Brady vs Manning, Whose More Marketable?

Showtime

Your Friend In Time
Joined
May 10, 2005
Messages
41,476
Reaction score
24
Points
58
http://www.boston.com/sports/footba...ts_but_patriots146_brady_is_no_slouch?mode=PF

By Keith Reed , Globe Staff | January 18, 2007

You’re more likely to see Peyton Manning than Tom Brady in a commercial when their teams vie for the American Football Conference title on Sunday, but that may not mean that Peyton is running away with the National Football League’s endorsement title.

Manning, star quarterback for the Indianapolis Colts, is by far a more prolific pitchman than local hero Brady. But Brady, who is not that far behind Manning in terms of endorsement dollars, just may be a lot more efficient.

Manning raked in $11.5 million from endorsements in 2006, hawking everything from Sprint cellphones to shopping at Tweeter stores. By comparison, Brady pulled in $9 million from endorsements, according to the latest ranking by Sports Illustrated.
Beyond that, the two both got high marks from the public in a survey in which participants were where they’re asked to attribute positive and negative adjectives to celebrities.

‘‘On paper, those guys are very bankable. All the negatives are really down, all the positives are up,’’ said Gerry Philpott, chief executive officer of E-Poll Market Research, which produced the study.

Forty-six percent of adults said they recognize Manning by name and 31 percent by face, according to E-Poll, compared with 27 percent name recognition and 26 percent face recognition for Brady. Forty-one percent called Brady ‘‘handsome’’ compared with 18 percent for Manning. Fifty-one percent said Brady was talented, compared with 63 percent for Manning, while 20 percent saw Manning as sincere, compared with 15 percent for Brady.

Given that, why does Manning have so many more endorsement deals than Brady? This season alone, the Colts’ gunslinger with the ‘‘laser, rocket arm’’ has been in commercials plugging Sony high-definition TVs, Sprint cellphones, DirecTV’s NFL Sunday Ticket package, MasterCard credit cards, Reebok apparel, Gatorade sports drink, and Tweeter stores as the place to go to buy, well, Sony TVs.

Tweeter Home Entertainment Group Inc. spokesman Jeff Duhamel said the Canton-based company didn’t pursue Manning, but jumped at the chance to feature him in an ad when Sony, whose products Tweeter sells, offered up its famous pitchman.
‘
‘Doing a commercial with Peyton Manning gave us the opportunity to both work with Sony’s pitchman and align the Tweeter brand nationally with one of the most recognizable quarterbacks in the NFL,’’ Duhamel said.
One reason Manning does more ads is that Brady probably turns down most offers, said Jon Hickey, senior vice president of sports entertainment and marketing for Boston advertising agency Mullen.

‘‘My guess is Peyton isn’t turning down a [darned] thing,’’ said Hickey. Manning also has emerged as a de facto public face for the National Football League, with many of the companies he endorses doubling as official league sponsors.

Messages for Manning’s agent, Alan Zucker, were not returned. Brady’s agent, Don Yee, could not be reached for comment.

Not that Brady’s an endorsement slouch: he and his offensive linemen starred in a campaign for Visa credit cards in the 2005 season, and he’s also pitched Cadillacs, a Dunkin’ Donuts sandwich, Gap clothes, Sirius Satellite Radio and more recently, Movado watches.
 
I could care less. I know both are very good...and one (Peyton) chokes in the playoffs.
 
Brady for magazine covers and payton for tv.Brady cant act,I mean have you seen that snl with him in it?
 
Peyton's ads are funny.


I agree, they are are a riot. The question is do you think he is overexposing himself and are is off field obligations clouding his ultimate goal?

I have been a Colts fan since 1995, Jim Harbaugh era. Of course I am a Patriots fan, I am from Boston. I follow both teams closely, the Pats get more attention because of my location, but it seems to me that Brady is more focused on his ultimate goal, I know it's a broad assumption, but that's how I am seeing it. That being said, Manning is unbelievable, he makes passes that defy logic. I don't know, just a thought.
 
I don't recall seeing Brady in any ads, while Manning is ****ing himself out for any company that asks. Having said that, Brady's got an advantage over Manning in the looks department. Manning's freakin' C.H.U.D.
 
