Casting the DC Universe - Part 1

[Thread Manager]

This is a continuation thread, the old thread is Here

[ComicChick]

(i'm creating this thread for a friend so don't shoot me)

Post your best casting choices for any characters you want in the DCU, regardless whether they have films in the works or not. Who are your definititive choices for the characters of the DCU?

[Webley]

Blue Devil
Kevin Durand
[IMG]http://www.**************.com/images/users/uploads/11631/69-blue-devil.jpg[/IMG]

[Jake Cassidy]

I want Durand for Lobo, but he'd be a good Blue Devil too.

[Webley]

Gypsy
Cindy Reynolds




Camilla Belle

[Webley]

Medphyll

Carrot Top

[Man of Steel]

1.Animal Man-Brad Pitt
2.Aquaman I(Orin/Arthur Curry)-Kevin McKidd or Armie Hammer
3.Aquaman II(Arthur Joseph Curry)-Alexander Skarsgard
4.Arion,Lord of Atlantis-Will Friedle
5.Arsenal-Sam Worthington
6.Atom I(Al Pratt)-Frankie Muniz(for lack of a better choice)
7.Atom II(Ray Palmer)-Edward Norton
8.Atom III(Ryan Choi)-Daniel Dae Kim
9.Azrael-John Cena
10.Batgirl I(Barbara Gordon)-Haley Ramm, see also Oracle
11.Batgirl II/Huntress(Helena Bertinelli)-Eliza Dushku
12.Batgirl III(Cassandra Cain)-Katie Leung
13.Batgirl IV/Spoiler/Robin IV(Stephanie Brown)-Gracie Dzienny
14.Batman I(Bruce Wayne)-Sam Witwer or Jeffrey Donovan
15.Batman II-see Azrael
16.Batman III-see Nightwing I
17.Batman IV(Terry McGinnis)-Adam Gregory(younger)/Matt Bomer(older)
18.Batman/Red Hood/Red Robin I(Jason Todd)-Jensen Ackles,see also Robin II
19.Batman(Tim Drake)-see Robin III
20.Batwoman-Daneel Harris
21.Big Barda-Jodi Lyn O'Keefe
22.Bizarro-Brandon Routh
23.Black Canary I(Carolyn Lance)-January Jones
24.Black Canary II(Dinah Lance)-Rebecca Romijin
25.Blackhawk-Eion Bailey
26.Blue Beetle I(Dan Garrett)-Bryan Cranston
27.Blue Beetle II(Ted Kord)-James Rhodey
28.Blue Beetle III(Jaime Reyes)-Ezra Miller
29.Booster Gold-Sean William Scott
30.Braniac-CGI/voice of Peter Jessop
31.Captain Boomerang-Russell Crowe
32.Captain Marvel-Ryan Kelley(Billy Batson)/Brandon Molale(Captain Marvel)
33.Captain Marvel Jr./CM3-Stephen Bender
34.Catwoman I(Selena Kyle)-Kate Beckinsale
35.Catwoman II(Holly Robinson)-Kristen Bell
36.Clayface-CGI/voice of Frank Welker
37.Darkseid-CGI/voice of David Sobolov
38.Deadman-CGI/voice of Michael Rosenbaum
39.The Demon-Julian McMahon
40.Dr. Fate-Liam Neeson
41.Firestorm I(Ronnie Raymond)-Chris Evans
42.Firestorm II(Jason Rusch)-Anthony Mackey
43.Flash I(Jay Garrick)-Bruce Greeenwood
44.Flash II(Barry Allen)-Michael Weatherly
45.Flash III/Kid Flash I(Wally West)-Dan Benson(younger)/Scott Porter(older)
46.Flash IV/Kid Flash II(Bart Allen)-Matt Shively
47.General Zod-Karl Urban
48.Green Arrow I(Oliver Queen)-Charlie Hunnam
49.Green Arrow II(Conner Hawke)-Justin Hartley
50.Green Lantern I(Alan Scott)-John Slattery
51.Green Lantern II(Hal Jordan)-Michael Vartan or Geoff Stults, see also Spectre II
52.Green Lantern III(Guy Gardner)-Bradley Cooper
53.Green Lantern IV(John Stewart)-Taye Diggs or Roger Cross
54.Green Lantern V(Kyle Rayner)-Freddie Prinze Jr.
55.Hawkman-Eric Bana
56.Hippolyta-Lucy Lawless(younger)/Lynda Carter(older)
