TAS Rogue vs. Evo Rogue

90s Rogue


Evo Rogue


1. Which do you think would win in a fight? Evo Rogue is at her max potential as seen in Self-Possessed. (when she started to use all the powers she absorbed)

2. Which one do you think looks better/sexier/whatever?

3. Which one do you think had the better voice-actress?

4. Which did you just plain like more?

[JP]

1. Which do you think would win in a fight? Evo Rogue is at her max potential as seen in Self-Possessed. (when she started to use all the powers she absorbed)
TAS Rogue. But since you said it's the Self-Possessed Evo-Rogue than I pick Evo-Rogue.

2. Which one do you think looks better/sexier/whatever?
Evo

3. Which one do you think had the better voice-actress?
Evo

4. Which did you just plain like more?
Evo

I view Self-Possessed Evo Rogue as Rogue at her best level mainly because she's not holding back. We know Mystique said she had "the potential for limitless power" and we saw that in SP. Plus it says somethign when Apocalypse "strongest mutant ever" (iN Evo anyway) required her power to steal powers to power himself up. Or whatever he did when he touched her.

Obviously normal Rogue in Evo without tapping into her stored powers list wouldn't stand a chance against a flying super-strong and durable brick.

[Neptune]

1. Which do you think would win in a fight? Evo Rogue is at her max potential as seen in Self-Possessed. (when she started to use all the powers she absorbed)

TAS Rogue would knock Evo Rogue 3 ways from sunday.


2. Which one do you think looks better/sexier/whatever?

TAS Rogue. Evo Rogue was a little too goth for me.

3. Which one do you think had the better voice-actress?
Definitely TAS Rogue. Her voice was sexy as hell.

4. Which did you just plain like more?
I like them both.

How would TAS Rogue knock Evo Rogue anywhere? Evo Rogue has Juggernaut's invulnerability + Kurt's teleportaiton + Quicksilver's speed...and that's only like a 1/5th of her full powers list that she can use simultaneously.

[JP]

Yeah, there really isn't a contest if your talking Evo Rogue at her full potential.

And honestly I would take any of the Evolution voice cast of the horrible 90's cast.

Though the new series seems to have the best voice cast yet.

[Havok83]

TAS wins in every category for me

TAS Rogue's VA overdid the accent IMO. Like Gambit's VA did.

[ComicChick]

Originally Posted by Nikkolas

90s Rogue


1. Which do you think would win in a fight? Evo Rogue is at her max potential as seen in Self-Possessed. (when she started to use all the powers she absorbed)

if you gotta make Evo Rogue all powerful to beat TAS Rogue, well, that tells ya right there that TAS Rogue is the best!
2. Which one do you think looks better/sexier/whatever?
not my cup of tea either way, but goth isn't really my style

3. Which one do you think had the better voice-actress?
TAS Rogue was the best, but EVO Rogue wasn't too shabby. Still TAS trumps all. i liked how there was the lil hint of something in her voice when she was emotional. that's how i'd expect Rogue to talk.

4. Which did you just plain like more?

TAS Rogue, 'nuff said

[ComicChick]

Originally Posted by Nikkolas

TAS Rogue's VA overdid the accent IMO. Like Gambit's VA did.

curious as to where you are from

i'm southern, and i know ppl from carolina and georgia with thicker accents that than

i work with 2 girls from miss'ippi and i can definitely say the voice actress wasnt too far off.

as for gambit; i loved his voice actor

[JP]

Eh, the entire TAS voice cast over-did everything.

[ComicChick]

not everyone lol

but man, jean's voice did annoy me after a while. she was constantly screaming for scott or passing out

[Neptune]

Jean's whole character annoyed the hell out of me. She may be the strongest X-man but she couldn't do anything on her own. I never liked her and i think i never will. Although Ultimate Jean isn't bad.

[04nbod]

Originally Posted by Neptune

Jean's whole character annoyed the hell out of me. She may be the strongest X-man but she couldn't do anything on her own. I never liked her and i think i never will. Although Ultimate Jean isn't bad.

Oh, ultimate Jean (can't go to sleep goblins are going to get me!)

[StormLegend]

Originally Posted by ComicChick

as for gambit; i loved his voice actor

I know what you mean, honey. He has like the most soul-melting voice I've ever heard.

So deep. So seductive. So perfect.

As for this topic, I really don't think evo Rogue had any charisma at all. TAS Rogue was the classic funny and tough sweetheart that everyone loved.

Plus she looked amazing and worked Ms Marvel's powers out very nicely the whole time.

I liked everyone's voice actors except for Storm's. The first VA made her sound old and dumb. The second one made her sound ugly and manly. I wish she would have been given a more majestic, regal-sounding voice, like what she's suppose to have.