Bought/Thought June 4th, 2008

CaptainCanada

Shield of the True North
Joined
Jul 26, 2006
Messages
4,608
Reaction score
1
Points
31
A small shipment this week, one that, for the most part, I found a bit underwhelming.

Avengers/Invaders #2

As the cover promises, the Mighty Avengers intercept the Invaders to try to preserve history; the Invaders are still shooting from the hip, so a big fight breaks out; the Mighty Avengers have a phenomenal edge in power, so the Invaders get a few shots but get clobbered, apart from Namor, who flees in search of help (I'm sure he'll find Atlantis very surprising). Later, in holding facilities, Iron Man appeals to Cap for help, while Bucky tries to escape (and current Bucky-Cap learns about the time-traveling heroes via The DB (pretty good use of current continuity here). The New Avengers, meanwhile, vow to bust the Invaders out. This is probably the best of the week for me; Sadowski's art is kind of weird in places, but it's mostly good, and Krueger writes everybody well (the opening scene with Iron Man and Ms. Marvel is particularly good).

Invincible Iron Man #2

They've modified the cover a bit from first place, to make Tony look a bit less like he's disco-dancing. Fraction continues to push the whole idea of Stane representing a new era of technology, and I think he pushes it a bit too much for it to be plausible (the total shock everyone feels about some of Stane's suicide bombers disguising themselves as Buddhist monks feels very manufactured, an appeal to "real" sentiment that wouldn't shock me too much even if it really happened; these guys have seen way worse than that). We do get a better explanation about why Stane's bio-tech is so dangerous: the bombers we've seen are essentially disposable one-use weapons that are devastating but cost a fraction of what Iron Man's suit does, and are more effective since they aren't intended for multiple uses (hence, no expensive hardware getting captured). I'm not really sure where Fraction is going with Tony and Pepper; I think the idea is that he's being insensitive to her dead husband. The big scene here is the totally unexpected appearance of Thor (Larroca's initial rendering of him is a bit suspect, but it gets better); it's nice to see a meeting between them written by someone willing to accept that Tony has feelings.

Secret Invasion #3

Better than #2, less than #1; so far, this has been a comfortably average story. As promised, the scope of events has broadened since last issue, which suffered greatly from just being about a bunch of guys running around the Savage Land; for the most part, there are only brief touch-ins with Thunderbolts Mountain and such, but, unsurprisingly, there's a good deal set in New York, where the Skrull army has landed. Skrull Queen Spider-Woman seems to kill Echo (eh, who cares), and tries to convince Iron Man that he's actually a Skrull sleeper agent. The Young Avengers and the Initiative get flattened, but Nick Fury and his new commandos arrive (quite frankly, their entrance leaves something to be desired; particularly since one of them is a preteen).

Young X-Men #3

Boooring.
 
it's nice to see a meeting between them written by someone willing to accept that Tony has feelings.

The feelings of a man who stands at someone's funeral whining "Me me me! It's all about ME!"

I mean at least JMS writes him as a *****e whose mind is on the job.
 
The start of June and this week brings us more scaly Marvel events and other assorted happenings. As always, full spoilers ahead.

Dread's Bought/Thought for 6/4/08:

DETECTIVE COMICS #845:
It is books like this that will bare the brunt of whatever tired crossovers that DC is doing via DESPERATELY TRYING TO RIP OFF BRUABKER'S SUCCESS ONCE HE FLED DC, otherwise known as BATMAN R.I.P., or even FINAL CRISIS. Just small books trying to do their thing every month, and they do it well without needing to rely on a half dozen other titles or stilted arcs. Every issue has a solo story but read as a whole there are carried over subplots. This is how to do a serial series. The cover alludes to the return of Catwoman although that really is a somewhat aimless cameo rather than a major point in the story.

Batman is helping Gordon and the GCPD with yet another series of murders in Gotham. The victims seem to be random people with items taken and used deliberately to fool attempts at finding patterns. The Riddler shows up to offer his P.I. services and naturally complicates the plot. A larger detail than Catwoman is that Batman apparently trolls around an ametuer's detective chatroom with Riddler (via another screen-name) and, of all people, Detective Chimp from SHADOWPACT (which has been canceled, hasn't it?). Some people find talking apes instantly funny, I usually don't; it depends on the ape, and Det. Chimp seems to be no Ken Hale. Riddler gets a lead, but ends up falling into the killer's trap and Batman swings to the rescue. It turns out the killer was a bystander for one of Riddler's old robbery sprees who wants revenge. It had that "guy out of nowhere" cop out appeal, but the mystery works well enough and helps cement the fact that Riddler has some skeletons in his closet, even if he is legit (which has become a great subplot). Riddler seems far more interesting as a sort-of ally than he ever did as a standard criminal, much like Penguin running a lounge as a front is better than cliche mobster schemes.

Oh, as for Catwoman, she basically shows up in the Batmobile, announces she escaped from SALVATION RUN without any footnotes if you weren't aware, complains that Batman is softening up to other women (namely Zatanna) and leaps off. It seemed a bit forced, as if to remind us that Batman and Catwoman have that "moonlighting" thing going. But haven't they for the past decade? Wasn't HUSH the only storyline that tried to make something of it, for about as long as it lasted? Batman's the king of being unable to seal the deal. Catwoman really has only herself to blame for waiting on Bruce. He can't get serious with anyone. I almost don't know why writers continue to shove romantic subplots at Batman when they never pay off. Crap or get off the pot. If Dini wants to make Zatanna his Mary Sue, go all the ****ing way. I am getting tired of the tension baloney. In a way, that was what I used to like about Nightwing. He used a lot of what Bruce taught him, but he remembered to be human, and that included forming intimate relationships. Granted, that all went to hell a while ago.