57.Joker-William Defoe
58.Jonathan Kent-Jeff Bridges
59.Martha Kent-Jullianne Moore
60.Lady Shiva-Fabiola Sarah Volante
61.Lois Lane-Zooey Deschanel
62.Lightning Lad-Dave Franco
63.Lobo-Jeffrey Dean Morgan
64.Lex Luthor-James Marsters
65.Man-Bat-Kevin Conroy
66.Manhunters-CGI/voice of Corey Burton
67.Martian Manhunter-CGI/Voice of Carl Lumbley(alien/superhero)/Jon Hamm(human)
68.Mary Marvel-Emma Roberts(Mary Batson)/Mary Elizabeth Winstead(Mary Marvel)
69.Max Mercury-Josh Brolin
70.Mon-El/Valor-Tom Welling
71.Mr. Freeze-Ralph Fiennes
72.Mr. Miracle-Ioan Gruffudd
73.Nightwing I(Dick Grayson)-Milo Ventimiglia, see also Robin I
74.Nightwing II(Lor-Zod/Chris Kent)-Henry Cavill
75.Jimmy Olsen-Logan Huffman
76.Oracle-Rachel Nichols, see also Batgirl I
77.Alfred Pennyworth-Ed Brigadier
78.Penguin-David Ogden Stiers
79.Power Girl-Elisha Cuthbert
80.Plastic Man-Dane Cook
81.Ra's Al Ghul-Jason Issacs
82.Riddler-Patrick Wilson
83.Robin I(Dick Grayson)-Josh Hutcherson, see also Nightwing I
84.Robin II(Jason Todd)-Logan Lerman, see also Batman/Red Hood/Red Robin
85.Robin III(Tim Drake)-Aaron Johnson
86.Robin IV-see Batgirl IV
87.Robin V(Damien Wayne)-Thomas Dekker
88.Scarecrow-David Tennent
89.Sergeant Rock-Harrison Ford
90.Spectre (Entity)-CGI/voice of James Earl Jones
91.Spectre I(Jim Corrigan)-Garret Dillahunt
92.Spectre II(Hal Jordan)-Ray Liotta,see also Green Lantern II
93.Spectre III(Crispus Allen)-Idris Elba
94.Starman-Jake Gylenhall
95.Steel(John Henry Irons)-Henry Simmons
96.Adam Strange-Paul Bettany
97.Strange Visitor-Liv Tyler
98.Superboy-Robbie Amell
99.Supergirl-Amber Heard
100.Superman-Brandon Routh or Henry Cavill
101.Superwoman-Laura Vandervoort
102.Swamp Thing-CGI
103.Tempest-Thomas Dekker
104.Steve Trevor-Jonathan Bennett
105.Two-Face-James Marsden
106.Ventriloquist and Scarface-Bob Hoskins
107.Wonder Woman I(Diana)-Erin Cummings or Taylor Cole
108.Wonder Woman II-see Hippolyta
109.Wonder Woman III(Artemis)-Jessica Biel
110.Wonder Woman IV/Troia(Donna Troy)-Jessica Stroup
111.Wonder Woman V/Wonder Girl II(Cassie Sandsmark)-Ashley Eckstein
112.Zatana Zatara-Julia Voth
113.Zoom II(Hunter Zolomon)-Josh Hartnett
New Additions:
114.Abra Kadabra-Shaun Toub
115.Iris Allen-Rachel McAdams
116.Bibbo Bibbowski-Barry Corbin
117.Lt. Harvey Bullock-Michael Chiklis
118.Desaad-Robert Carlyle
119.Lt. James Gordon-Bruce Willis
120.Gorilla Grodd-Michael Clark Duncan
121.Granny Goodness-Kathleen Turner
122.Harley Quinn-Amanda Seyfreid
123.Highfather-Sean Bean
124.Kalibak-Tyler Mane
125.Kilowog-Michael Madsen
126.Lady Blackhawk-Yvonne Strahovski
127.Lashina-Jessica Alba
128.Lighray-Ryan Kwanten
129.Lt. Renee Montoya-Michelle Rodriguez
130.Orion-Daniel Craig
131.Linda Park-Kristen Kreuk
132.Dr. Psycho-Peter Dinklage
133.Maggie Sawyer-Mariska Hargitay
134.Star Saphirre(Carol Ferris)-Jordana Brewster
135.Stargirl/Star Sprangled Kid II(Courtney Whitmore)-Dakota Fanning
136.Dan Turpin-Christopher Meloni
137.Vicky Vale-Cobie Smulders
138.Wonder Girl I(Donna Troy)-Alexandra Daddario, see also Wonder Woman IV/Troia
139.Professor Zoom(Eobard Thwane)-Mark Wahlberg(younger)/John Wesley Shipp(older)

