Cap TFA - 8
Winter Soldier - 10
Civil War - 6.5
Average - 8.2
Avengers - 9
AOU - 6.5
Infinity War - 10
Endgame - 9
Average - 8.6
Cap only has one grandslam and no home runs.
Avengers has two home runs and a grand slam.
Avengers takes this.
Civil War is a grand slam for me. I would go Avengers, though. Just on strength of Endgame and Avengers alone.
For me Avengers, CW, IW and EG would all be home runs on their own but IW and EG combined as one epic would be a grand slam. The only other comparable grand slams in film for me would be the Star Wars OT and the LotR trilogy.Civil War is a grand slam for me. I would go Avengers, though. Just on strength of Endgame and Avengers alone.
Honestly in terms of filmmaking I find LotR trilogy a thousand times better than either Star Wars and Avengers, and it’s not even close. It’s like the peak of cinema for me.
Although I would say that Endgame is the best cinematic experience I have ever had, maybe due to the first and only IMAX screening that I have attended.
I don't knock your taste, just that I don't know what it had to do with Avengers vs Cap..............but to each their own.It’s nothing new. I think Pulp Fiction is a better film then Forrest Gump but I enjoy the latter more.
Oh ok. What did you think of Avatar? You think it was grander than any of them visually? I know the story sucked but visually it was a beast.I was replying the preceding comment.
What?! That story sucked! Visually it is amazing, not going to lie but to rewatch it is painful! I've tried! But you are right.......let's stay on topic........................but last question: you plan to watch the Avatar sequels? I think they are 10 years to late honestly. No way will they make as much as the original.I mean Avatar is widely bashed today, almost everyone bashing it for being the biggest movie of all time without cultural impact blah blah. For me it’s a technical máterpiece that I really like. I never had any problem with the story.
But let’s keep track to our topic here
You say that like Tony having control didn't bring about Ultron and cause the Sokovia situation, which led to deaths. Tony, driven by guilt, giving control of himself over to the government, to try to atone for his actions by over-correcting makes sense to me. Who says he, specifically, sides with Ross? At the end of the movie, he dismisses him.But I absolutely loathe Civil War (because it makes NO SENSE) so it really hurts my vote for the Captain America movies...
It seems to me that all the Avengers movies, I think, are about Thanos. (Even indirectly Ultron) but all the Cap movies are about Steve trying to find his place in the world, whether it's as the skinny kid from Brooklyn trying to fit in a world at war, to him trying to find where he belongs in the present thinking it's with SHIELD, and then how the world should instead fit with him in Civil War. He has never been on the side of preemptive strikes. He made that clear in Winter Soldier, and then again in Ultron when he is upset with Tony for the program he was developing. Not really because Tony created murder bots (I'm not sure Steve believes Tony is solely at fault for that) but Steve just had to take down SHIELD because Hydra managed to convince them that floating murder machines were a good idea and here Tony is basically doing the same thing even if Tony wouldn't use it the same way, or even thought to use it the same way. So Steve's position in Civil War is a natural progression. Tony, on the other hand, spent several movies making up for the fact he let others take his inventions (his weapons) and he didn't care or pay attention to how they were being used and the damage they did. That was why he became Iron Man, to stop that and to keep control of his creations. But he also knows something else is coming, which fuels his drive to protect the Earth. Yet in Civil War he's all about handing over control of not only himself but all the Avengers to a committee so they can wield them how they see fit? Because, yeah, that worked out so well before. And siding with Ross?? Whose argument is, "while stopping millions of people from dying multiple times, you broke some stuff so we're gonna tell you what to do from now on" is so weak it's insulting. Add to that how ridiculous Zemo's plan is and I just can't stand that movie, nope, sorry.