Henry Cavill IS Superman: - - Part 11

[Dr.]

Originally Posted by DKDetective

It's definitely true about accents slipping during scenes where actors raise their voices or have to convey strong emotion, which is something that should give us pause regarding Cavill's performance in MOS. This is supposed to be a new take on Superman, meant to reinvigorate the brand and get people to care for the character again. Given the strong emotional themes this board has picked up on so far from spoilers and media coverage, it's likely that a lot of strong emotion and shouting will be required of Cavill. So there is some cause to be concerned.

CK will be American but Supes will have a British accent (for disguise purposes). So that reduces the chances of Cavill "slipping" by 50%.

[Szetsilya]

Natalie Portman is kooky? I think the term kooky is being confused with intelligent and educated.
I've always felt that Christipher Reeve had a god like face as Superman so it is hard to beat him. But I think Henry looks damn good in his Superman promos; like he could whoop Tom, Brandon and Dean Cain's butt in a fight.

[RachelDawes]

Originally Posted by DKDetective

No guarantee there. Look at the shouting match between Gordon and Dent in The Dark Knight where Oldman's English accent is blatantly showing through the entire scene.

I never thought Oldman sounded particularly English in TDK but there were times that his speech seemed odd. I wouldn't've pegged it as a foreign accent intruding if I hadn't known his background.

Originally Posted by BH/HHH

It happens a lot with British actors, look at Michael Fassbender in First Class his Irish accent comes out really badly at the end but he's so good you forgive it. The funny thing about Cavill's accent in Cold Light if Day is it sounds different to the one he did in Hellraiser which was actually closer to his MOS Superman voice.

Fassbender said he conceived as Magneto as having wandered around Europe for years so he would speak with a mishmash of accents. The Irish accent coming through was therefore not quite as strange as it seemed.

[BH/HHH]

Originally Posted by RachelDawes

I never thought Oldman sounded particularly English in TDK but there were times that his speech seemed odd. I wouldn't've pegged it as a foreign accent intruding if I hadn't known his background.



Fassbender said he conceived as Magneto as having wandered around Europe for years so he would speak with a mishmash of accents. The Irish accent coming through was therefore not quite as strange as it seemed.

I never bought that, the guy just went super Irish at the end. After having a different accent throughout the film.

[ThePowerCosmic]

Originally Posted by BH/HHH

I never bought that, the guy just went super Irish at the end. After having a different accent throughout the film.

Right? Just seems like Fassbender was attempting to cover-up the fact that he slipped and reverted to his normal accent.

[flickchick85]

Originally Posted by BH/HHH

I never bought that, the guy just went super Irish at the end. After having a different accent throughout the film.

Buy it or not, we know he could have done a straight English accent if he wanted (like McKellen's), because he's done it perfectly before. But he said he talked it over with Matthew Vaughn, who basically told him that he envisioned Magneto as a wanderer after his teenage days, so he should just use his natural accent (which is not straight Irish as some people seem to suggest here, but rather an Irish/German mix). So he wasn't doing an accent at all, just a suppressed version of his natural one. Sure it became less suppressed on the beach, but that's not "a different accent," and I honestly don't see why that would be problem within the framework of that backstory.

[Bren]

Haha, the guy slipped up on his accent, they didn't have time to shoot more, came up with a (lame) excuse for it........ and I actually don't care because he was still a brilliant Magneto.

If Superman sounds generic american throughout the film and slips up once or twice, I hope he's more honest about it, rather than some "my kryptonian roots show when under stress and yes kryptonians sound british" excuse hahaha.

Even if he did slip up, and make dumbass excuses... if he's genuinely good or better as Superman, again I won't care, and will thank him for the overall performance

[flickchick85]

Dude, they talked about that before anyone even saw the movie. His accent didn't "slip," as that implies he was doing an accent in the first place. It was the same throughout the entire movie, just heavier on the beach, NOT a different accent. And anyone who's watched his interviews knows that's his natural accent. It's not a "lame excuse."

This is his natural accent:

VIDEO-CLick to Watch!:

His accent as Magneto was just a lighter version of that. Heavier on the beach, but still the same accent.

[ThePowerCosmic]

It was a lame excuse. Let it go. Jesus, lmao.

Keep defending it all you want, but it changes nothing.

[flickchick85]

Originally Posted by ThePowerCosmic

It was a lame excuse. Let it go. Jesus, lmao.

Keep defending it all you want, but it changes nothing.

It's not an "excuse" at all, but whatevs. I thought you all were the ones who couldn't let this nitpick go, but if you wanna move on, let's. How 'bout that Superman? Faora's costume looks good. Seeing Amy Adams on Leno made me realize I hope Henry goes on shows like Kimmel, Fallon, Conan or Ferguson when he's promoting MoS. Those interviews tend to be looser and more fun. Wasn't he already on Leno for Immortals?

[ThePowerCosmic]

I have no idea, I'd love to see him on Conan though. That would be hilarious.