[Mondragon]

[Mr. Earle]

Originally Posted by Man of Steel

14.Batman I(Bruce Wayne)-Sam Witwer or Jeffrey Donovan

WTF bro?

[Eddie Dean]

Most of his list is pretty WTF..

[Mr. Earle]

He cast 139 characters. Dude needs a hobby or something.

[Donnie Darko]

Originally Posted by Mondragon

How weird does it make me that I would go see a Wonder Twins movie with that cast?

[batnkevlar]

I hate when people pose huge 200 person cast lists... it might be more exciting if people took the time and posted pictures with the names... it makes it perdy...

[Donnie Darko]

not just pics, but also I really enjoy when people give a little write-up as to WHY they picked someone. It opens up a lot more for discussion.

[TheWatcher]

I've got a two person cast.

Henry Cavill as Superman.
Ryan Reynolds as Hal Jordan.

Done.

[HighFivingMF]

Originally Posted by TheWatcher

I've got a two person cast.

Henry Cavill as Superman.
Ryan Reynolds as Hal Jordan.

Done.

You should work for WB.

[scatterax]

heath ledger as the joker, christian bale as.............robin???

[Ultra Lantern]

Originally Posted by Man of Steel

1.Animal Man-Brad Pitt
2.Aquaman I(Orin/Arthur Curry)-Kevin McKidd or Armie Hammer
3.Aquaman II(Arthur Joseph Curry)-Alexander Skarsgard
4.Arion,Lord of Atlantis-Will Friedle
5.Arsenal-Sam Worthington
6.Atom I(Al Pratt)-Frankie Muniz(for lack of a better choice)
7.Atom II(Ray Palmer)-Edward Norton
8.Atom III(Ryan Choi)-Daniel Dae Kim
9.Azrael-John Cena
10.Batgirl I(Barbara Gordon)-Haley Ramm, see also Oracle
11.Batgirl II/Huntress(Helena Bertinelli)-Eliza Dushku
12.Batgirl III(Cassandra Cain)-Katie Leung
13.Batgirl IV/Spoiler/Robin IV(Stephanie Brown)-Gracie Dzienny
14.Batman I(Bruce Wayne)-Sam Witwer or Jeffrey Donovan
15.Batman II-see Azrael
16.Batman III-see Nightwing I
17.Batman IV(Terry McGinnis)-Adam Gregory(younger)/Matt Bomer(older)
18.Batman/Red Hood/Red Robin I(Jason Todd)-Jensen Ackles,see also Robin II
19.Batman(Tim Drake)-see Robin III
20.Batwoman-Daneel Harris
21.Big Barda-Jodi Lyn O'Keefe
22.Bizarro-Brandon Routh
23.Black Canary I(Carolyn Lance)-January Jones
24.Black Canary II(Dinah Lance)-Rebecca Romijin
25.Blackhawk-Eion Bailey
26.Blue Beetle I(Dan Garrett)-Bryan Cranston
27.Blue Beetle II(Ted Kord)-James Rhodey
28.Blue Beetle III(Jaime Reyes)-Ezra Miller
29.Booster Gold-Sean William Scott
30.Braniac-CGI/voice of Peter Jessop
31.Captain Boomerang-Russell Crowe
32.Captain Marvel-Ryan Kelley(Billy Batson)/Brandon Molale(Captain Marvel)
33.Captain Marvel Jr./CM3-Stephen Bender
34.Catwoman I(Selena Kyle)-Kate Beckinsale
35.Catwoman II(Holly Robinson)-Kristen Bell
36.Clayface-CGI/voice of Frank Welker
37.Darkseid-CGI/voice of David Sobolov
38.Deadman-CGI/voice of Michael Rosenbaum
39.The Demon-Julian McMahon
40.Dr. Fate-Liam Neeson
41.Firestorm I(Ronnie Raymond)-Chris Evans
42.Firestorm II(Jason Rusch)-Anthony Mackey
43.Flash I(Jay Garrick)-Bruce Greeenwood
44.Flash II(Barry Allen)-Michael Weatherly
45.Flash III/Kid Flash I(Wally West)-Dan Benson(younger)/Scott Porter(older)
46.Flash IV/Kid Flash II(Bart Allen)-Matt Shively
47.General Zod-Karl Urban
48.Green Arrow I(Oliver Queen)-Michael Fassbender
49.Green Arrow II(Conner Hawke)-Justin Hartley
50.Green Lantern I(Alan Scott)-John Slattery
51.Green Lantern II(Hal Jordan)-Michael Vartan or Geoff Stults, see also Spectre II