So, another solid mystery, even if sometimes interupted by some romantic tension that is boring only because it ends the same way for Batman, all the time.

As usual on the title, the art from Nguyen is good. And Dini writes a great Detective, niggles notwithstanding. He, at the least, is a TV writer who manages to turn in a timely comic or allow fill-in teams when he cannot. Who'd have thunk?

INVINCIBLE IRON MAN #2 That Larroca cover is unintentionally funny. It looks like Iron Man is either throwing marbles or levitating some gum-balls to select for himself. Not terribly manly.

Iron Man takes on A.I.G. and the third copy of MODOK, MODOG (the G is for Genocide), and basically beats them all and throws MODOG into the dustbin of history alongside MODAM (or space, for you technical people). But despite this, Iron Man is no closer to Zeke Stane or his plan. This title basically merges comic book Iron Man concerns with real world themes such as terrorism and making easily built, low cost explosive soldiers to wage an unpredictable war on the West. In a cool twist to international heroes, a team of superheroes from the Philippines are honored for aiding with the tsunami disaster before they themselves are bombed. Iron Man investigates with War Machina and is still at a loss. The issue ends with Potts being annoyed at Stark seeing her as a gopher while he continues his hedonism, and Stane's explosive plot hits too close to home.

Fraction does a good job of maintaining the character as refreshed by the movie while keeping things grounded in the current MU so that he can possibly keep new readers to the franchise, like me. His Iron Man is a quicky duck; not perfect (he attends a funeral and can barely maintain token mourning because he is obsessing over getting Thor to work with him again) but a lot more rootable than the storm-trooper of other comics, past and present. Larroca's art is rather good and Fraction manages to write a decent Thor (even if, naturally, this is from Iron Man's perspective so he sees Thor as being rigid). I can buy Iron Man being a bit impersonal at the hero funerals considering he didn't know them personally. I mean, does anyone really honestly believe that when politicians give token appearances for cop/soldier funerals, they are truly 100% emotionally involved and aren't thinking about other things, like business or how it will go down politically and with the media? Iron Man is an international symbol as head of SHIELD so he has to make these showings. On the upside, the issue revealed that Stark accepts no salary for his position; for better or worse, he is Iron Man because he believes it will get America and the world to a better place. I am curious if Fraction will seriously update the "thruster boots" technology.

The cliffhanger is naturally nixed once you recall that Stark is the Extremis and thus the armor comes automatically from his body, but it still was paced effectively. Stane is shown as increasingly unstable. A shame that Potts seems to have forgotten about Henry Hellrung so quickly, but she's been making doe eyes for Iron Man for ages now. I like the idea this book offers and the manner in which they merge the superhero stuff with SHIELD without going overboard on either. For capitalizing on the movie (or trying to), this is the best title to do so without alienating the hardcore audience. Fraction's establishing himself as a straight-up, go-to Marvel writer who is very reliable and imaginative, and if this can be his first A-List title, so be it.

KICK-ASS #3: Taken at a glance, this issue almost looks like an arc of USM; a lean, costumed hero takes on bad guys, lips off, can't back himself up, gets pummeled, and then has to be rescued by a girl, who beats said bad guys with zero effort. Really, hasn't this been every USM arc since SABLE? Or every other arc?

Millar & Romita Jr.'s quicky franchise from ICON, which is selling well for an ICON book, chugs along. After saving a man's life from a gang of Puetro Ricans (Millar makes sure to mention their ethnic background every time he can, in case you forgot), Dave's stunt becomes a YouTube phenom with over 10,000. "Kick-Ass", as the video and by extension he is called, gets media coverage and a degree of "street cred" from it. Now, this naturally feels contemporary (Millar compares it to "The Star Wars Kid" and other such Internet phenoms), but the bit where it goes too far is having Leno and Letterman condone it. It was RIDICULOUSLY violent; there is no way late night comedians would endorse it; hell, I could imagine it being on the news just so police could lambaste it. That isn't saying youth wouldn't embrace it, I just think it went too far. Millar is trying to ground this in reality, a "what if a costumed vigilante popped into the real world", so little things like this count. Of course, every issue it seems Dave takes 1,000 times the beating that Rocky Balboa ever got and he continues to survive, so realism is bent a bit here.

Dave gains new confidence in school, only to learn that while "Kick-Ass" is an indie star, at school they think he's a gay prostitute and the "hottest girl" Katie only sees him as her "gay male friend". I know it is a cliche, but I am always bemused by women who won't open up or interact like a human being to a guy unless he is gay and thus in no way is interested in her sexually. Dave goes along and we are treated to another "pathetic male loser" character not unlike the guy in WANTED, only with fewer moves. Kick-Ass starts his own MySpace page and takes on cases for "clients", and picks on trying to scare off an obsessive ex-boyfriend for a chick. Of course, he turns out to be a ghetto gang-banger with a bunch of thugs, and they proceed to stomp Dave to the ground before he is saved by a 10 year old girl with a katanna that is larger than her. At least this time, Millar has his ghetto thugs talk like them. Meanwhile, Dave has to fend off his overly concerned father and in the background, the mob has taken notice of Kick-Ass and they seem familiar with it.

