Sequels 5 Reasons

[Lando81]

5 reasons this movie will never happen.

5.Fox is going the wrong direction.

4.Ian McKellen is the only Magneto People want.

3.There can never be a young Magneto.

2.How can a Villian have Villians?

1.Wolverine will be a hit and get a Sequel not this film.

 

[Doctor of Doom]

5.Fox is going the wrong direction.

Impossible to say for sure. We don't know much about it yet.

4.Ian McKellen is the only Magneto People want.

Firstly, you can't say that for sure. Secondly, we might/will be getting McKellan for all/some of the film.

3.There can never be a young Magneto.

There is absoloutely nothing to back that up. I don't even understand what you mean. He has a vastly more itneresting background than Wolverine.

2.How can a Villian have Villians?

Firstly, the movie is about how he BECAME a villain thus for most of the movie he is not one. Secondly, Magneto is not a real 'villain' per se. Thirdly, it's very very easy to have an enemy of the main character, villain or no.

1.Wolverine will be a hit and get a Sequel not this film.

And that isn't even a reason why this movie won't be made.

 

[Lando81]

Whatev.

 

[Chris Wallace]

5. There's no real indication of WHAT direction Fox is going in.
4. That's like saying Christopher Reeve is the only Superman people want, or David Prowse is the only Darth Vader people want. Both of these were proven false. Is Michael Keaton the only Batman people want?
3. I again refer you to Darth Vader. And it's basically the same principle. How he became Magneto & why.
2. A villain can have villains, but he won't even be a villain yet. But as for how, ever heard of Stryker?
1. What happens w/Wolverine has no bearing on anything w/Magneto.
In short, none of your reasons are valid.

 

[Charlie No-One]

If they have an excellent story and Ian Mckellen is in it for a little bit, the movie will be fine. Since we do not know any of these details though, you can't say this movie will not be made and/or will be bad.

 

[Chris Wallace]

Precisely.

 

[Halcohol]

You know, I'm of the opinion that we got all we needed about Magneto's motivations and background from X-Men.

He was imprisoned and tortured for being different.

Now he's powerful.

What more do you need? This is a ridiculous idea for a movie that, even if it gets made, will make absolutely no money. Just another cash-cow idea from Fox that will never materialize.

 

[Cyrusbales]

Am I the only one who thinks It'l be an interesting stroll through history with a twist? I'm lookign forward to it! And they're making it, so tough luck to all the haters!

 

[Gamma Burst]

You know, I'm of the opinion that we got all we needed about Magneto's motivations and background from X-Men.

He was imprisoned and tortured for being different.

Now he's powerful.

What more do you need? This is a ridiculous idea for a movie that, even if it gets made, will make absolutely no money. Just another cash-cow idea from Fox that will never materialize.

Exactly.

 

[DA Harvey Dent]

 

[cardslinger]

Am I the only one who thinks It'l be an interesting stroll through history with a twist? I'm lookign forward to it! And they're making it, so tough luck to all the haters!

You're not alone. I'm looking forword to this movie more than the Wolverine movie. Magneto is an intoresting character with an intoresting past. Why not show it on the big screen?

 

[Chris Wallace]

Am I the only one who thinks It'l be an interesting stroll through history with a twist? I'm lookign forward to it! And they're making it, so tough luck to all the haters!

The only one? Far from it.

 

[Turtletron2.0]

theres plenty of story to tell. anyone who dissagrees has no idea what theyre talking about. it will be a good movie

 

[Boba_Fett_123]

...What the hell?

 

[ElectroFlare]

4. That's like saying Christopher Reeve is the only Superman people want, or David Prowse is the only Darth Vader people want. Both of these were proven false. Is Michael Keaton the only Batman people want?

You should have used Adam West. That would have proven your point even more.

 

[chaseter]

Uhhh Laura just said that the Mags movie is in development so this thread is pretty useless...

 

[Galact-Gal]

You know, I'm of the opinion that we got all we needed about Wolverine's motivations and background from X-Men.

He was imprisoned and tortured for being different.

Now he hangs out with the X-Men.

What more do you need? This is a ridiculous idea for a movie that, even if it gets made, will make absolutely no money. Just another cash-cow idea from Fox that will never materialize.

See how easy it is to say that about the X-Man of your choice?
I'll admit Hugh Jackman is incredibly sexy, but I'm more interested in Magneto's character than in Wolverine's.

 

[Chris Wallace]

You should have used Adam West. That would have proven your point even more.

Maybe you're right.

 

[lilboo]

will they be using ian mckellen with cgi effect or a whole other actor for the role of mags

 

[Chris Wallace]

Since this is supposedly going to take place before he ever wore a cape-possibly before he even met Xavier-I'm thinking it'll be a different actor, w/McKellen possibly in the final shot.

 

[Crimson_L]

See how easy it is to say that about the X-Man of your choice?
I'll admit Hugh Jackman is incredibly sexy, but I'm more interested in Magneto's character than in Wolverine's.

Same. I'm actualy interested in this movie, Wolverine I am not.

 

[Mysterio]

Whatev.

Funny, that was my reaction when i saw your post.

 

[Papa Burgundy]

2.How can a Villian have Villians?

they can do something kind of like episode three. they can show him before he went all, bad then show how he became the person he is.obiviously, someone or something had to happen for him to become who he is.

 

[Charlie No-One]

Also, if you are evil, wouldn't YOUR villain be people who good? So yeah bad guys can have bad guys.

 

[GREEN =w= DAY]

See how easy it is to say that about the X-Man of your choice?
I'll admit Hugh Jackman is incredibly sexy, but I'm more interested in Magneto's character than in Wolverine's.

same here!! aside from Wolverine, i think the character that stood out the most for me in all 3 films was Magneto. i especially liked some of his lines:

"Hell hath no fury like a woman's scorn."
"Never trust a beautiful woman, especially one that is interested in you" t:

Ian McKellan MADE that role his. i hope he takes part in this film one way or another. maybe as a narrator.