Batman Vs. Superman Who Would Win

Who would WIn Batman vs. SUperman?

  • Batman

  • Superman

  • Batman

  • Superman

Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
In movie verse, Batman has been taken from "one of the highest intellects in the DCU" to "of gifted intelligence". He is not even half the man he is in that regard. The movie probably puts him on par with DareDevil maybe, but probably along the lines of the Phantom (comic version) or Wildcat. He is certainly not the best battle tactician. Certainly not the wiz he is supposed to be at science (should I understand any of that?) and certainly possesses no krytonite. He would get owned.
 
In recent comic continuality, Superman. Anyway.

He got his supermind back and it was upgraded.

The only way, and I mean only, is if Batman had enough kryptonite to surround a whole suit of iron armor, and hope to get a sneak attack off. But, with Supermans "I'm listening to 50 different news confrences and TV reports, as well as flying to save some people", I'm pretty sure he'de hear Batmans elevated heartbeat comming closer and closer.
 
Well since this is listed in the DC Comics film board, I take it that it's basically Christian Bale's Batman vs. Brandon Routh's Superman?

Bale/Batman would win this soooo easily.
 
ShadowBoxing said:
In movie verse, Batman has been taken from "one of the highest intellects in the DCU" to "of gifted intelligence". He is not even half the man he is in that regard. The movie probably puts him on par with DareDevil maybe, but probably along the lines of the Phantom (comic version) or Wildcat. He is certainly not the best battle tactician. Certainly not the wiz he is supposed to be at science (should I understand any of that?) and certainly possesses no krytonite. He would get owned.
Click to expand...

Well, if they do a Superman Batman movie and Batman never gets his hand on any Kryptonite during the course of said movie, someone has missed the basic idea boat.

Nolan's Bat is still rich and resourceful, and not afriad to use it. Singerman is simply easy to get the drop on. He's a great guy, but not all that perceptive. Nolan's Bat with some K equals a good multi-fight conflict. Batman and Superman randomly fighting out of thin air OR Batman and Superman holding hands and skipping happily together towards the bad guy in instant friendship is insane.
 
dpm07 said:
Given time to prepare, Batman. In a straight up battle no time to prepare, Superman.
Click to expand...
I hate this "given time to prepare BS". It's not like any fight starts with Superman sending Batman a month in advance letter saying "I am coming to beat you: and here is how".
 
GL1 said:
Well, if they do a Superman Batman movie and Batman never gets his hand on any Kryptonite during the course of said movie, someone has missed the basic idea boat.

Nolan's Bat is still rich and resourceful, and not afriad to use it. Singerman is simply easy to get the drop on. He's a great guy, but not all that perceptive. Nolan's Bat with some K equals a good multi-fight conflict. Batman and Superman randomly fighting out of thin air OR Batman and Superman holding hands and skipping happily together towards the bad guy in instant friendship is insane.
Click to expand...
He may be rich and resourceful but a guy who cannot kept his closely guarded identity from Lucius Fox and cannot solve a mystery without the help of Gordon is not really at all on par with the Batman of the comics. The Batman who so frequently finds himself the object of debate. Batman Begins Batman, while certainly a great version of Batman, is really a glorified ninja. He doesn't design his own tech whether he assembles some of it or not. So unless Waynetech is going to be ordered to create anti-superman armor and nuclear weapons which Wayne can cart home from applied science, there is no contest.

Also Superman of Singerverse may be not the brightest of the bunch. But he can withstand an Island full of Krytonite for a considerable amount of time and lift said Island over his head. He is massively strong in ways comic Superman hasn't been in a while apparently.

Also unlike comics, Batman's Nolanverse is extremely grounded. Someone as fast, as strong, as powerful as Kal El would hand Batman his a$$ in this Universe.

Simply put, the only character written not on par with his comic counterpart in terms of the question posed, is Batman. Resouceful as he may be he is obviously a far cry from the 158 martial art master, super-genius, Olympic athlete. Batman is the one who is at a chronic disadvantage in a Superman fight. Even if one includes the DKR other continuity battle. Batman has no definitive win against Superman, whereas Superman has thrashed Bats to near death.
 
daveswb said:
That's a picture from the dark knight returns. No infact Superman is not killed ny Batman there. Batman uses Kryptonite on him first and then starts fighting him. Getting in a few cheap shots. After Supes gets away from the Kryptonite the armor Bats is wearing breaks when it hit Supes. And Superman kills batman. Though we find out later he faked his death.
Click to expand...
Thanks for clearing this up :up: I hate people who say Batman killed Supes in DKR. It is the first sign that they have not bothered to read DKR.
 
