle of those two.

1. Keith Pollard
2. Ron Frenz
3. Todd MacFarlane
4. Eric Larsen
5. Marc Bagley
6. John Romita Jr.
7. Ross Andru
8. John Byrne
9. Mike Deodato
10. Mark Texiera

[Themanofbat]

bump.

[Quentin Beck]

Wow thanks for making the thread manofbat! and no we haven't had a woman in peter's life elimination game yet. So I probably do the C list character round next and then the woman in peter's life. Thanks for the suggestions you guys!

[Red]

Artist, should be the next round as suggested above.

[Norman Osborn]

Just another that popped into my head...The "Death Becomes them" elimination game....the best written deaths

Gwen Stacy ASM 121
Harry Osborn SSM 200
Aunt May ASM 400
Doc Ock ASM 398?
Uncle Ben AF 15 (May want to consider "not" using this one for obvious reasons)
Norman Osborn ASM 122
Spiderman FNSM 3
Carnage New Avengers 2
George Stacy ASM 90

[Themanofbat]

Originally Posted by WhatIfTales

Just another that popped into my head...The "Death Becomes them" elimination game....the best written deaths

Gwen Stacy ASM 121
Harry Osborn SSM 200
Aunt May ASM 400
Doc Ock ASM 398?
Uncle Ben AF 15 (May want to consider "not" using this one for obvious reasons)
Norman Osborn ASM 122
Spiderman FNSM 3
Carnage New Avengers 2
George Stacy ASM 90

Great idea, but I'd drop Gwen from the list because she's the obvious winner.

Maybe add Ned Leeds in the Spidey/Wolverine One-Shot...

And also add Kraven the Hunter in ASM #295.

[Norman Osborn]

Originally Posted by Themanofbat

Great idea, but I'd drop Gwen from the list because she's the obvious winner.

Gwen obious over Uncle Ben and Cap'n Stacy?.....maybe....

.....I think..*looks around for Symbiotica....can't be found* Carnage'll win

[Symbiotica]

* * *

[Themanofbat]

Originally Posted by WhatIfTales

Gwen obious over Uncle Ben and Cap'n Stacy?.....maybe....

Well, I wouldn't include Uncle Ben's death for the same reason, even Captain Stacy's (maybe)

I would also include Ben Reilley & Nathan Lubensky (who died trying to save May from the Vulture).

[Norman Osborn]

Originally Posted by Symbiotica

.... You honestly think I would vote for Carnage's "death" in Nude Avengers issue 2 to be one of the all-time best/most meaningful deaths in the Spider-verse?

You would be most sadly mistaken, I fear.

In fact I would flip that around and suggest an "All-Time WORST deaths" poll. God knows there's enough to pick from.

Lol,..I was being sarcastic .....Carnage's entry in this game is what I like to call the "whipping boy" entrant.......that entrant that everyone attacks immediately....to warm the game up.....not unlike "Other" being part of the "Greatest arc" game and "JMS" being part of the "Writers" game....

[Themanofbat]

So as far as a "Best Death" contest, we'd have ...

Kraven the Hunter ASM #295
Harry Osborn SSM #200
Aunt May ASM #400
Nathan Lubensky ASM #336
Norman Osborn ASM #122
Spiderman FNSM #3
Carnage New Avengers #2
Ben Reilley PPSM #75
Ned Leeds SM/WOL One Shot
Alison Mongrain ASM #441

[Norman Osborn]

Originally Posted by Themanofbat

So as far as a "Best Death" contest, we'd have ...

Kraven the Hunter ASM #295

I can't freaking believe I forgot KRAVEN!!...I'm such a tool ...and I agree, the Stacy's deaths are too iconic to be included...list looks good now

[Themanofbat]

Originally Posted by WhatIfTales

I can't freaking believe I forgot KRAVEN!!...I'm such a tool ...and I agree, the Stacy's deaths are too iconic to be included...list looks good now

I'm sure we could nail a coupel more token Spidey deaths...

Didn't Madam Web die in the Gathering of the Five story?



Actually, it was Alison Mongrain who died in issue #441.

I just checked.

[Norman Osborn]

Originally Posted by Themanofbat

I'm sure we could nail a coupel more token Spidey deaths...

Didn't Madam Web die in the Gathering of the Five story?

Hmmm... I know she became young again...and maybe even contacted Matte Franklin/SpiderGirl afterwards...can't remember if she died though......

...isn't Mysterio dead?

[Themanofbat]

Originally Posted by WhatIfTales

Hmmm... I know she became young again...and maybe even contacted Matte Franklin/SpiderGirl afterwards...can't remember if she died though......

...isn't Mysterio dead?

That's hard to tell... apparantly, there's two Mysterio's running around the Marvel Universe these days...

[Norman Osborn]

Originally Posted by Themanofbat

That's hard to tell... apparantly, there's two Mysterio's running around the Marvel Universe these days...

Are you counting the "psychic" guy from "The Evil that Men do?" as one of the Mysterios?.....to me he's just a wannabe that bought a suit from KingPin

[Kraven]

Originally Posted by WhatIfTales

Are you counting the "psychic" guy from "The Evil that Men do?" as one of the Mysterios?.....to me he's just a wannabe that bought a suit from KingPin

The original shot himself and died, but the second one from way back in the 100's came back in the relaunch, but has gone into limbo.

[Themanofbat]

Someone should put a list of the previous 19 Spidey Games so that I can put them in the first post.

That way, we don't see repetetive lists.

[Quentin Beck]

Ok themanofbat here they are:

Round 1: Villains
Round 2: Grade B Villains
Round 3: Goblins
Round 4: Peter's Family and Friends
Round 5: Villains named after Animals
Round 6: Villain Teams
Round 7: Allies
Round 8: Allies Part 2
Round 9: Story Arcs
Round 10: Costumes
Round 11: The Final. All top 10 winners battle off.
Round 12: I forgot
Round's 13 to 16 were just random villains and characters.
Round 17: Writers
Round 18: Clones
Round 19: Best Single Story Issue
Round 20: C Listed Supporting Characters

[WolfCypher]

The top ten famous deaths/ressurections?

[Kraven]

Originally Posted by I.R.Venom

The top ten famous deaths/ressurections?

For deaths we could have:
1. Gwen Stacy
2. Arthur Stacy
3. Norman Osborn (GG1)
4. Aunt May (temporary)
5. Kraven the Hunter
6. Harry Osborn (GG2)
7. Jean Dewolf
8. Ned Leeds
9. Uncle Ben (maybe, but he'd win by a landslide)
10. Ben Reilly
11. Ezekial (If you didn't use #9)