Who Wins? Doctor Manhattan vs Galactus

[A.Cho.P.o.P.]

Originally Posted by WillardNation

We need the guys from Deadliest Warrior to put the stats in their computer program and decide a winner.

And we need the same guy narrating everything. It would be epic.

[Chunin]

Galactus, Devourer of Naked Blue Guys

[Ultra Lantern]

Galactus would win.

[ripse]

Galactus punch his little brother dr.manhattan (if u know what i mean little blue)??? is look hurt...:/

[Bruce_Begins]

Dr, Manhatten cannot be destroyed, he can teleport anywhere in the Universe in an instant, he can exist in past, present and future, he can see past, present and future, has telekinesis, is Immortal.

Galactus cannot do anything here.

[The Morningstar]

Where has it been shown that Dr M can exist in the past, present and future? I thought he could just see the past, present and future simultaneously?

Either way, Galactus can do all that too. There is nothing Dr M can do to Galactus.

[Aesop Rocks]

Tron

[Duke]

Dr. Manhatten would win with just a flick of the wrist.

[Kane52630]

[Blitzkrieg Bop]

I don't think Manhattan would even bother trying to fight.

[donkeypunch]

Great point! agreed

[RiddleMeThat]

Manhattan and it's not close.

[pr0xyt0xin]

Galactus, by far.

Galactus is out of Dr. Manhattan's league. idk if he'd even make it past the heralds.

[LEONCIO]

Originally Posted by pr0xyt0xin

Galactus, by far.

Galactus is out of Dr. Manhattan's league. idk if he'd even make it past the heralds.

I see him closer to Silver Surfer's power level, Galactus would be in a different league indeed.

Manhattan was "created" in a lab accident, Galactus was created with the destruction of his whole universe, the energy difference between both accidents is just too big.

Manhattan can create a big sand castle on Mars, while Galactus can just devour Mars, or Jupiter, or Saturn, or even bigger planets outside our solar system. He could just eat Earth with Manhattan on it, and the doctor's only choice to survive would be to teleport outside the planet, he couldn't fight against one of the most powerful beings in the whole universe.

If I remember well, Mahattan himself said that his powers had certain limitations, that he wouldn't be able to stop a soviet full nuclear attack, I don't remeber if he said exactly this, but I remember reading (like yesterday) something like this mentioned in a thread from other forum where a similar fight was discussed.

Galactus not only has the power to stop that kind of attack, he has the power to destroy and devour full planets, he is among the most powerful entities in the whole universe, Manhattan could be just a powerful herald to serve the devourer of worlds, not a real threat, at least not when he is full powered and not starving.

[Space Ghost]

Manhattan beats almost everybody.

[KangConquers]

Doctor Manhattan is kind of untested. Watchmen claims he's omnipotent, but he never performs any feats that the Silver Surfer couldn't match. Galactus is of course leagues beyond that.

Galactus based on feats.

[KangConquers]

Originally Posted by pr0xyt0xin

Galactus, by far.

Galactus is out of Dr. Manhattan's league. idk if he'd even make it past the heralds.

Exactly. If you plunk Silver Surfer in the middle of Watchmen, or hell, in the middle of our world, he'd seem like an omnipotent god.

Galactus unleashed an attack in the Annihilation climax that ravaged galaxies. I'm not saying Manhattan necessarily couldn't do that, but we have no proof that he can.

[Beyonder]

Uh.....
Dr.Manhattan doesn't have any planet level feat claiming he does is a speculation/assumption as he has physical/mental weaknesses.....
1. His brain is STILL PHYSICAL.
2. He can't DIRECTLY interfere.
3. He has limits to his powers.

Galactus only weaknesses are higher Nigh-omnipotent beings and or items along with the Ultimate Nullifier I mean Galactus once RAISED his fist and destroyed a entire UNIVERSE on-panel.

Galactus wins this to many feats and powers that dwarfs Dr.Manhattan.

[ripse]

Galactus win,? of course