52.Green Lantern III(Guy Gardner)-Bradley Cooper
53.Green Lantern IV(John Stewart)-Taye Diggs or Roger Cross
54.Green Lantern V(Kyle Rayner)-Freddie Prinze Jr.
55.Hawkman-Eric Bana
56.Hippolyta-Lucy Lawless(younger)/Lynda Carter(older)
57.Joker-William Defoe
58.Jonathan Kent-Jeff Bridges
59.Martha Kent-Jullianne Moore
60.Lady Shiva-Fabiola Sarah Volante
61.Lois Lane-Zooey Deschanel
62.Lightning Lad-Dave Franco
63.Lobo-Jeffrey Dean Morgan
64.Lex Luthor-James Marsters
65.Man-Bat-Kevin Conroy
66.Manhunters-CGI/voice of Corey Burton
67.Martian Manhunter-CGI/Voice of Carl Lumbley(alien/superhero)/Jon Hamm(human)
68.Mary Marvel-Emma Roberts(Mary Batson)/Mary Elizabeth Winstead(Mary Marvel)
69.Max Mercury-Josh Brolin
70.Mon-El/Valor-Tom Welling
71.Mr. Freeze-Ralph Fiennes
72.Mr. Miracle-Ioan Gruffudd
73.Nightwing I(Dick Grayson)-Milo Ventimiglia, see also Robin I
74.Nightwing II(Lor-Zod/Chris Kent)-Henry Cavill
75.Jimmy Olsen-Logan Huffman
76.Oracle-Rachel Nicols, see also Batgirl I
77.Alfred Pennyworth-Ed Brigadier
78.Penguin-David Odgen Stiers
79.Power Girl-Elisha Cuthbert
80.Plastic Man-Dane Cook
81.Ra's Al Ghul-Jason Issacs
82.Riddler-Crispin Clover
83.Robin I(Dick Grayson)-Josh Hutcherson, see also Nightwing I
84.Robin II(Jason Todd)-Logan Lerman, see also Batman/Red Hood/Red Robin
85.Robin III(Tim Drake)-Aaron Johnson
86.Robin IV-see Batgirl IV
87.Robin V(Damien Wayne)-Thomas Dekker
88.Scarecrow-David Tennent
89.Sergeant Rock-Harrison Ford
90.Spectre (Entity)-CGI/voice of James Earl Jones
91.Spectre I(Jim Corrigan)-Garret Dillahunt
92.Spectre II(Hal Jordan)-Ray Liotta,see also Green Lantern II
93.Spectre III(Crispus Allen)-Idris Elba
94.Starman-Jake Gylenhall
95.Steel(John Henry Irons)-Henry Simmons
96.Adam Strange-Paul Bettany
97.Strange Visitor-Liv Tyler
98.Superboy-Robbie Amell
99.Supergirl-Amber Heard
100.Superman-Brandon Routh or Henry Cavill
101.Superwoman-Laura Vandervoort
102.Swamp Thing-CGI
103.Tempest-Thomas Dekker
104.Steve Trevor-Brendan Fraser
105.Two-Face-James Marsden
106.Ventriloquist and Scarface-Bob Hoskins
107.Wonder Woman I(Diana)-Erin Cummings or Taylor Cole
108.Wonder Woman II-see Hippolyta
109.Wonder Woman III(Artemis)-Jessica Biel
110.Wonder Woman IV/Troia(Donna Troy)-Jessica Stroup
111.Wonder Woman V/Wonder Girl II(Cassie Sandsmark)-Ashley Eckstein
112.Zatana Zatara-Julia Voth
113.Zoom II(Hunter Zolomon)-Josh Hartnett
New Additions:
114.Abra Kadabra-Shaun Toub
115.Iris Allen-Rachel McAdams
116.Bibbo Bibbowski-Barry Corbin
117.Lt. Harvey Bullock-Michael Chiklis
118.Desaad-Robert Carlyle
119.Lt. James Gordon-Bruce Willis
120.Gorilla Grodd-Michael Clark Duncan
121.Granny Goodness-Kathleen Turner
122.Harley Quinn-Amanda Seyfreid
123.Highfather-Sean Bean
124.Kalibak-Tyler Mane
125.Kilowog-Michael Madsen
126.Lady Blackhawk-Yvonne Strahovski
127.Lashina-Jessica Alba
128.Lighray-Ryan Kwanten
129.Lt. Renee Montoya-Michelle Rodriguez
130.Orion-Dainel Craig
131.Linda Park-Kristen Kreuk
132.Dr. Psycho-Peter Dinklage
133.Maggie Sawyer-Mariska Hargitay
134.Star Saphirre(Carol Ferris)-Jordana Brewster
135.Stargirl/Star Sprangled Kid II(Courtney Whitmore)-Dakota Fanning
136.Dan Turpin-Christopher Meloni
137.Vicky Vale-Cobie Smulders
138.Wonder Girl I(Donna Troy)-Alexandra Daddario, see also Wonder Woman IV/Troia
139.Professor Zoom(Eobard Thwane)-Mark Wahlberg(younger)/John Wesley Shipp(older)

