fan4stic
Sidekick
- Joined
- Oct 25, 2017
- Messages
- 2,711
- Reaction score
- 658
- Points
- 73
I go to Cap. From a direct storytelling and character enjoyment perception:
CA TFA/The Avengers: I'm a little more torn on this one than I will be on the next, as it's more conflicting to me. I am not an avid fan of The Avengers movie, as much as some are. And TFA isn't a very strong movie, to me. I almost want to tie this for that. But I also, personally, have begun to have more of a preference for some things in the structure of the Cap story. But also, I think there's more entertaining elements in TA. Tie, maybe.
TWS/AOU: This one's easier. I like the story of AOU more as some concepts, but this continues Whedon's trend of Tony being unlikable, to me. And while it has interesting concepts, to me, I don't think it's well done. TWS, to me, wins this round.
This last one's a bit more complicated, based purely on the fact that this isn't CW compared with one movie, but 2.
If I were to compare it to IW, a part of me likes IW more, but also think CW has more going on, maybe, in some cases, while IW may have more going on in others. But CW is better, in spite of me probably liking things in IW and wanting to rewatch it, more.
But, to me, EG is more disappointing than CW. So not only from a quality perspective of writing structure in that way, but also an enjoyment factor, I prefer CW.
CA TFA/The Avengers: I'm a little more torn on this one than I will be on the next, as it's more conflicting to me. I am not an avid fan of The Avengers movie, as much as some are. And TFA isn't a very strong movie, to me. I almost want to tie this for that. But I also, personally, have begun to have more of a preference for some things in the structure of the Cap story. But also, I think there's more entertaining elements in TA. Tie, maybe.
TWS/AOU: This one's easier. I like the story of AOU more as some concepts, but this continues Whedon's trend of Tony being unlikable, to me. And while it has interesting concepts, to me, I don't think it's well done. TWS, to me, wins this round.
This last one's a bit more complicated, based purely on the fact that this isn't CW compared with one movie, but 2.
If I were to compare it to IW, a part of me likes IW more, but also think CW has more going on, maybe, in some cases, while IW may have more going on in others. But CW is better, in spite of me probably liking things in IW and wanting to rewatch it, more.
But, to me, EG is more disappointing than CW. So not only from a quality perspective of writing structure in that way, but also an enjoyment factor, I prefer CW.