Batman Elimination Game: Round 23 - Most Significant Moment

Mister J

Enlightened to the Great Darkness
Staff member
Joined
Jul 23, 2005
Messages
39,243
Reaction score
477
Points
73
Batman Elimination Game: Most Significant Moment

Olly Olly Oxen Free!! The Michael Jordan Commemorative Round (#23 for the sports-impaired) brings the fascinating inquiry of what moment in Batman's history stands out as the most significant. Alternatively, think of it as what made you say "Holy ****! :eek:" the loudest. For obvious reasons, the murder of Thomas and Martha Wayne will be excluded. Primarily, because it's the clear choice. Secondly, if any of you voted against it, I'd have Dew ban you on the spot. :cmad: To a lesser degree, this is also true as to why Batman's inital confrontation with the Red Hood was not included.

Basic Rules: You subtract one point from a moment you don't like and add a point onto another moment that you do like, until (much like the drink minumum on No Cover Night at the Nudie Bar) there is only one. You can only post once in 60 minutes, meaning every 60 minutes you can vote to give everyone a chance.

Yep, this idea was mine, but I don't wanna talk about it. ...seriously. ... there's nothing else here. ...I'm not to write anything else. ...I don't know what you're waiting for.

Guys, please be careful with your posts. These games are subject to getting off track with missed tallies due to simple error. After your post, please check that it accurately reflects what you wanted and that no other post came through before you were able to submit yours. Also, if you see an error has been made, feel free to call attention to it or correct it yourself with another post. Thanx. :up:


Alright people. Remember to put your left in and take your right foot out.:batty:

Becoming a member of the Justice League 10
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 10
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 10
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 10
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 10
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 10
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 10
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 10
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 10
Talia's revelation of Damian 10
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 9 (-)
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 10
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 10
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 10
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 10
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 10
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 10
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11 (+)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 10
Talia's revelation of Damian 10
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 9
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 10
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 10
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 11 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 10
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 10
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 10
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 10
Talia's revelation of Damian 9 (-)
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 9
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 10
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 10
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 11
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 9 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 11 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 10
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 10
Talia's revelation of Damian 9

When did he find out the JLA mindwiped him?
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 8 (-)
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 10
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 10
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 11
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 9
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 11
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 10
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 12 (+)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 10
Talia's revelation of Damian 9

JTStarkiller said:
When did he find out the JLA mindwiped him?

In Identity Crisis. He then created Brother I and it was hijacked basically and misused. That is why Infinite Crisis occured.
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 8
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 10
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 10
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 11
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 9
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 11
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11 (+)
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11 (-)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 10
Talia's revelation of Damian 9
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 8
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 10
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 10
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 11
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 11
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11 (+)
Talia's revelation of Damian 9
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 8
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 10
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 10
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 12 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8 (-)
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 11
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 8 (-)
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 8
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 10
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 10
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 13 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 11
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 7 (-)
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 8
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 9 (-)
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 10
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 13
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 12 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 7
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 8
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 9
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 10
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 14 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 12
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 6 (-)
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 7 (-)
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 9
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 10
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 14
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 12
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 12 (+)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 6
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 7
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 9
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11 (+)
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 14
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 12
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11 (-)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 6
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 7
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 9
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 14
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 10
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 13 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 5 (-)

Good list Mister J.
 
Fledermaus said:
Good list Mister J.
YES!! Sweet, sweet validation. :up:

The rest of you are officially on the same list as the holdout dentist who didn't recommend this game. :cmad:


Becoming a member of the Justice League 7
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 9
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 14
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11 (+)
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 13
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 10 (-)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 5
 
Umm.... *cough cough* sweet game Mister J!:up: :up: :up:
;)

Becoming a member of the Justice League 7
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 9
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 15 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 13
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 10
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 4 (-)

Also, I just had to say I'm glad to see these games have lasted as long as they have. The Spider-Man ones seemed to have died away.
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 7
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 8 (-)
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 15
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 14 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 10
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 10
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 4
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 6 (-)
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 9
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 15
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 13
The death of Stephanie Brown 11 (+)
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 10
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 4
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 6
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 9
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 16 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 13
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 10
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 3 (-)
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 6
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 9
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 17 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 13
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 10
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 11
Talia's revelation of Damian 2 (-)
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 6
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 9
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 10
Bane breaking his back 17
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 13
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 10
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 12 (+)
Talia's revelation of Damian 1 (-)
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 6
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 9
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11 (+)
Bane breaking his back 17
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 13
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 10
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 12
Talia's revelation of Damian 0 (-) I can't stand that damn Damian.
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 6
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 8 (-)
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 17
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 14 (+)
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 10
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 12
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 5 (-)
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 8
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 17
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 14
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11 (+)
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 12
 
Becoming a member of the Justice League 4 (-)
His falling out with Dick Grayson (firing him as Robin) 8
The Joker crippling Barbara Gordon 11
The death of Jason Todd 11
Bane breaking his back 18 (+)
Losing Gordon's trust (due to Azrael's actions as 'Batman') 10
Trying to preserve Gotham City during No Man's Land 11
Being framed for the murder of Vesper Fairchild 10
The revelation of Hush's identity 8
Revealing his identity to Catwoman 14
The death of Stephanie Brown 11
Discovering fellow JLA members had mindwiped him/Creation of the Brother I satellite 11
Discovering that Jason Todd is alive 11
Adopting Tim Drake as his son 12
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"