Comics Best BND Writer?

[Kirk Langstrom]

Out of Spidey's current "Braintrust" of writers, who do you think had the best arc so far?

 

[Spider-ManHero12]

I loved them all, but since we can only choose one, I guess I will have to pick Dan Slott.

 

[Blader5489]

Slott is better in terms of plotting, but Wells does a better job with the dialogue. Tough pick.

I guess ultimately I choose Slott, but Wells really impressed me with this last arc, so I look forward to more stuff from him.

 

[iloveclones]

I went with Slott, but it was a tough choice with Wells. Dan got the edge because he had a tougher job. But it's like having Crosby and Malkin on the same team. I'm in no hurry for either one to explore free agency....

 

[Themanofbat]

While I will enjoy Slott's story's overall more often, I liked Guggenheim's story the best...

Unfortunately for Slott, he had to handle the "cram all the new" stuff within his short three issues, and it didn't play up to his strengths as a writer... strengths that we will no doubt see in his future stories.

And Wells really came on strong as well...

Gale, unfortunately, had two mediocre issues, though came through with his third issue, and it looks like he'll need some time to work the "craft" when it comes to comicbook storytelling.

 

[DestinyMakerX]

I personally didn't like Slott's that much, Guggenheim's was okay, but it was really between Gale and Wells. I ended up going with Wells; I loved his story the most.

 

[wolvie2020]

For me it was Slott hands down

He smacked the proverbial boty 6 ways from Sunday as an opener IMO.

McNiven's art really did help him though

 

[Donald Thomas]

Aloha,
I choose Slott. But as TMOB said, he had the hardest task. He was the lead off runner in a marathon relay filled with great controversy. When I compared the first 12 issues of Amazing v.2 with the first 12 issues of BND, I found a great improvement.
Spidey rules