Naturally, this is a flashback story as Kick-Ass is tied to a chair, getting his nards zapped off by the mob from #1, so this is part of leading up to that moment. Obviously, Kick-Ass is saying something about current "youth movements", as Dave is half Daredevil, half JACK-ASS -esque guy. This comic will probably seem horribly dated in a decade, but that isn't the concern here. And as always, Romita Jr. does great art, from the high school scenes to Kick-Ass' Kirby-esque suit to the action, it all flows well. Millar's written this sort of story before, but it isn't as vile or bleak as WANTED, at least not yet. Millar still has a habit of over-the-top lines that feel like he is trying to make every one a blurb on a t-shirt rather than characters talk like characters, but frankly that's been one of his flaws since he launched Ultimate X-Men, so I am used to it. Some people are calling this THE RAPTURE and that's hardly not true, but so far it's entertaining me enough to continue.

Still, the title would be more accurate if it was, ASS-KICKED. Because that is what happens to Dave every issue.

NOVA #14: Ah, a great book to read after KICK-ASS, where you get a hero who can actually stand up for himself against threats, whether they are alien serial killers or heralds of Galactus. DnA and Alves continue their story in which Nova tries to save the people of Orbucen.

Nova, as per last month's cover, grapples against Silver Surfer for a bit, and manages to fight the Surfer without embarassing himself too much in terms of power levels, and convinces him to ask Galactus to delay his feast long enough for the Orbucenians to flee. Nova aids in this evacuation until he finds out that Hollow has escaped and is settling on slaughtering as many escapees as he can. Ignoring Worldmind's pleas, Nova fights Hollow and manages to defeat him, only is seemingly stuck on a dying world and about to end up in Galactus' belly.

Yes, it still sucks that ANNIHILATION returned Surfer to his 60's status quo in a 180 that is, well, worthy of DC at this point, but obviously it seems here to stay for a while. As always, the banter between Nova and Worldmind is excellent and worthy of carrying an issue even without the great art and action. Hollow is a bit, well, Hollow since DnA basically did this sort of villain on Knowhere, which wasn't a long time ago. Really, all this story needed was a potent enough alien threat and that could have been anything. Still, it gets the point across that Nova is not the sort of man who believes the few should be sacrificed to save the many, instead trying to save EVERYONE whenever he can, which of course has it's strengths and limitations. Considering how many Marvel heroes have seemed to compromise their morals over the last few years (Spider-Man can now watch Wolverine and Punisher kill people without batting an eye), I like seeing that Nova doesn't with his, even in the face of Galactus. In less than 2 years NOVA has become one of my favorite Marvel heroes and is a pleasure to read every month, and DnA are a major reason of why. **** being repetitive; had Nova saved the day and tore Ultron apart in AC, it would have been a gazillion times better than Phyla-channeling-Sailor Moon.

Naturally, Nova will escape the planet in time, but it is the ride to that point that will be worth reading. Maybe Silver Surfer comes through again after all. The only major challenge that DnA have to overcome are some better threats for Nova to face down in terms of villains. But even barring that, Nova's a thrill to read. The space hero for those who usually dislike space heroes.

PUNISHER WAR JOURNAL: The JIGSAW story reaches it's midway point. Chaykin is the new official artist, but it doesn't seem too bad here; the only problem is he draws a limited range of faces so you have to use dialogue and other quirks to tell people apart sometimes.

The obviously insane Jigsaw has hired the ninja Hand to kill Frank Castle after framing him for some murders and getting the anti-terrorism task force on him. Bridge and his SHIELD allies Sable, Domini, and Valentina (who is a Skrull, right?) quickly determine that Punisher is being set up, even if they have to hunt him down regardless. Bridge's comment about Castle and poetry was friggin' hilarous. Castle and his allies are soon beset by the ninja and after a bloody fight, Punisher faces off against three superpowered vixens out for blood.

Between Zeke Stane and Jigsaw, Fraction obviously seems to be in his element when writing bad guys who are completely insane, which isn't a bad thing. Considering this is the first "serious" Punisher story since the Hate-Monger one, this one is coming together a lot better and stronger than that one did. Fraction has also assembled a supporting cast for Punisher, which I didn't know was possible. And so far he has resisted having some cameos from other heroes trying to capture Castle, staying focused on his niche. The action scenes were pretty good, gritty and explaining why Castle isn't Daredevil, who does those kind of scenes a lot. And I like that Stuart Clarke has become a far more useful partner than Microchip ever was. Besides, "Rampage" is a better codename anyway.

SECRET INVASION #3: I am curious as to why Marvel feels every issue has to be $3.99. The first had a whopping extra page than normal comics, but the last two haven't. Are we paying for the cardstock covers? Because if so, they aren't worth it. What I "love" about modern comic pricing, especially Marvel, is that there is no middle ground between $2.99 and $3.99. A comic cannot be $3.25 or $3.50 or even $3.75. No, it has to be the whole extra buck. Great way to reward fans who continue to buy in the six figure range amid a sagging economy and gas woes. Granted, Joe Q's era has been one of shrewd honesty. Past EIC's have tried to act like the fan's friend, maintaining that cosy bullpen illusion and whatnot, keep that human touch. Joe Q isn't about that. He thinks in cold, hard dollars and only sees fans as the bringers of wallets, and rarely claims otherwise (in his blog, he basically went with the "I'm a businessman, not a politician" to explain why he doesn't give a damn about controversy). If the numbers were there, he'd charge $20 a page if he could get away with it, and smug all the way to the bank. Still, for an 8 issue arc, charging an extra buck for no reason seems to be daring people to trade-wait.