[flickchick85]

Originally Posted by ThePowerCosmic

I have no idea, I'd love to see him on Conan though. That would be hilarious.

I feel like Conan has a slight "in" with DC now, due to his work with DC animation, so I'm crossing my fingers for that one.

[ArmsHeldOut]

Originally Posted by FilmNerdJamie

Nah, his American accent sounds fine. Gotta keep in mind, garbage like The Cold Light of Day was the best thing he was getting offered and the dude had to eat.

I take more offense to Willis and Weaver doing it. Since they didn't need the money per say, but they could afford to be pickier. Took it and ran.

That they did my friend. At least Weaver stuck around for a bit though.

[ArmsHeldOut]

Originally Posted by flickchick85

Dude, they talked about that before anyone even saw the movie. His accent didn't "slip," as that implies he was doing an accent in the first place. It was the same throughout the entire movie, just heavier on the beach, NOT a different accent. And anyone who's watched his interviews knows that's his natural accent. It's not a "lame excuse."

This is his natural accent:

VIDEO-CLick to Watch!:

His accent as Magneto was just a lighter version of that. Heavier on the beach, but still the same accent.

It usually bugs me when actors/actresses don't adopt character accents properly, but Fassbender's performance as Magneto was so good that I wasn't bothered in the least by the way he sounded. His Magento was the best thing about that film, along with McAvoy's Xavier.

[BH/HHH]

Originally Posted by flickchick85

Dude, they talked about that before anyone even saw the movie. His accent didn't "slip," as that implies he was doing an accent in the first place. It was the same throughout the entire movie, just heavier on the beach, NOT a different accent. And anyone who's watched his interviews knows that's his natural accent. It's not a "lame excuse."

This is his natural accent:

VIDEO-CLick to Watch!:

His accent as Magneto was just a lighter version of that. Heavier on the beach, but still the same accent.

Sorry but that's a lame excuse why would his accent suddenly get heavier at the end of the film. I'd understand if he was surrounded by Irish people cause accents cone out more then but hey it doesn't bother me cause the guy was awesome but doesn't change the fact that he ****ed up.

[flickchick85]

Sorry, but we already established that I completely disagree, and moved on. Let's stick to that, yeah? I swear, if I never hear the lame excuse for a phrase that is "lame excuse" again, I'll be a happy woman. ...But I'd take some new MoS footage as consolation instead.

[Bren]

I hope Cavill hasn't felt the need to read from Fassbender's 'Book of lame excuses'

[flickchick85]

Originally Posted by Bren

I hope Cavill hasn't felt the need to read from Fassbender's 'Book of lame excuses'

But I know, I asked for that. I'll take my new MoS footage then, please.

[Project862006]

i have watched fc many time is never notice an accent slip maybe because magneto isn't an American character so it doesn't bother me at all nor do i notice it

[Batman jr.]

Talia's death was silly, but

1) it only lasts 5 seconds or so
2) it's nowhere near the "worst" ever
3) Oldman's accent never bothered me.

Thus, the word nitpicking is not as important to me as MOS.

[Batman jr.]

Originally Posted by Excelsior.

I question how detailed Nolan is on the acting side when he is fine with a take where Gary Oldman clearly breaks his American accent, or, the most incriminating, Talia's lame death. That was the best take Nolan could get, really?

I can answer that question. How is Gary Oldman's breaking of the accent ruining Nolan's great eye for casting? it's not.

[DKDetective]

Originally Posted by Batman jr.

I can answer that question. How is Gary Oldman's breaking of the accent ruining Nolan's great eye for casting? it's not.

But that is not Excelsior's point. There is more to being a "good actors' director" than just casting. It is about working with your actors on set, during takes, and getting the best possible performance out of them. Having one of your lead actor's accent slip very noticeably in a key dramatic scene and doing nothing about that is arguably something that can criticized.

[Batman jr.]

Originally Posted by DKDetective

But that is not Excelsior's point. There is more to being a "good actors' director" than just casting. It is about working with your actors on set, during takes, and getting the best possible performance out of them. Having one of your lead actor's accent slip very noticeably in a key dramatic scene and doing nothing about that is arguably something that can criticized.

Oldman gave his all in the three films, at least imho, and a few little accent slips won't change that. If that's the only thing to remark, well, then you are either sad or only in it to cry about everything. With that kind of attitude you won't be able to enjoy any movie. Ever.

[chamber-music]

I thought Cavill's American accent was fine in Blood Creek and The Cold Light of Day.

The Cold Light of Day was filmed in Spain and the only Americans in the film were Bruce Willis and Sigourney Weaver. The cast and crew were mostly European.

Man Of Steel was filmed in the U.S and Canada with most the cast and crew being American which will probably make it easier for him to do a American accent as he would of been hearing it all day long. I'm sure people on set would of said if his accent wasn't good enough as well.

[Excelsior.]

Originally Posted by Batman jr.

I can answer that question. How is Gary Oldman's breaking of the accent ruining Nolan's great eye for casting? it's not.

Not only did you not answer any question, you raised a false question from wrongly interpreting my words.