The Official Lex Luthor Casting Thread - Part 6

[I SEE SPIDEY]

I don't want a Hackman like Lex. Hackman is a fine actor and played that version of Lex, which I assume was simular to the comicbook version at the time, as well as can be expected but we in the 2000's not 1978. I want a new version that is nothing like the old one.

I do like Chandler as an actor though and wouldn't mind someeone like him in the role. I'm kind of hoping they cast against type but I wouldn't mind some of the choices on this thread.

[hopefuldreamer]

I have no particular objection to Kyle Chandler actually

Originally Posted by Rodrigo90

Look at my post above - Don't you just feel like punching that bald git?

Pearce is very much capable of playing Lex, but in such a way, you want to knee him in the balls the second you see him.

Issacs? He's 50 this year...Del Toro looks older though

Yeah, it's weird. I know Issacs is older... But he looks in the same age group as the other two to me. And, call me weird, but he's the sexy kind of older man. Which I really want from Lex. Not like 'Oh he's such a fittie', but just well groomed and charming.

[RachelDawes]

Originally Posted by Marvin

So many safe choices here.

Kyle Chandler!
At his core he's got a tremendously strong presence and projects will. All he needs is some good writing. We might be looking at the true modern Hackman.

I suspect they'll be casting a bigger name to play Lex. Someone the public will immediately recognize.

[Eddie Dean]

Chandler would have made a killer Pa Kent. Hell, throw in Connie Britton as Ma Kent as well.

[Marvin]

Jackman, like Spacey was unfortunately stuck with a lame characterization. To this day I think jackman would be ideal if he was given the proper script.

Watching him in films such as Unforgiven and Crimson Tide among others...plus he has that 90's era comic look.

[GreenKToo]

I dnt know. For me, I see someone like jude law or josh brolin or isaacs in the role.

[hopefuldreamer]

Originally Posted by Marvin

Jackman, like Spacey was unfortunately stuck with a lame characterization. To this day I think jackman would be ideal if he was given the proper script.

Watching him in films such as Unforgiven and Crimson Tide among others...plus he has that 90's era comic look.

We talking bout Hugh Jackman? Or Gene Hackman?

[Sawyer]

Obviously Hackman.

[Llama_Shepherd]

Not so obvious when you use someone else's name.

[Marvin]

Hackman, my bad.
Just got back from Les Mis

[DKDetective]

Originally Posted by I SEE SPIDEY

I don't want a Hackman like Lex. Hackman is a fine actor and played that version of Lex, which I assume was simular to the comicbook version at the time, as well as can be expected but we in the 2000's not 1978.

Actually, Hackman's Lex wasn't really at all similar to comic book Lex of that era. Much of the characterization was invented by the filmmakers out of the blue.

[Sawyer]

Originally Posted by Llama_Shepherd

Not so obvious when you use someone else's name.

But obvious enough to figure out that said actor wasn't even in the movies they were talking about.

[Rodrigo90]

Originally Posted by hopefuldreamer

Yeah, it's weird. I know Issacs is older... But he looks in the same age group as the other two to me. And, call me weird, but he's the sexy kind of older man. Which I really want from Lex. Not like 'Oh he's such a fittie', but just well groomed and charming.

Well I'm not going to call Benicio sexy by any means lol I'm sure other women out there think that, which they do, but I'm a straight guy, you know?
I've only seen Issac's as Lucius Malfoy, Hook and briefly in Resident Evil. I can't see him as Lex in those roles, but he could possibly do it, I'm sure you've seen him in more stuff than I...enough to make you think he's sexy lol

Age doesn't bother me that much. I know we want to see a younger Lex, but I just want to see a different Lex, thanks to the performances of Hackman and Spacey.

I won't keep harping on about him, but I see a lot of Lex potential in Del Toro.
From friendly and charming, cracking a smile and story like Rosenbaum...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BNtX...t=HL1357448285
To downright psycho
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NpymyOS70_w

That's what I see of Lex...could be from Del Toro, or another actor like him.

[hopefuldreamer]

Originally Posted by Sawyer

Obviously Hackman.

Well yeah... But this wouldn't be an internet message forum if someone didn't point it out like a douche

[Oberon sexton]

"Hack Man!"

[hopefuldreamer]

Originally Posted by Rodrigo90

Well I'm not going to call Benicio sexy by any means lol I'm sure other women out there think that, which they do, but I'm a straight guy, you know?
I've only seen Issac's as Lucius Malfoy, Hook and briefly in Resident Evil. I can't see him as Lex in those roles, but he could possibly do it, I'm sure you've seen him in more stuff than I...enough to make you think he's sexy lol

Age doesn't bother me that much. I know we want to see a younger Lex, but I just want to see a different Lex, thanks to the performances of Hackman and Spacey.

I won't keep harping on about him, but I see a lot of Lex potential in Del Toro.
From friendly and charming, cracking a smile and story like Rosenbaum...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BNtX...t=HL1357448285
To downright psycho
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NpymyOS70_w

That's what I see of Lex...could be from Del Toro, or another actor like him.

Well it's not 'sexy' exactly with Isaacs... he's just a good looking older man. And yeah, i'm getting it more from watching 'Awake'

I do get what you mean about Del Toro... I certainly wouldn't be bummed if Lex did turn out to be him.

[BH/HHH]

I know this gas been mentioned before by sone but on the Modern Myth Media podcast someone in there suggested Idris Elba for Lex Luthor. I have to say if they were to go against the comics version (Lex been a bald white male) to an a diverse version of Lex in Elba then I would be very on board with that.

[Project862006]

jason does look great for a near 50 year old man


he'd make a tough bad ass lex no doubt

[Lex Luthor]

Originally Posted by Rodrigo90

but I just want to see a different Lex, thanks to the performances of Hackman and Spacey.

That's a genuine requirement to fully get Lex over with modern audiences in this new franchise, and I agree. For whoever lands the role, the performance simply cannot be akin to what the previous live action films have already presented, and somehow expect it to be taken in with any enthusiasm.

[BH/HHH]

I have a question for everyone, do you think Lex needs to be bald in the MOS universe?

[Project862006]

i do but some people also thought superman with a spit curl,white perry, and a brunette lois lane were a sure thing lol

[BH/HHH]

Originally Posted by Project862006

i do but some people also thought superman with a spit curl,white perry, and a brunette lois lane were a sure thing lol

True lol

So do we think Lex has to be a bald white male?

[hopefuldreamer]

Originally Posted by Project862006

jason does look great for a near 50 year old man


he'd make a tough bad ass lex no doubt

Yup, and that's a pic of him in 'Awake', which was the show that made me change my mind about him being too old.

[godisawesome]

I'm for abald Lex in the sense that I think his baldness is like Superman's cape-it's part of his classic "costume." Luthor can be of whatever ethnicity or accent they want, but if Nick Fury gets an eye-patch, than Lex gets to be bald.

[Marvin]

The best live action lex so far as been on Lois and Clark imo.

Some might champion Smallville, but that would akin to championing Welling as the best superman so far. Which he ain't, due to context and a few other things.

Plus lex was mad dumb on Smallville.