The Official 'Hulk in Avengers' thread. - Part 2

[Vartha]

Originally Posted by wobbly

It's imdb so don't assume its true.
Personally, I hope it isn't. Ferrigno had his time as the Hulk, and that's been half the problem with the live action films since. Time to move on from ties to the old series.

Indeed.

[Longshot777]

Ok since Ed Norton is not in it,


Am I the only one who is dropping The Incredible Hulk DVD out of their Avengers DVD/BluRay Collection???

It will be just: Ironman, Thor, Captain America and then The Avengers.

Oh yeah, I also dropped Ironman 2 out of this continuity. C'mon man!! Different Rhody!!

Ironman 2 is a good movie but not worthy of those 4.

Hulk was my least favorite movie but not a bad movie and I would have put it on the continuity BUT since it will not be the same Bruce Banner...it's kinda pointless.

I know Rachel was a different actress in Nolan's Batman movies...but both movies are just great films I can overlook a minor character being different actresses.

[Weadazoid]

Originally Posted by Longshot777

Ok since Ed Norton is not in it,


Am I the only one who is dropping The Incredible Hulk DVD out of their Avengers DVD/BluRay Collection???

It will be just: Ironman, Thor, Captain America and then The Avengers.

Oh yeah, I also dropped Ironman 2 out of this continuity. C'mon man!! Different Rhody!!

Ironman 2 is a good movie but not worthy of those 4.

Hulk was my least favorite movie but not a bad movie and I would have put it on the continuity BUT since it will not be the same Bruce Banner...it's kinda pointless.

I know Rachel was a different actress in Nolan's Batman movies...but both movies are just great films I can overlook a minor character being different actresses.

Different artists draw characters quite differently


I don't mind actor changes as long as they embody the characters.

[Gamma Goliath]

Bruce banner us the James bond of the mcu. Lol.

[herolee10]

Originally Posted by Longshot777

Ok since Ed Norton is not in it,


Am I the only one who is dropping The Incredible Hulk DVD out of their Avengers DVD/BluRay Collection???

It will be just: Ironman, Thor, Captain America and then The Avengers.

Oh yeah, I also dropped Ironman 2 out of this continuity. C'mon man!! Different Rhody!!

Ironman 2 is a good movie but not worthy of those 4.

Hulk was my least favorite movie but not a bad movie and I would have put it on the continuity BUT since it will not be the same Bruce Banner...it's kinda pointless.

I know Rachel was a different actress in Nolan's Batman movies...but both movies are just great films I can overlook a minor character being different actresses.

Well, while the actors may be different (which I know can be irksome for the sake of continuity), TIH for whatever purposes, is still being treated as a part of the large continuity in the MCU.

I mean, it was stated in the SHIELD website that had been opened prior to the release of Thor that both Erik Selvig and Jane Foster are from the same university that Bruce Banner and Betty Ross work at, and Erik Selvig is also a known associate of Banner as well.

Plus, we have the footage of the campus attack being shown in the SHIELD Warehouse in Iron Man 2, we also have that special short film that's being released alongside Thor called "The Consultant" that ties the gap between Iron Man 2 and the end of TIH.

Hell, the Super Soldier Serum is also a main element in TIH as well.

Personally, I just think of this case being similar to cases like how we had two actors playing Dumbledore in the Harry Potter Series, and how despite the fact that they had a new actor playing the character after the second film (due to the first one having passed away), they still used clips from the first two films in latter films for flashbacks and even had flashback scenes that took place before the events of the first film using the second actor.

[Dark Raven]

Originally Posted by herolee10

Well, while the actors may be different (which I know can be irksome for the sake of continuity), TIH for whatever purposes, is still being treated as a part of the large continuity in the MCU.

I mean, it was stated in the SHIELD website that had been opened prior to the release of Thor that both Erik Selvig and Jane Foster are from the same university that Bruce Banner and Betty Ross work at, and Erik Selvig is also a known associate of Banner as well.

Plus, we have the footage of the campus attack being shown in the SHIELD Warehouse in Iron Man 2, we also have that special short film that's being released alongside Thor called "The Consultant" that ties the gap between Iron Man 2 and the end of TIH.

Hell, the Super Soldier Serum is also a main element in TIH as well.

Personally, I just think of this case being similar to cases like how we had two actors playing Dumbledore in the Harry Potter Series, and how despite the fact that they had a new actor playing the character after the second film (due to the first one having passed away), they still used clips from the first two films in latter films for flashbacks and even had flashback scenes that took place before the events of the first film using the second actor.