As for the story itself, with Bendis' other titles MIGHTY & NEW AVENGERS handling a lot of the details, the core event book gets to be more broad and cover many areas at once. It isn't terribly fantastic, but it's far better than HOUSE OF M was at this stage. True, we've not moved much in terms of the plot from this issue to the last (Stark is still rebuilding his armor, Midtown is still under attack, Capt. Marvel is still fighting the Thunderbolts), but it doesn't feel as slow as some of Bendis' past event issues. Once again, HOM spent the first 3-4 issues window dressing.

A few bodies hit the ground here; the biggest reveal was naturally that Spider-Woman was the Skrull Empress all along, which I can't imagine was always planned, otherwise why the **** did Marvel publish those origin comics all those years ago if Drew has been a bloody Skrull since the team founded? She seemingly kills Echo by snapping her neck, and somewhere I think Bendis things someone is supposed to care about this character. Over in Midtown, Vision 2.0 gets blasted, but as a robot he is perennially rebuildable. 616 Geldoff, however, isn't. The Initiative get involved and while Yu's art is strong on the most part, he's not exactly Caselli at drawing some of the newer recruits. Maria Hill gets in some complaints as "Drew" tries to convince Stark that he's a Skrull, which I don't buy because it would explain the "stormtrooper" phase too well and Marvel seems to like making him into another Magneto.

I still don't get the Capt. Marvel sequence and only see it as a complete waste of Reed's mini. That was all about Marvel being his own man despite the Skrulls, and now he is doing their bidding by taking out some more of Earth's defenses.

And, as predicted by every man, woman, and child that has ever read a comic book, Nick Fury emerges from no where with the walking Dues Ex Machina's to save the day, or at least try to. Seriously, Bendis needs to stop insisting on being so damned predictable if he wants to be an A-Lister. His last relavant plot twist was about 5-6 years ago. If he wanted to surprise me, it'd have been Thor who came into the story or something. Unfortunately, all the potent heroes like Thor and Nova will be stuck doing inconsequential things in mini's and tie-in's that will provide absolutely nothing to the core SI series. I'll still probably read 'em, but knowing beforehand that nothing they do will save the day or really matter to the event as a whole. That would require Bendis to acknowledge that someone besides himself writes comics, and that's something he is physically incapable of doing. I am amazed he bothered to get all the post-issue #12 Initiative recruits right. Besides, main things happen in the mini. Flash didn't weaken Anti-Moniter in a side mini, he did it in the core mini. Stuff like that.

For all the talk about how crafty the Skrulls are, they mostly are winning because they have created a new breed of super-Skrull and have mass produced it. Not that this is bad; for Bendis it is surprisingly action packed so far. But just saying. And if Yellowjacket at Camp Hammond is still a Skrull, then the heroes are really in deep. I wonder if Pym from MA will be a Skrull while Yellowjacket from Hammond could be real? Or both are Skrulls? Guess that will come soon in MA. The big question is what has happened to the characters the Skrulls are impersonating. Are they dead? In that space-ship in the Savage Land, mixed with moles? Captive somewhere? Because Drew, Black Bolt, Pym, and others are notable characters here.

Honestly, this is better than I thought it would be. It isn't incredible, but it's been solid action fodder (even if that scene with Stark mumbling, "No" every panel like a sissy would have been better served with him silent). I just keep waiting for the shoe to drop, the finale to suck wind. If that doesn't happen, bravo. But I'm not about to get my hopes up, especially with Bendis being utterly predictable with a major twist like Nick Fury.

And at least we got CAPTAIN BRITAIN AND MI-13 out of this. :up:
 
Dread said:
But I'm not about to get my hopes up, especially with Bendis being utterly predictable with a major twist like Nick Fury.

Jesus Christ, Dread, what tipped you off: Nick Fury being on the cover, the last few issues of MA focusing on Nick Fury, or Bendis saying that SI would feature the return of Nick Fury?

Dread said:
If he wanted to surprise me, it'd have been Thor who came into the story or something. Unfortunately, all the potent heroes like Thor and Nova will be stuck doing inconsequential things in mini's and tie-in's that will provide absolutely nothing to the core SI series. I'll still probably read 'em, but knowing beforehand that nothing they do will save the day or really matter to the event as a whole. That would require Bendis to acknowledge that someone besides himself writes comics, and that's something he is physically incapable of doing.

Yeah, I doubt Bendis would ever use guys like Thor or the new Cap in his event.
 
Jesus Christ, Dread, what tipped you off: Nick Fury being on the cover, the last few issues of MA focusing on Nick Fury, or Bendis saying that SI would feature the return of Nick Fury?

Dude, people were calling this a year ago. There was a whole topic about it and I was arguing with PhotoJones (I think) about how utterly predictable it would be, especially after SECRET WAR. I also feared Nick would just become head of SHIELD again and return to status quo. It would be too easy.

Yeah, I doubt Bendis would ever use guys like Thor or the new Cap in his event.

Is that an actual SI cover?

Bendis must have a ghost-writer, or must be in some immense mystical pain right now. Still, he could write them like ****, and then order would be right in the universe. ;)

I mean, I expect Thor to talk like a 14 year old boy just like all his other characters.
 
Dude, people were calling this a year ago. There was a whole topic about it and I was arguing with PhotoJones (I think) about how utterly predictable it would be, especially after SECRET WAR. I also feared Nick would just become head of SHIELD again and return to status quo. It would be too easy.

Of course it was predictable! BENDIS SAID FURY WOULD BE RETURNING.

It's not like he was hiding it or keeping it a surprise. It's about as predictable as Bucky becoming Captain America.

Dread said:
Is that an actual SI cover?

