Comics ASM #613... preview and spoilers...

^^ My god, that looks great! Also, I have to say, I LOVE the fact that DItko's art is on the cover. It's like, a "launch" back to 1963. :up:
 
That isn't Ditko's art. It's just an impression by Quinones.
 
That isn't Ditko's art. It's just an impression by Quinones.

If it is, he did a great job... I thought it was from ASM Annual #1...

AmazingSpider-ManAnnual01.jpg
 
Wow... that does look nice.
Hey you don't mind if I borrow that this weekend do you? I've never read that particular issue.
 
All right, might as well go ahead and say what I have to say about this issue:

*Mark Waid turns in a adequate script here, but that’s all it is--adequate. Oh sure, we’ve got some nice scenes here, especially towards the end with Spider-Man making fun of the fact that the Mad Thinker is not really a threat, and also how Electro has “the worst battle cry in the world.” Also, it’s essentially your patented Spider-Man dilemma in which even though he’s the hero, the public sees him as a villain as opposed to the actual villain (and at least, in this instance, there’s some justification for why they see Electro as a populist crusader). Yet, at the same time, there are plot developments which seem cut from your standard superhero comic clichés, such as the resolution the last issues cliffhanger with Spidey escaping the mob by going through a conveniently place manhole cover without them noticing. Or Mad Thinker’s lab assistant suddenly realizing just what bad people she’s really working for. Or Dexter Bennet making a deal with Electro only the find out he’s been double-crossed.

*Also, this issue solidifies my belief that the Ultimate Marvel line was partially created to test ideas to eventually bring into the 616, as now Electro becomes a full-fledged energy being just like his Ultimate counterpart (as well as the MTV Spider-Man and Spectacular Spider-Man cartoon). Perhaps Marvel decided to do this because they believe Electro becoming living lightning is the character those outside of comics are familiar with. Whatever, it really not as big of a deal as the comic makes it out to be.

*The other problem this issue has is that, when it comes to the new characters, we’re not really given a reason to care about them. Michelle Gonzales, in both scenes she appears in, is basically nothing more than a hot-tempered harpy, although at least it’s not limited to Peter this time around (and boy are her days numbered now! She is officially on Aunt May’s “You’re no good for my precious nephew” **** list). The same goes with Dexter Bennet, as his role could have been played by any stock “crooked businessman” character, although I did think Electro threatening him in the tub was somewhat effective. Maybe it’s because it seems like a have sneaking suspicion that the story is going to end with the Daily Bugle destroyed and Bennet ruined, which would be the obvious outcome to this story.

*And as for Paul Azaceta’s art, I know that last week I thought it worked well for the story, but this time around it just seemed unfinished and muted to me. Not to mention the action sequences involving Spidey and Electro looked especially stiff, with no real sense of dynamism or movement. And yes, you really get to see the inconsistency of the character’s facial features this time around.

So, all in all, while it’s a decent enough Spider-Man story, it unfortunately feels like Waid is just phoning it in. Perhaps being Editor-in-Chief of Boom! Studios in which he’s personally involved with comics like Irremediable, Potter’s Field, and The Unknown take up too much of his time, energy, and effort, because he‘s definitely a stronger writer than this. This story would be fine if it were just a regular arc of Amazing Spider-Man, but not something that’s supposed to kick off a major long-running storyline like “The Gauntlet.” I guess we’ll see how Waid wraps this up in two weeks.
 
Happy Thanksgiving, to those who celebrate! Here are my thoughts:

Had a laugh-out-loud moment. Spidey's silly and that's part of the reason I relate to him. He's probably the only character who could get away with this sort of battle introduction: "Mind keeping it down? The whole neighborhood can hear you cackling maniacally and... Hey! It's The Mad Thinker!"

I'm getting tired of the art with the square bodies and thin arms, it's probably ok for a one-shot, but maybe not so for three issues. Or maybe the yucky yellow background in the beginning threw me off this one. Gotta admit though, I'm still attracted to Michelle. She's wrapped in a towel. Maybe Pete should give it to her again, then have her later explain it all away. I think I'm into it. Oh, plus the artist draws Electro well when he's all agnsty or threatening like (Electro stands over Bennett as the poor guy's bathing in his bathroom tub. Not a place you'd want to see Electro!)

Petey gets all gadgety to track down Electro's electrical impulses. Yes. Spidey's embracing his inner scientist again. I love when that happens. The Mad Thinker induces Electro with weird bacteriophages, powering him up, and announces; "Behold, Electro 2.0!!! But in reality he's like 3.2 or something since this isn't the first time Electro received an upgrade. Oh well.

Other things happen, like Aunt May and her hubby swinging by Pete's place unannounced only to get yelled at by Michelle. How rude. Oh, and Electro can travel as an electrical current now, like on the Spectacular Spider-Man animated series.

Another B-, and I'm sensing a C sinker, next ish. (The cliffhanger didn't make much sense to me. Electro asks publicly for all his supporters to turn on their lights, so he can charge up even more? Err... just go to the power station, man!)

---------------------------------
Combustible Pumpkins
 
okedey doke, Just finished writing the review. Below is exactly what I have been posting on all other forums.

I have read and re-read the issue, hoping to find something more interesting to grasp my interest in the ASM Comics again.
Read my review here

http://www.spidermanreviews.com/2009/11/amazing-spider-man-613.html

Overall, not the very best issue. Still better than ASM 611 or 612. Dexter Bennet is remarkable. As if he could not forsee that Electro, the crook in the story was going to double cross him. Furthermore, I do not see the great threat in Electro's video on youtube. Sure, he wants all the lights on so he can get lots of power of something. Nonetheless, all Dexter has to do is inform some authorities, turn off the electrical supply for the night and let spider-man come up with an idea to stop him.

Michelle, I re-dislike, if I may say so. I have to say that it has to do with her being drawn like a barbarian. Especially when Aunt May and JJ s. pop by. Read my review for the overall rating.
 
How many times has Electro been revamped or shown to be "more powerful than before"?
Light the Night? In the 90's when X-Man helped Spidey? Marvel Knights? Breaking prisoners out of the raft? Now this...

How many more times will Electro be revamped or shown to be "more powerful than before"? God only knows.
 
I want the old costume, not this InFamous meets Ultimate Electro look.
 
Common, let's be honest. Every time they change Electro's costume it's really subtle. His look never changes. It's always the green with the lightning bolts, and some sort of star lightning bolt on his face.
 
http://www.newsarama.com/php/multimedia/album.php?aid=32037

I have to say that the art is growing on me... has a Vertigo feel, which is unusual for Spider-Man, but I like it here... and how awesome is it to see some Ditko art on that ASM varient cover (even if it is old art)...

:word: :word: :word:

:yay:

That art is ugly as heck. That might well be one of the ugliest comic pages I've ever seen. Electro looks terrible. It looks like an Archie comic or something.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
201,134
Messages
21,905,830
Members
45,702
Latest member
Nsl1354
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"