blueharvest
Eternal
- Joined
- May 8, 2008
- Messages
- 76,328
- Reaction score
- 51,967
- Points
- 103
10 years after the first movie
Their biggest issue is leadership. Tired and way past expiry.
Should have been gone yesterday.
Eh. I think thats quite a harsh decision given worse creatives got to stay with more dismal effort:I do think it's time to send Kevin Feige on his way at this point. He clearly had no idea how to manage this slate or play the long game story after the Infinity Saga/Endgame.
Eh. I think thats quite a harsh decision given worse creatives got to stay with more dismal effort:
- Zack Snyder with WB
- Michael Bay with Transformers
- Simon with the X-Men
Marvel Studios isn't a sinking ship yet, given the good reception to the Fantastic 4 and Deadpool & Wolverine. Those are not Bvs, Dark Phoenix, Dark of the Moon level that you go on to fire the main producer.
Snyder was with Wb for a long time (from 2004 when he was hired to direct 300, to the year he was replaced by Joss Whedon.) Mind you, he directed mid to bad movies which imo is a bigger offense than Feige producing bad movies.Snyder is not a good example in this argument look at what happened to him. Also, his tenure was nowhere near as long as Feige.
He didn't head an entire cinematic universe specifically, and even when Man of Steel came out in 2013, that wasn't fully seen as the start of a universe in the same way that Iron Man was. Not to mention he left partially due to a personal tragedy in his family. If anything, the downfall of the DCEU equally lies with Warner Bros. Snyder wasn't calling the shots by the time stuff like Blue Beetle and Aquaman 2 came out.Snyder was with Wb for a long time (from 2004 when he was hired to direct 300, to the year he was replaced by Joss Whedon.) Mind you, he directed mid to bad movies which imo is a bigger offense than Feige producing bad movies.
- Watchmen and 300 are mid movies.
- Legends of the Guardians, Sucker Punch, Man of Steel, Bvs are poorly reviewed movies.
Nothing great came from Zack Snyder when he was under Warner Bros. I don't give him credit for producing Wonder Woman as that was Patty's work.
Endgame was 6 years ago, and since then Kevin Feige produced No Way Home, Shang-Chi, Wakanda Forever, Fantastic 4, Thunderbolts and Deadpool & Wolverine - none of those films are dumpster fire films that you go ahead and fire him. Also, if you fire him, who would take in charge overseeing these films?
Vile is right this isn't a good comparison. Snyder directing other movies WB doesn't compare to Feige's tenure because they had nothing to do with the DCEU. Heck even when he was making MoS, he wasn't planning a whole universe. That didn't come until after MoS was released.Snyder was with Wb for a long time (from 2004 when he was hired to direct 300, to the year he was replaced by Joss Whedon.) Mind you, he directed mid to bad movies which imo is a bigger offense than Feige producing bad movies.
- Watchmen and 300 are mid movies.
- Legends of the Guardians, Sucker Punch, Man of Steel, Bvs are poorly reviewed movies.
Nothing great came from Zack Snyder when he was under Warner Bros. I don't give him credit for producing Wonder Woman as that was Patty's work.
The point is Zack Snyder had a bad track record with WB and they should have let him go right after Mos instead of giving more chances with directing BVS/Justice League.He didn't head an entire cinematic universe specifically, and even when Man of Steel came out in 2013, that wasn't fully seen as the start of a universe in the same way that Iron Man was. Not to mention he left partially due to a personal tragedy in his family. If anything, the downfall of the DCEU equally lies with Warner Bros. Snyder wasn't calling the shots by the time stuff like Blue Beetle and Aquaman 2 came out.
Also, way to cherry pick movies. Feige also produced The Marvels, Black Widow, The Eternals, Ant-Man and the Wasp Quantumania, is an executive producer on shows like Secret Invasion, and next to none of those products are good (though Eternals isn't as bad as some make it out to be). He may not have as many strikes on his record, but there are strikes.
I just think this suggestion of @TheVileOne of firing Kevin Feige is irrational and really doesn't make sense, unless they already have someone in mind that could a better job overseeing this franchise. I doubt it!
The point is Zack Snyder had a bad track record with WB and they should have let him go right after Mos instead of giving more chances with directing BVS/Justice League.
Inbetween products like Love and Thunder, Marvels, Brave New World, Quantumania - Feige was also responsible to movies like No Way Home, Thunderbolts, deadpool & Wolverine, First Steps, Wakanda Forever. I highly doubt Feige was deeply invested to those countless mcu shows. WandaVision, sure. Echo/Secret Invasion, I doubt it.
Feige acknowledges the fact they focused on quantity rather than quality, and they are now trying to steer the ship in the right direction.
He's not saying Feige should have been fired, he's saying that Feige should have passed the batton to someone else after Phase 3. With his promotion to Marvel CCO, someone else should have taken the role of President of Marvel Studios.I just think this suggestion of @TheVileOne of firing Kevin Feige is irrational and really doesn't make sense, unless they already have someone in mind that could a better job overseeing this franchise. I doubt it!
This head honcho you are talking about is credited for these movies as a producer:The comparison of Feige to Snyder makes no sense. It's not the same thing. I'm talking about Feige as the general manager and head honcho of the MCU.
Sure he had a track record but that's not what we are talking about here. Snyder wasn't president of the studio or the main creative in charge of the DC Universe going back to 2004.
He was in charge of the three Dc films he directed, that got DCEU to a bad start which DCEU never really recovered from.Sure he had a track record but that's not what we are talking about here. Snyder wasn't president of the studio or the main creative in charge of the DC Universe going back to 2004.
He was in charge of the three Dc films he directed, that got DCEU to a bad start which DCEU never really recovered from.
This isn't the case with Mcu, not even post-Endgame. Doomsday is about to become the biggest movie of 2026. Spider-Man: Brand New Day is going to be huge too.
Which they should have done sooner. Kevin Feige doesn't have the same bad track record to get fired, which you are suggesting they should do.He didn't get to stay there that long with more dismal efforts. He basically got fired from Justice League.
Not gonna happen, when he's still producing hits to Disney. You keep giving my posts, "confused" reactions doesn't make your suggestions realistic.It's fine that you disagree. I still think it's time to fire him after mismanaging the Multiverse Saga and for even choosing to do a Multiverse Saga in the first place.