While both were heavily flawed, the first was far more entertaining. I felt like Returns just didn't make sense & Burton couldn't get out of the movie's way. I felt it contained a lot of stupid camp elements, ("In order to destroy Batman we must turn him into what he despises most"-I could so see Julie Newmar saying that) a lot of redundancy (killer clowns? Again?) HORRENDOUS dialogue (the "mistletoe" bit especially) and it just wasn't any fun for me. I've always hated the Penguin and turning him into a bizarre sideshow freak didn't change that. I felt Max was a completely unnecessary character and Batman himself didn't shine. He was more of a supporting character in Burton's world of oddities than a superhero. And he wasn't much of a hero at that. He didn't catch Catwoman, he didn't save the Ice Princess, (he just STOOD THERE!) killing Penguin was completely unnecessary-I could go on and on about what I didn't like about that movie. I've watched it 3 more times to see if I felt any differently & I still hate it. I actually found "Batman Forever" far more entertaining.