So,you were bored and made this list. Photos would have been nice.

[illmatikk]

heres mine.

[Man of Steel]

Originally Posted by Ultra Lantern

So,you were bored and made this list. Photos would have been nice.

Like I'm going to post pictures for 139 characters. I doubt it would even let me.

[sabetoonth]

Nope, you're limited to ten images a post

[UltimateJustin]

Ben Affleck as Captain Marvel



Nicholas Hoult as Rabit



Emma Stone as Slapstick

[Man of Steel]

Originally Posted by UltimateJustin

Ben Affleck as Captain Marvel



Nicholas Hoult as Rabit



Emma Stone as Slapstick

Rabit? Affleck as Marvel, never thought of it before, might actually work.

[UltimateJustin]

Originally Posted by Man of Steel

Rabit? Affleck as Marvel, never thought of it before, might actually work.

Oops, meant Robin obviously. My cousins brought their rabbits over last week and I accidentally killed one and hid the remains.

I guess this is more or less my brain trying to force me to come clean about it like in the movie The Machinist.

But yeah, I think that people generally hate Affleck less now than they did 7 years ago, so it might work.

[Man of Steel]

Originally Posted by UltimateJustin

Oops, meant Robin obviously. My cousins brought their rabbits over last week and I accidentally killed one and hid the remains.

I guess this is more or less my brain trying to force me to come clean about it like in the movie The Machinist.

But yeah, I think that people generally hate Affleck less now than they did 7 years ago, so it might work.

Just tell them about the rabbit. Affleck's only problem is that he's a little too short.