Bendis must have a ghost-writer, or must be in some immense mystical pain right now. Still, he could write them like ****, and then order would be right in the universe. ;)

I mean, I expect Thor to talk like a 14 year old boy just like all his other characters.

But the important part is that I proved you wrong. Yay.
 
Nova, as per last month's cover, grapples against Silver Surfer for a bit, and manages to fight the Surfer without embarassing himself too much in terms of power levels, and convinces him to ask Galactus to delay his feast long enough for the Orbucenians to flee. Nova aids in this evacuation until he finds out that Hollow has escaped and is settling on slaughtering as many escapees as he can. Ignoring Worldmind's pleas, Nova fights Hollow and manages to defeat him, only is seemingly stuck on a dying world and about to end up in Galactus' belly.

Yes, it still sucks that ANNIHILATION returned Surfer to his 60's status quo in a 180 that is, well, worthy of DC at this point, but obviously it seems here to stay for a while.

I'd have to disagree with this a little. It doesn't appear to me that Surfer has returned to his 60's roots at all. What I got out of this issue was that specifically Silver Surfer was trying to help in whatever way he could without Galactus putting the smack down on him. They made a point that Surfer took Nova to the planet to talk to him so that Galactus wouldn't notice. And the Surfer didn't convince Galactus to hold off a bit, the Surfer himself got rid of the interference that was stalling the evacuation rather than trying to bring Galactus into it.

What I've got out of the Surfer's recent appearances is that he's chosen to be Galactus's herald again because he's the one best suited for it and always has been. He helps when he can, as he did here in small ways, but knows that Galactus is a force of nature and his will is simply inevitable. You have to believe that the Surfer knew this planet was already evacuating themselves when they showed up, he's powerful enough that he would.

I see the Silver Surfer as someone like a tornado tracker. He heralds the coming of the storm, but there is little he can do to keep it from destroying. The most he can do is give a warning by showing up first. If the planet is capable of evacuating they will, if not, there's little he could do anyway.
 
Of course it was predictable! BENDIS SAID FURY WOULD BE RETURNING.

It's not like he was hiding it or keeping it a surprise. It's about as predictable as Bucky becoming Captain America.

But nowhere near as satisfying. Again, Bendis did this in SECRET WAR. I expect about 7 pages of exposition from Fury at this rate.

People were calling this before Bendis revealed it. It wasn't brain surgery.

But the important part is that I proved you wrong. Yay.

Then it is even more shameless to have Thor in a mini if he is in the core mini. Just do it in the mini and save fans a few bucks. Ah, that wily Joe Q.

At least I am still right about Nova.

I'd have to disagree with this a little. It doesn't appear to me that Surfer has returned to his 60's roots at all. What I got out of this issue was that specifically Silver Surfer was trying to help in whatever way he could without Galactus putting the smack down on him. They made a point that Surfer took Nova to the planet to talk to him so that Galactus wouldn't notice. And the Surfer didn't convince Galactus to hold off a bit, the Surfer himself got rid of the interference that was stalling the evacuation rather than trying to bring Galactus into it.

What I've got out of the Surfer's recent appearances is that he's chosen to be Galactus's herald again because he's the one best suited for it and always has been. He helps when he can, as he did here in small ways, but knows that Galactus is a force of nature and his will is simply inevitable. You have to believe that the Surfer knew this planet was already evacuating themselves when they showed up, he's powerful enough that he would.

I see the Silver Surfer as someone like a tornado tracker. He heralds the coming of the storm, but there is little he can do to keep it from destroying. The most he can do is give a warning by showing up first. If the planet is capable of evacuating they will, if not, there's little he could do anyway.

In the 60's, Surfer was Galactus' herald.

In 2007, he is Galactus' herald.

That is the exact same thing. For 40 years Silver Surfer made this huge deal about being his own man, discovering himself, exploring people, places, and his psyche. And now? Back being "janitor to the apocalypse" as The Tick would put it.

Yeah, okay, Surfer has reason and mercy. That is the least they could do. I still see it as a massive step backwards, but at the very least writers are working with it. DnA are good after all.

I was under the impression that Surfer seemed to psychically confer with Galactus, rather than shut off the interference himself. Maybe I'll reread the scene again, because your interpretation makes sense, too. Granted, maybe I feel the way I do because I always thought the "Galactus must exist to kill worlds and slaughter species" from Bryne's FF run was baloney, but it's been cemented so there is no going back now. If that is true, then vampires have a right to exist on Earth, and Blade is wrong to slay them.
 
But nowhere near as satisfying. Again, Bendis did this in SECRET WAR. I expect about 7 pages of exposition from Fury at this rate.

People were calling this before Bendis revealed it. It wasn't brain surgery.

Jesus, who cares? Do you want a medal or something?

It was never meant to be a surprise, it's been something Bendis has alluded and built to as part of Secret Invasion. I doubt people were "calling it" before Bendis revealed it, and if they did, it was probably more like "I hope this is the event that returns Fury to the MU" (it couldn't have been a year ago because it hasn't even been a year since SI was announced). You'd have a more valid point arguing that [blackout]J'onn's death[/blackout] in Final Crisis was a more predictable plot point.

But in the end, you're really just *****ing about this because it's a Bendis-written comic and you have some kind of personal vendetta against Bendis. You know that, I know that, everyone knows that--and I'm not going to waste any more time on it.
 
That is the exact same thing. For 40 years Silver Surfer made this huge deal about being his own man, discovering himself, exploring people, places, and his psyche. And now? Back being "janitor to the apocalypse" as The Tick would put it.