Like I said, physically Superman would kill Batman. Mentally, Batman can break Superman down easily just with mind games, which could innately weaken him. Batman has told him off on more than one occasion, and knows full well he could snap him in half, yet he continues to talk to him like he's a mere mortal.
 
terry78 said:
Like I said, physically Superman would kill Batman. Mentally, Batman can break Superman down easily just with mind games, which could innately weaken him. Batman has told him off on more than one occasion, and knows full well he could snap him in half, yet he continues to talk to him like he's a mere mortal.
Click to expand...
That is also because Batman is extremely arrogant and untrusting of power (hence the spy satillite). Batman tends to think he is always right. I suppose that is why when Superman accidentally hand him his a$$ on the Watchtower it was such a hit to his ego. Being an a$$hole when you talk to someone is not winning a fight. And as others point out, Superman is intelligent. He wouldn't fall for some "mere mortal" bullsh** if provoked. Darkseid and Mongul, for example, touts the same mere mortal attitude when talking to Superman and have found themselves both defeated by Kal El. Batman is just Superman's friend, so Superman who generally holds back on humans, won't kill him. But as we have seen in issues such as "Lex Luthor Man of Steel" all the smarts in the batworld cannot save Bruce when Superman actually wants to fight him.
 
Naminton said:
NOt always the case. You see? The writer let supervillians damage Superman for a reason, For THE ENTERTAINMENT DAMN IT! if Every movie, comics, Superman just Beat the living crap out of all the villian, then it wouldn't make the story interesting! accept it! Can anybody move a whole planet like superman? :/
Click to expand...
You've not only shown me that you know nothing of Superman, but you've also shown me that you are an idiot.
 
boywonder13 said:
People would think that Superman would beat Batman, but in the Dark Knight Returns, by Frank miller. Batman actually KILLS Superman. This battle is not one sided at all. What do you guys Think.
Click to expand...
Um . . . no . . . Batman NEVER killed Superman in The Dark Knight Returns. Bats just beat him bloody had a faked stroke and a funeral WHICH SUPES ATTENDED!!! Go read that book again and come back later.
 
batbat_29640 said:
Um . . . no . . . Batman NEVER killed Superman in The Dark Knight Returns. Bats just beat him bloody had a faked stroke and a funeral WHICH SUPES ATTENDED!!! Go read that book again and come back later.
Click to expand...
I don't think he read the book to begin with. He probably just saw a couple scanned pictures and made his own weird conclusions.
 
It's like this. Superman fanboys are gonna say Superman. Batman fanboys are gonna say Batman. Those of us who actually "READ" the comics know for sure . . . You guys can argue all you want. We know the truth. Ya want real answers come to us . . . not sayin we're gonna give em right away but we do know the answer.
 
If we're going off the recent movie characters Bales Batman would easily beat Rouths weeping stalker Superman:o
 
The video I posted clearly shows, if Superman really wants to beat Batman he would end up killing him. If Batman pushed him far to over the edge.
 
This thread < Every other thread on the Hype.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

T
  • Poll Poll
(BB) BATMAN vs SUPERMAN (SR) Who would win???
Replies
13
Views
3K
Firehawk
F
venom628
World venom vs carnage who would win?
2 3
Replies
66
Views
10K
Astrø
Astrø
spidermanJLA!~
  • Poll Poll
Batman vs Batman! Who would win?!
Replies
5
Views
2K
DRMRSIR
D
Johnny Drama
Who would win in a fight? [The VS Game]
4 5 6
Replies
137
Views
11K
djchristensen
djchristensen
hippie_hunter
  • Poll Poll
Who would win: Batman vs. Chuck Norris
2 3
Replies
73
Views
8K
trustyside-kick
trustyside-kick

Staff online

Members online

Total: 4,760 (members: 38, guests: 4,722)

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,351
Messages
22,090,227
Members
45,886
Latest member
Elchido

Share this page

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"