Best comic film this year?

[phillip phonix]

what was the best comic book film in 2007? - sorry i did not include 300 i forgot

 

[arachnid-guy]

Spider-Man 3. [Even though I have not seen TF]

Basically, Spider-Man had more heart than GR or FF2. Sure, some parts were bad- but on the whole, out of the list given, S-M3 would have my vote.

 

[Kevin Roegele]

What is Transformers doing in there?

 

[Spider-Fan]

WTF with Transformers

Anyways, Spider-Man 3.

 

[CFE]

What is Transformers doing in there?

He's probably basing it on the numerous comic Transformers projects.

As for comic book based films, which were all disappointing this year (Ghost Rider, Spidey 3, FF2) I will say SM3 was the most entertaining of the three.

But not a good year for CB films. Hopefully TDK, IM and Hulk will change that for 08.

CFE

 

[CConn]

300.

 

[The Shredder]

300.

Yup.

 

[arachnid-guy]

300.

Oh yeah! I mightve reconsidered my post if 300 was included.

 

[see-m]

please people..dont vote for the crap called spider man 3! it was the most embarrassing comic movie in a long time!

 

[Kevin Roegele]

He's probably basing it on the numerous comic Transformers projects.


CFE

Probably. Which is very silly.

 

[Spider-Fan]

Spider-Man 3 > 300

 

[Rezzo]

Transformers doesn´t belong on the list, 300 should have been included on the list and it also wins easily

 

[CFE]

Can't believe I forgot 300. Yeah, that wins easily.

Techincally, we also forgot about "TMNT" and the Dark Horse-based property "Pathfinder," but I heard "TMNT" was sub-par and "Pathfinder" was utter dogs**t, so...

I denouce my original Spidey 3 vote; 300 gets my official vote.

CFE

 

[co2]

This year was overall just disapointing.
I'd rank the ones I have seen as
1. 300 (not my cup o' tea, but was definitely a good movie)
2. Spider-man 3 (Simply diapointing, because it could have been so much more)
3. FF: Rise of the Silver Surfer (can't call it disapointing, because it actually met expectations...which were average and dismissable.)
4. Ghost Rider (OK, it was just plain bad.)

 

[chiefchirpa]

Transformers hands down. It's the only comic movie that I've desire and actually watched twice.

 

[chiefchirpa]

Transformers doesn´t belong on the list, 300 should have been included on the list and it also wins easily

The poll is half-right, there are Transformers comics. I vote TF because the others were disappointing to me, yeah including the much-hyped film with sweaty dudes 300.

 

[Rezzo]

The poll is half-right, there are Transformers comics. I vote TF because the others were disappointing to me, yeah including the much-hyped film with sweaty dudes 300.

Sure there are comics of Transformers but it´s more known for the cartoons and toys rather than the comics. When you think of Transformers what do you think of the cartoons and toys or the comics?

 

[Warhammer]

Even though Transformers has the right to be considered a comic book film, I will never consider it one. With that said, the best (and only good) comic book film this year is 300, without a doubt.

 

[chiefchirpa]

Sure there are comics of Transformers but it´s more known for the cartoons and toys rather than the comics. When you think of Transformers what do you think of the cartoons and toys or the comics?

Both

Uh okay if TF is out, then it's 300 > F4 2 > SM3 >>>> GR

If TF is in (in category like best Summer movie or best movie with toys), you would vote TF too right?

 

[Rezzo]

Both

Uh okay if TF is out, then it's 300 > F4 2 > SM3 >>>> GR

If TF is in (in category like best Summer movie or best movie with toys), you would vote TF too right?

I'd put Transformers behind 300 mostly because I didn't enjoy anything from the movie other than the visual effects and Shia Labeouf´s performance, other than that the movie was pretty mediocre with the story and character development for both the Autobots and Decepticons

 

[chiefchirpa]

Well to me, 300 it's just a screaming sweaty dudes performance with small substance. And annoying cinematography obviously.

 

[Green Goblin 1964]

Spider-Man 3 is my favorite of the trilogy Period and it's my favorite of 2007.

Spidey trilogy kicks arse!

Spider-Man 3>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>ALL!

 

[co2]

Well to me, 300 it's just a screaming sweaty dudes performance with small substance. And annoying cinematography obviously.

I kinda agree. And I feel the same about Transformers...only no screaming sweaty dudes.

Honestly, I wasn't happy with any comic related film this year

 

[chiefchirpa]

I kinda agree. And I feel the same about Transformers...only no screaming sweaty dudes.

Actually TF has little substance too, but the FX is mindboggling and it has exceeded our low "it's gonna suck" expectation.

 

[co2]

All I know is I was just waiting for TF to end in that last half hour.