Yeah, okay, Surfer has reason and mercy. That is the least they could do. I still see it as a massive step backwards, but at the very least writers are working with it. DnA are good after all.

I was under the impression that Surfer seemed to psychically confer with Galactus, rather than shut off the interference himself. Maybe I'll reread the scene again, because your interpretation makes sense, too. Granted, maybe I feel the way I do because I always thought the "Galactus must exist to kill worlds and slaughter species" from Bryne's FF run was baloney, but it's been cemented so there is no going back now. If that is true, then vampires have a right to exist on Earth, and Blade is wrong to slay them.

I got my interpretation from the bit of dialogue between Nova and Surfer (and I don't have the issue in front of my so I'm paraphrasing) were Surfer says "It is done (meaning eliminating the interference) and Nova says "You can do that" to which Surfer replies "The Power Cosmic allows me to...I don't have to explain myself."

Also, I see the decision of the Silver Surfer to become a herald again as the culmination of 40 years of history. For all this time the Silver Surfer has been flitting about the universe saving lives and being introspective. How could he not come to the realization that Galactus could only be tempered through his intervention. For someone with the Surfer's morals the only option is for him to become the herald. He couldn't entrust it to anyone else. At least that's the way I see it.

And the Galactus/Vampire comparison doesn't really stand up. Galactus is a fundamental part of the universe created at the dawn of the current universe. Vampires are little more than a spell created from Chthon's (sp?) Darkhold. Galactus is essentially beyond morality, he simple exists, like inertia or light as a part of the fabric of the current reality. Vampires were created by evil for the purpose of evil. It's like comparing a hurricane to nerve gas.
 
and I really dont see how DC is trying to rip off the death of captain america with Batman RIP, especially when theyve said bruce isnt dying, and especially when grant morrison said that this was actually the first story he came up with for his run,which i believe was before cap dying...not to mention the "RIP" part is being heavily hinted at meaning something other than "Rest in peace"
 
Dread, as far as Captain Marvel attacking the Thunderbolts, it's been suggested that he's going after a Skrull infiltrator, not attacking Earth's heroes.

Secret Invasion- PICK OF THE WEEK! This book needs to be a lot longer than 22 pages. I love every page, but there's so much going on that it feels like we end up just getting snippets of what we wanna see. 9/10

Amazing Spider-Man- Dan Slott knows how to write a Spider-Man story. This arc is textbook Spider-Man. An interesting villain, Peter having to question his decision-making and inevitably choosing the greater good over himself, Peter losing more than he realizes... I love it. And the cast is really gelling, too. Vin as Peter's roommate and potential competition is going to be great to watch. 9/10

Iron Man- Anyone that loved the movie must read this series. It reads like a sequel, relying very little on continuity knowledge to step in, but not ignoring anything, either. Larocca is blowing me away, and the villain is a great concept. Tony has needed some compelling new enemies, and Stane is a great character that could even work in a future sequel. 9/10

Transformers: The Reign of Starscream- Digging this. Seems like the team is trying hard not to do anything that might contradict the real sequel, but the art's great, and we're getting to see some of the movie toys that didn't actually show up in the movie. Plus, one of my favorite movie villains might end up pulling through. Nice. 8/10

American Dream- My vote for worst cover to an otherwise good comic. God, the logo even sucks. 8/10

PWJ- Not bad. Frank fighting the Hand seems kinda odd, but this whole series is pretty odd, in all fairness. 7/10

Cable- Best issue so far. Still not sold on this series, but this issue showed more potential than any other so far. Liked the Cannonball fight. 7/10

Avengers/Invaders- Starting to get cooking. I wish Ross were on interior art, though. 7/10
 
Invincible Iron Man #2

The big scene here is the totally unexpected appearance of Thor
Ugh, I gotta go back to the shop tomorrow. :whatever:

Robin/Spoiler Special #1
Very well done. I thoroughly enjoyed the first story, with Spoiler getting right back into her life in Gotham and again coaxing the usually responsible Tim into dangerous situations. I can't stress enough how much I've ****ing hated Tim since One Year Later. Seriously, he went from being my favorite DC character to being a whiny, angst-riddled *****ebag who inspired absolutely zero sympathy. Here he's still portrayed a bit darker than I like, but Dixon goes the extra mile and actually addresses it as part of Spoiler's reason for even coming back to Gotham. Remember how Robin used to be the person who kept Batman from going off the deep end? Well, now Spoiler's looking to fill that role for Robin. I hope to God Dixon keeps Steph around in Robin's comic and actually does something with that plot thread. Anything that gets Tim back to the precocious, funny supergenius-in-training that I grew to love initially would be much appreciated.

The second story is basically the story of what da fug Steph was doing the whole time she was away. She and Leslie were basically helping out small African villages with vaccinations and such. It's surprising how much damage to both these characters Dixon effectively undid with such apparent ease. Leslie's up to her old tricks again, roping Steph into the relief effort to let her help others without going the violent cape-and-cowl route, and Steph tries it for a while but ultimately figures out that it's not for her thanks to some ethnic-cleansing, severely misguided witch doctor.

The art in both stories is good, although I was surprised to find I liked Ibanez's art more than Albuquerque's. Ibanez has a very deft, clean style that makes it look like not a single line was wasted. The dusty, brown-tinted coloring works well with it.