Manning really doesn't have that "Golden Boy" look. Brady has only done a couple localized commercials. One was an ongoing credit card commercial.
 
Manning really doesn't have that "Golden Boy" look. Brady has only done a couple localized commercials. One was an ongoing credit card commercial.
I love his Master Card ads, cheering on regular people like they're players..and the other where he's acting as a fan to waitresses, clerks, mechanics and accountants. Hilarious :woot:
 
I don't recall seeing Brady in any ads, while Manning is ****ing himself out for any company that asks. Having said that, Brady's got an advantage over Manning in the looks department. Manning's freakin' C.H.U.D.

HAHA! Sinewave checks out dudes.:dry:
 
This reminds me of those baseball and football charaters on conan o brian and how really bad they are at acting,with the stiffness and all.
 
I agree, they are are a riot. The question is do you think he is overexposing himself and are is off field obligations clouding his ultimate goal?

I have been a Colts fan since 1995, Jim Harbaugh era. Of course I am a Patriots fan, I am from Boston. I follow both teams closely, the Pats get more attention because of my location, but it seems to me that Brady is more focused on his ultimate goal, I know it's a broad assumption, but that's how I am seeing it. That being said, Manning is unbelievable, he makes passes that defy logic. I don't know, just a thought.

Holy crap, Showtime! You basically described me with that statement. I'm a big fan of the Colts! It's unusual for me because they are the one team that I can actually point to the specific time I became a fan. Do you remember that AFC championship game where they were huge underdogs to the Steelers and Harbaugh had the bloody knuckles? That's when I became a fan.

Anyway I have to disagree with the idea that Manning isn't focused on the ultimate goal of winning a Super Bowl. If anything I think he works himself too hard and studies too much film. Sometimes I think he overanalyzes and thinks things through too much. You could say Brady gets distracted by the supermodels he dates (most recently he's been attached to Giselle Bundchan- did I spell that right?). But I wouldn't agree. Those guys are both football players through and through. They know what's important. :woot:

P.S. Don't you catch a lot of flack for being a Colt's fan in Boston? :huh:
 
Holy crap, Showtime! You basically described me with that statement. I'm a big fan of the Colts! It's unusual for me because they are the one team that I can actually point to the specific time I became a fan. Do you remember that AFC championship game where they were huge underdogs to the Steelers and Harbaugh had the bloody knuckles? That's when I became a fan.

Anyway I have to disagree with the idea that Manning isn't focused on the ultimate goal of winning a Super Bowl. If anything I think he works himself too hard and studies too much film. Sometimes I think he overanalyzes and thinks things through too much. You could say Brady gets distracted by the supermodels he dates (most recently he's been attached to Giselle Bundchan- did I spell that right?). But I wouldn't agree. Those guys are both football players through and through. They know what's important. :woot:

P.S. Don't you catch a lot of flack for being a Colt's fan in Boston? :huh:

That was a great game vs Pitt. Harbaugh is a "dirt dog" and he almost willed them to the victory.

In regards to Manning, I was just trying to throw something out there to explain why he caves in big games, it's been following him since college. Brady on the other hand seems to thrive in big games. I am reaching for the problem.

No I don't catch any flack. I have a couple Colts jackets and hats, and nobody has said anything to me, not even friends. My dad loves the Colts just as much. In fact, I am throwing a party this Sunday with many Patriots fans, and he is going to wear a Colts shirt and hat. :dry:
 
Being from Mass,Patriots are Huge!!! Everyone loves Brady,He seems to do better in big games while Manning seems to panic,Peyton won't be considered "one of the best quarterbacks ever" till he is wearing his Super Bowl Ring. Joe Montana,Tom Brady,Brett Farve,Joe Namith they all have Super Bowl Rings...Manning is still trying to get his first one.
 
I think Manning is a sure fire Hall of Famer and is a fantastic quarterback. He will definately go down as one of the best quarterbacks of all time. When it is all said and done he will most likely end up like Marino, if he can't get the monkey off his back this year. While Brady will be up there with Joe Montana, Troy Aikman, and John Elway.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"