Transformers: ROTF User Review Thread

[Sarge 2.0]

Originally Posted by Nathan

I thought Wheelie said it at least once when he made the Graveyard comment.

He said "frickin" in that scene I think. Mudflap or Skids - I forget which - almost said "mother****er" but got cut off.

[marvelman2006]

I dont know how to review this thing because im half and half on it.
on one side i loved the action and anything including the autobots, and thought some of the jokes worked.

on the other side i still couldnt tell what was going on in some of the action scenes because the camera was too close and some of the other jokes didnt work.

its weird thinking about it becasue so much stuff did work and at the same time the stuff that didnt work came from the stuff that did work.
Why is it so hard though in today's movie making for these directors to simply pull the camera back and lets us see whats going on. They have a boner for putting camera as close as possible.

[SpiderByte]

Originally Posted by mr. peasant

Just watched the movie. And I must say, most of my thoughts have already been posted. It does seem rushed and yet some parts just dragged. In other words, pacing could have been tighter. Also, some parts that struck a nerve:

A fellow robot died in order to give Optimus his upgrade. Upon beating the Fallen, what does he do? Chucks it aside like so much waste.

The Fallen revealed the Transformers' existence and announced he was after Sam. The movie also indicated that the government was considering said option. Yet, at no point did it feel as though other humans were after him. Sure, he was on a 'wanted list' but again, nothing came of it.

There were far, far too many Transformers on both sides and at the climax. I couldn't tell them apart and more importantly, I couldn't tell whose side they were on. It was just too chaotic to appreciate.

Lastly, Devastator's size could have been done better. Why have a humongous Transformer built from several vehicles and not put another Transformer beside for scale comparison? Then, there's the really big one at the start of the movie, making Devastator's initial appearance all the less impressive

In order:

Welll what was he supposed to do? with all that junk on he couldn't transform.

Thats because they hadn't really acted on it yet. they got confirmation from egypt, but just to keep an eye on him.

I'll give you a hint: the autobots you see in the beginning are the ones you see in the end. no new autobots join during the final battle. how hard is that to understand? only the decepticons got new allies at the end, not autobots.

What the hell do you mean by "there were no transformers near him" What about the twins? They were CLIMBING on him!

[Colossal Spoons]

Originally Posted by Sarge 2.0

Here's the thing, not only is it a bad action movie because it's stupid, it's a bad action movie because it was boring. There's no excuse for boring in an action movie. And you're right that Optimus may have been the saving grace of this movie (there is only one good moment in the entire movie: Optimus beating the **** out of Starscream, Megatron, and some other unnamed Decepticon). Too bad he's dead for most of it. Even his fight with the Fallen was boring. He also said some things that I would never expect Optimus to say like "Any last words?" and the worst was "Give me your face!". I mean, wtf?

I need to leave this thread. The more posts like this I read, the more I agree with them OP's badass lines were cool, but def out of character.

[Nathan]

When he beat the Fallen, we should've gotten the line "I thought you were made of sterner stuff." It would've fit better, because honestly, I'm sure we all thought what a push over the Fallen was. Not only that, the line also sounds less blood thirsty.

[Mr. Earle]

What i really liked was Lennox's character. How he taps Ironhide's bonnet telling him something, talks to the Arcees, asks for Sideswipe to get in the action, and finally.... when he learns about Optimus' death. He seemed to be friends with the robots.
Basically all the NEST soldiers were friends with the autobots and stood up for them. I loved that part.

What i didnt like was the Starscream/Megatron dynamic, as i said in my review as well. Megatron was abusing SS all the time for no reason. In G1 Starscream often contradicts Megatron but Megatron is barely abset. He knows about SS's treacherous ways but he wants him next to him because of his strategical mind and his abilities. He only beats him when its necessary. Here Bay tried to do what we were whining about the first movie. He made SS a pussy constantly bowing to Meg who was like a wife beater. I didnt like it.

[AnorexicBatman]

Considering the Fallen was such a wuss... I wouldn't be surprised if Sam kills Unicron in TF3
I mean really. Whatever happened to the Bay who liked epic climactic battles?