I wonder if there will be any flashbacks with Norton, or will they refilm those with Ruffalo? They need to at least get Liv Tyler to interact with Ruffalo for some "flashback" scenes.

[herolee10]

Originally Posted by Dark Raven

I wonder if there will be any flashbacks with Norton, or will they refilm those with Ruffalo? They need to at least get Liv Tyler to interact with Ruffalo for some "flashback" scenes.

Well if there's a sequel, to the TIH, then they could just go on with Ruffalo with the remainder of the TIH's cast.

But yeah, I wouldn't mind seeing certain scenes recreated with Ruffalo playing Banner in it.

[Norm3]

I think they are going to recast Betty. I hope so anyway.

[Gamma Goliath]

Why would they?

[Bren]

Because Liv Tyler was rubbish AND ugly

[Gamma Goliath]

I would try to keep as many actors in place as possible from this franchise .

[Triad]

Originally Posted by Bren

Because Liv Tyler was rubbish AND ugly

I certainly would disagree with you that she is ugly, but I will say that she was somewhat unconvincing to me as a scientist. I think that Jennifer Connelly was better suited in the role in Ang Lee's version...and better looking too, but Liv Tyler is no pain on the eyes AT ALL, IMHO!

[November Rain]

Originally Posted by Obi-Ron

My worry is that they will just make him the Infraggable Krunk

VIDEO-CLick to Watch!:

i love this show

[November Rain]

man, is this what the glorious hulk board of long ago has been reduced to?

meh

at least there are some familiar faces still on here...

where's sava?

[Avenger]

I liked Liv Tyler as Betty, but I won't be horribly upset if they recast her. The one person from TIH that I really hope they don't recast is William Hurt as Thunderbolt Ross. I really enjoyed his performance, and to be honest I prefer him over Sam Elliott's Ross (I know, I know, blasphemy! ).

[Triad]

Originally Posted by Avenger

I liked Liv Tyler as Betty, but I won't be horribly upset if they recast her. The one person from TIH that I really hope they don't recast is William Hurt as Thunderbolt Ross. I really enjoyed his performance, and to be honest I prefer him over Sam Elliott's Ross (I know, I know, blasphemy! ).

Totally agree on all points!

[Obi-Ron]

Originally Posted by November Rain

man, is this what the glorious hulk board of long ago has been reduced to?

Ah, the good old days...

[Weadazoid]

I liked Liv, even if Connely was more suited to the scientist role, Liv actually conveyed a bit more human emotion, Connely is almost cold at times detached removed.



When Liv see's Bruce for the first time, as he accidentally walks through those double doors.... I actually felt bad for her, for him for everybody.

[TikkiEXX]

i actually loved Liv as Betty. i really dug their relationship. thought she was great. but i wont be too upset if shes replaced. just going on record that i really enjoyed her performance in TIH. and i think shes plenty hot. just kind of in a soccer momish way these days, not quite the smoking hot teenager anymore, but shes aged really well.

[BigThor]

Originally Posted by TikkiEXX

i actually loved Liv as Betty. i really dug their relationship. thought she was great. but i wont be too upset if shes replaced. just going on record that i really enjoyed her performance in TIH. and i think shes plenty hot. just kind of in a soccer momish way these days, not quite the smoking hot teenager anymore, but shes aged really well.

This

Although I enjoyed Jennifer Connely in the role as well.

[Bren]

She was ugly.

[Khemik@L]

Check out my Hulk Fan Vid:
http://www.twitvid.com/7TGVL

[TikkiEXX]

Originally Posted by BigThor

This

Although I enjoyed Jennifer Connely in the role as well.

yeah she was awesome too. and speaking of aging well, shes like a fine wine, just keeps getting better with age. lol

[Doc Samson]

Originally Posted by Triad

I certainly would disagree with you that she is ugly, but I will say that she was somewhat unconvincing to me as a scientist. I think that Jennifer Connelly was better suited in the role in Ang Lee's version...and better looking too, but Liv Tyler is no pain on the eyes AT ALL, IMHO!

Maybe, but Liv & Norton had loads more chemistry than anything I felt between Jennifer & Eric. And to me, in these types of films, that's the most important aspect for the female lead.

[Obi-Ron]

I think that more to do with Bana, he was quite dull.