Giant-Size Astonishing X-Men #1: My shop got this a week late, so I just read it. Not much to say; it's all pretty much what we expected thanks to context clues from stuff that takes place after it in continuity but came out months before it. But while the plot stuff wasn't too interesting (and, in fact, felt a bit disjointed at times), Whedon knocked those quiet character moments toward the end out of the park. I wasn't too fond of Agent Brand before, but by the end of this issue I found myself hoping she and Beast start up a relationship. I'm also wondering what her real name is now. The best of the end scenes, though, belonged to Emma and Scott. It was, in a word, perfect. Not a word wasted, not a panel overplayed--just a quiet, simple acceptance of a couple of realities, both good and bad, that was so poignant it damn near made me sniffle. That's probably one of my favorite Cyclops moments now. The art was, of course, by Cassaday. Do I really need to say it was awesome? Everyone knows it always is. (He takes long enough to make it that way, too.)

Secret Invasion #3: Not bad. The scope of the conflict broadens impressively in this issue. I hope Tony Stark's not a Skrull. That would be pretty lame. I figure it's just the Skrull queen trying to use her good ol' Skrull hypnosis to make Tony believe he's a Skrull. It'd be a simple and effective way to take one of the major players off the board. Vision's apparently dead but we all know he'll be back, so no big deal there. Bendis killed off some random Initiative kids--also no big deal. I liked how Skrullowjacket essentially led them into an ambush by playing on their desire to be heroes, though. I have to admit, I was pretty jazzed when that Giant-Skrull knocked Stature the **** out, too. I hate that girl so much. The last page was pretty neat. I forgot about Fury, actually, so when I saw everything shaking I thought it might've been Thor causing an earthquake or a lot of thunder or something, since I think he and Bucky are meant to show up in another issue or two. Alas, not him, but Fury's new Howling Commandos aren't a bad consolation prize. Yu's art was phenomenal, as always. His shot of Venorpion getting knocked out of T-bolts Mountain in particular looked amazing. Looking forward to the next issue.

Nova #14: Good goddamn, this issue ruled. I'm glad the Surfer's not a total bastard now that he's working for the G-man again. He just had to keep any concern for the poor slobs Galactus is world-raping under Galactus' radar. I'm a little surprised that the Surfer is still so far beyond Nova, though; even with the entirety of the Nova Force, the Power Cosmic is still so much better that Nova was essentially running for his life most of the time? Eh, whatever. It was still pretty awesome when he decided to man up and he ****ing rammed the Surfer. The art on that and the rest of the issue, especially the sheer scale of Galactus, was great. Alves seems to have hit his groove on Nova nicely. My only concern is that, with the way things are left in this issue, it seems like the next issue is set up to be... um... identical to this issue, only with Nova pleading for some help to get himself off of Orbucen instead of the Orbucen people. We'll see, though.

Trinity #1: Great start. I wasn't this excited after the first issue of either of DC's past weeklies. The breakfast scene was a really nice, subtle way of accentuating the differences among the trinity. The Flash's appearance kicked ass; I enjoyed him here even more than in his own series, and I'm one of the few people who's actually enjoying Peyer's Flash run. Very interested in all of the mysteries set up--who is the cosmic dude trying to break free, what's the deal with the evil anti-trinity, why is the dude reaching out to these six people specifically, how does Batman stomach such a sunny facade as Bruce Wayne, etc. Looking forward to Despero--he's one of DC's most underrated villains, in my opinion. Bagley's art was slick and clean, as usual, and his faces weren't as wonky as I remember them from USM, so that was nice. McDaniel's art is bouncing off the walls, as usual, and looked great. My one gripe isn't even about the comic itself; the cover's just kind of... crappy? It's a boring shot of Superman just standing around under the ugly Trinity logo and its unnecessarily gi-friggin'-normous blank white background. Blurg. Anyway, I got so caught up in the issue that I forgot it was a weekly, so when I finished I remembered and was pleasantly surprised that I only had a week to go before the next chapter. Yay!

Buffy #14: Pretty awesome except for the fact Renee's dead. Seriously, all Mutant Enemy employees, listen up: crafting compelling characters, building relationships between them and existing characters, and then killing the compelling new character off to put the existing character through hell? Great idea when used sparingly. That's sparingly, as in, not every ****ing time you introduce a compelling character. Doing it too often is a surefire way to get me to just stop giving a **** when I see new characters in your stories. Anyway, now that that's out of the way, I loved about half of this issue and felt indifferent to the other half. The half I loved consisted of, essentially, anything involving Dracula and Mecha-Dawn; the half I was indifferent to consisted of anything involving the main plot and Buffy and Satsu. Both the main plot and the much-maligned lesbian subplot just felt really rushed and inconsequential to me. The Japanese vampires were built up to be really impressive badasses, but then Willow takes their magic away and they're essentially a bunch of scared *****es and/or easy marks--even the leaders. They should've made a bigger deal out of the sorceress vampire instead of dispatching her so casually; she had the most potential for awesomeness. Meanwhile, Buffy and Satsu essentially just decide that Buffy's not a lesbian, she just hit an experimental mood, I guess? So... yeah. They **** again and then Buffy leaves Satsu's ass in Japan. With a promotion, I know. :o Jeanty's art was good, but I'd be lying if I said I weren't really looking forward to Moline's art next month. Bring on some Fray lovin'. :up:

I also got American Dream, Manhunter, Detective Comics, Abe Sapien: The Drowning, and House of Mystery, but I'm pacing myself so I have something to read at lunch tomorrow. :)
 
Here's hoping. We can take it for granted that it'll be better than Countdown regardless. Stepping in dog poop is better than Countdown. :o
 
Here's hoping. We can take it for granted that it'll be better than Countdown regardless. Stepping in dog poop is better than Countdown. :o

I stepped in dog poop today and I thought "Well, at least I'm not reading Countdown" and then skipped away, yes, skipped.
 