[Mr. Earle]

Originally Posted by Sarge 2.0

Here's the thing, not only is it a bad action movie because it's stupid, it's a bad action movie because it was boring. There's no excuse for boring in an action movie. And you're right that Optimus may have been the saving grace of this movie (there is only one good moment in the entire movie: Optimus beating the **** out of Starscream, Megatron, and some other unnamed Decepticon). Too bad he's dead for most of it. Even his fight with the Fallen was boring. He also said some things that I would never expect Optimus to say like "Any last words?" and the worst was "Give me your face!". I mean, wtf?

I agree with you. I ve been saying this in the "Prime is too brutal" thread for like... forever! Thank you!

[Golgo-13]

This movie requires MULTIPLE viewings to take in all the information, but:

How did Jetfire get to the museum again, and why was he in-active? I spilled my soda on my lap during that scene and missed some of the dialogue.

[AnorexicBatman]

No wonder it's making so much money, people have to see it multiple times just to understand the damn thimg

[Colossal Spoons]

Originally Posted by Golgo-13

This movie requires MULTIPLE viewings to take in all the information, but:

How did Jetfire get to the museum again, and why was he in-active? I spilled my soda on my lap during that scene and missed some of the dialogue.

Spilled soda or not, I don't know why Jetfire was inactive in the museum haha

[Nathan]

Originally Posted by Golgo-13

This movie requires MULTIPLE viewings to take in all the information, but:

How did Jetfire get to the museum again, and why was he in-active? I spilled my soda on my lap during that scene and missed some of the dialogue.

He was in-active because he ran out of Energon. It's also the reason why he appears rusty and starts to fall apart. So while in-active and in his alt mode, he someday ended up in the Museum. Question is, how did Wheelie now everyone's location? Did someone catch that part?

[AnorexicBatman]

He's old and crotchety.
Smithsonian = Retirement home for old old old Autobots/Decepticons
I wish he was called 'Skyfire' at some point... just as a reference...

[anrrd_2]

why didnt sam just use the spark fragment to revive OP instead of jetfire???

[Colossal Spoons]

Originally Posted by anrrd_2

why didnt sam just use the spark fragment to revive OP instead of jetfire???

Jetfire wasn't "dead"

[Mr. Earle]

Originally Posted by anrrd_2

why didnt sam just use the spark fragment to revive OP instead of jetfire???

Because.... Because **** you, thats why!!!

Spoiler!!! Click to Read!:

I am kidding man!

[Nathan]

Originally Posted by Colossal Spoons

Jetfire wasn't "dead"

Megatron was. But he got revived with a Spark fragment.

[anrrd_2]

but megs was, and they used a spark fragment to bring him back..

[anrrd_2]

Originally Posted by Mr. Earle

Because.... Because **** you, thats why!!!

Spoiler!!! Click to Read!:

I am kidding man!

little boy: why did all the primes die?

museum attendent: because you touch yourself at night!

Originally Posted by Nathan

Megatron was. But he got revived with a Spark fragment.

you beat me

[Mr. Earle]

Originally Posted by Colossal Spoons

Jetfire wasn't "dead"

But Megatron was and it worked on him just fine!

EDIT: You guys got me!

[Erzengel]

8 out of 10.

The first one was better although, I enjoyed the action more in this one. Especially with Optimus going up against Megatron, Starscream and I think Grindor in the forest.

My biggest problem with this movie is giving Megatron a Master. Megatron in any incarnation would never subjugate himself to anyone, Unicron withstanding.

[roach]

Originally Posted by anrrd_2

but megs was, and they used a spark fragment to bring him back..

they also had to sacrifice another Decepticon in the process

[Nathan]

Just because they needed the body parts since he was missing an arm and a leg.

[roach]

Prime's chest was missing...who was gonna replace his chest

[anrrd_2]

really? they did? i must have missed that part....anyway OP wasnt missing any limbs...just his mechanical entrales