I hear skipping's good for dispersing the poop in such scenarios. :up:
 
If only it worked towards making Countdown good.
 
Lies, skipping requires no patron deity. :o

Oh, I also took a look at the Whatever this Revamp of the X-Men Is Called Sketchbook, too. The designs ranged from minor modifications of existing costumes to downright horrendous pieces of ****. The only one I actually liked was Beast's, and I still think it's a little too busy with the Xes and the piping and the colors and all.
 
Detective Comics 845

Show of hands: did anybody ever need to see Batman tell someone "BRB"?

While sitting at a keyboard cramming a ****ing sandwich into his face, no less?

All that was missing here is him sweeping the crumbs off his beer-gutted Batsuit.

Also: I await the renaming of this comic to "*****es love the Batman."

Secret Invasion 3:

Let's kill Vision! That'll be totally new and different!

But I'm not about to get my hopes up, especially with Bendis being utterly predictable with a major twist like Nick Fury.

I don't actually think it was intended to be a major twist, for all that the book set it up as though it were one. It seemed like it was meant more as a "Hey everybody we've been teasing you with Nick Fury forever now - and here he finally is, ready to kick ass!" I mean it was actually written as though it were supposed to be a twist, but hey - Bendis is a ****ty writer.

Invincible Iron Man 2:

The Thor bit was basically word-for-word what JMS would have written, except with Fraction throwing in Tony's internal monologue for an extra layer of whiny *****e.

Pepper and Tony need to either **** or stop wasting my time. They're trying to be Bond and Moneypenny and failing miserably.

Past that the issue felt kind of filler-blah. Tony beats up some generic villains, Stane Junior does nothing that we didn't already see last issue, a bunch of heroes we've never heard of get killed. The suicide terror angle is about six years too late to be interesting and while I'd like to buy the extremist Christian bit on the grounds that I'm an ex-Catholic with a chip on my shoulder the fact is that it doesn't actually fit anything like the profile of actual suicide terrorists. If Fraction's going to try and inject RIPPED FROM THE HEADLINES realism into his book he could at least try and make it actually realistic.

The above probably sounds way more hateful towards the book than I actually am. Not really bad so much as just very solidly mediocre. This book needs 90% more crazy bio-cyborg dudes killing rooms full of executives for lulz and then jumping out of top-story windows.

Nova 14:

I like where the Worldmind was like "Richard we must leave now. I mean now. I mean right ****ing now" and Nova's like but wait I must capture this maniac and help these people and find this old man's car keys and then finally he's like oh okay I guess we can leave the Worldmind is like "Hey remember when I told you 'now' like twenty Goddamn minutes ago? Wasn't kidding! Have fun being a Galactus-snack."

Also the Silver Surfer was done really well. Like if you want to see an example of what the Silver Surfer looks like when he's being done really amazingly well? This is that.

Robin / Spoiler Special 1

I never get why they number these things.

Anyway, the best retcon ever continues being the best retcon ever. Once in a very rare while in the vast and endless ****-swamp of comics one tiny thing manages to go exactly right, and this is it.

Also a tiny extra bonus occurred to me in that God willing this will be what at long last drags a stake through the heart of that Robin-Wonder Girl ****fest that they've been using to punish anybody still reading Teen Titans.

Unless they've ended that already? I mean I wouldn't know because **** you I'm not reading Teen Titans.

Kick-Ass 3

This comic is like a joke being played on anyone stupid enough to pay money for it. It's like sending someone a package recipient-collection and then whoever it is pays for it and opens it up and it's this big-ass box of ****. If I walked into a comic book store and the dude at the register actually let me hand him honest to god non-Monopoly legal US tender in exchange for giving me this comic and then watched me walk out of the store I would turn around and punch him in the ****ing nuts. AND THEN POST IT ON MY MYSPACE PAGE LOLOLOLOL.
 
Lies, skipping requires no patron deity.

Requires? No. Deserves, yes.

She would get together with Dionysus and Eros and make a club of Gods of Things That are Totally Great.

Then they'll get drunk, ****, and then skip around laughing how great it is not to be the gods of Death or Dog Poop or Having to Read Countdown.
 
Punisher War Journal #20 - this book has been on a roll since Chaykin jumped onboard,I love all the obscure characters being used and the real "street level" feel Matt has achieved,"Jigsaw" continues to impress
 
Jesus, who cares? Do you want a medal or something?

It was never meant to be a surprise, it's been something Bendis has alluded and built to as part of Secret Invasion. I doubt people were "calling it" before Bendis revealed it, and if they did, it was probably more like "I hope this is the event that returns Fury to the MU" (it couldn't have been a year ago because it hasn't even been a year since SI was announced). You'd have a more valid point arguing that [blackout]J'onn's death[/blackout] in Final Crisis was a more predictable plot point.

But in the end, you're really just *****ing about this because it's a Bendis-written comic and you have some kind of personal vendetta against Bendis. You know that, I know that, everyone knows that--and I'm not going to waste any more time on it.

And you miss the point AGAIN!

Here is every Bendis book written in the past few years:

Interesting concept - Possibly a taste of action
Build up
Talking
More build up
Talking
Action
Deus Ex Machina comes out of nowhere and saves the day.

He's a one trick pony, anymore...and that pony sucks. You REFUSE to see it, so don't blame Dread. There are FAR better writers out there you could be defending. Only, you wouldn't have to defend them, because they don't suck.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"