Cast The Movie In A Previous Time

[gwynplaine]

Sam Peckinpah's
Batman v Superman:
Dawn of Justice
(1973)
​

Bruce Wayne/Batman - James Coburn

Clark Kent/Superman - Kriss Kristofferson

Lex Luthor - Bob Dylan

Diana Prince/Wonder Woman - Ali MacGraw

Lois Lane - Susan George

Alfred - David Warner

Aquaman - Warren Oates

 

[Tg11]

Spider-Man (1985) (if the 2002 film were made in the 1980s)

Peter Parker/Spider-Man- Eric Stoltz
Mary Jane Watson- Molly Ringwald
Norman Osborn/Green Goblin- Anthony Hopkins
Uncle Ben Parker- Paul Newman
Aunt May Parker- Betty White
J. Jonah Jameson- R. Lee Ermey
Harry Osborn- Emilio Estevez
Flash Thompson- Chris Penn
Robbie Robertson- Ernie Hudson

 

[Tg11]

The Avengers (1994)

Tony Stark/Iron Man- Alec Baldwin
Steve Rogers/Captain America- Tom Cruise
Thor Odinson- Brad Pitt
Bruce Banner/Hulk- Johnny Depp (human form); CGI (Lou Ferrigno)
Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow- Angelina Jolie
Clint Barton/Hawkeye- Ethan Hawke
Nick Fury- Morgan Freeman
Loki- Willem Dafoe
Agent Phil Coulson- Dennis Quaid
Maria Hill- Brooke Shields
Dr. Erik Selvig- Jurgen Prochnow
Pepper Potts- Amy Yasbeck
J.A.R.V.I.S. (voice)- Jeremy Irons


The Avengers: Age of Ultron (1997)

Tony Stark/Iron Man- Alec Baldwin
Steve Rogers/Captain America- Tom Cruise
Bruce Banner/Hulk- Johnny Depp (human form; CGI (Lou Ferrigno))
Thor- Brad Pitt
Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow- Angelina Jolie
Clint Barton/Hawkeye- Ethan Hawke
James "Rhodey" Rhodes/War Machine- Wesley Snipes
Pietro Maximoff/Quicksilver- Leonardo DiCaprio
Wanda Maximoff/Scarlet Witch- Kate Winslet
Jarvis/Vision- Jeremy Irons
Maria Hill- Brooke Shields
Sam Wilson/Falcon- Will Smith
Peggy Carter- Vanessa Angel
Heimdall- Laurence Fishburne
Erik Selvig- Jurgen Prochnow
Nick Fury- Morgan Freeman
Baron Wolfgang Von Strucker- Ralph Fiennes
Ulysses Klaw- Gary Oldman

 

[Eddie Dean]

Ken Russell's Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice (1970)

Oliver Reed - Batman

Alan Bates - Superman

Vanessa Redgrave - Wonder Woman

Michael Gothard - Lex Luthor

Glenda Jackson - Lois Lane

with Ringo Starr as Alfred Pennyworth

and Roger Daltrey as Aquaman

 

[gwynplaine]

Billy Wilder's Spider-Man 2 (1961)
​

Peter Parker/Spider-Man - Jack Lemmon

Mary Jane Watson - Shirley MacLaine

Dr. Octopus - Walter Matthau

J. Jonah Jameson Erich Von Stroheim

Aunt May - Gloria Swanson

Norman Osborn - Fred MacMurray

Harry Osborn - Tony Curtis

Uncle Ben - Edward G. Robinson

 

[Tg11]

Batman vs Superman (1989)

Bruce Wayne/Batman- Kurt Russell
Clark Kent/Kal El/Superman- Mel Gibson
Diana Prince/Wonder Woman- Madeleine Stowe
Arthur Curry/Orin/Aquaman- Dolph Lundgren
Barry Allen/Flash- Michael J Fox
Lex Luthor- Kevin Bacon
Lois Lane- Geena Davis
Alfred Pennyworth- Richard Harris

 

[Tg11]

Doctor Strange (1995)

Dr. Stephen Strange/Doctor Strange- Pierce Brosnan
Baron Mordo- Alan Rickman
Clea- Nicole Kidman
Nicodemus West- Tim Roth
Dormmamu- Malcolm McDowell
The Ancient One- Chow Yun Fat
Wong- Robin Shou

 

[Muze]

1980s Doctor Strange

Stephen Strange - Jeff Goldblum
Baron Mordo - Jeffrey Combs or Michael Ironside
Dormammu - Peter Weller or Terrence Stamp
Wong - Dennis Dun
Nicodemus West - Jack Palance

 

[Tg11]

2000s Doctor Strange

Stephen Strange/Doctor Strange- Johnny Depp
Baron Mordo- Rufus Sewell
Dormammu- Ralph Fiennes
Wong- BD Wong
The Ancient One- Donnie Yen
Nicodemus West- Kiefer Sutherland
Clea (love interest)- Denise Richards

 

[Tg11]

The Incredible Hulk (1994)

Dr. Bruce Banner/The Hulk- David Duchovny (human form); CGI (Lou Ferrigno; voice)

Betty Ross- Bridget Fonda

Emil Blonsky/Abomination- Michael Wincott

Samuel Sterns- Peter MacNicol

Leonard Samson- Kyle MacLachlan

General Thaddeus "Thunderbolt" Ross- Jon Voight

Tony Stark/Iron Man (cameo)- Alec Baldwin

 

[Tg11]

Iron Man (1994)

Tony Stark/Iron Man- Alec Baldwin
Lt. Colonel James "Rhodey" Rhodes- Laurence Fishburne
Obadiah Stane- Ed Harris
Yinsen- Tony Shalhoub
Pepper Potts- Nicole Kidman
Raza (leader of The Ten Rings)- Art Malik
J.A.R.V.I.S. (voice)- Gary Oldman
Agent Phil Coulson- Kevin Costner
Nick Fury- Lou Gossett, Jr.
Happy Hogan- John Goodman

 

[gwynplaine]

Stanley Kubrick's Dr. Strange (1964)
​

Stephen Strange/Dr. Strange - James Mason

Baron Mordo - Kirk Douglas

Dormammu - Timothy Carey

Wong - Joe Turkel

The Ancient One - Peter Sellers

Clea - Christiane Kubrick

 

[Tg11]

The Punisher (if the 2004 film was made in the 1990s) (1992)

Frank Castle/The Punisher- Mel Gibson
Howard Saint- Al Pacino
Quentin Glass- Michael Wincott
Frank Castle, Sr.- Paul Newman
Livia Saint- Maria Conchita Alonso
Spacker Dave- Corey Feldman
Joan- Sharon Stone
Bumpo- Wayne Knight
Maria Castle- Michelle Pfeiffer
Will Castle- Kieran Culkin
Agent James "Jimmy" Weekes- Courtney B Vance
Robert "Bobby" Saint/John Saint (twins)- River Phoenix
Mickey Duka- Steve Buscemi
The Russian- Dolph Lundgren
Harry Heck- Mark Collie (the only thing that I would keep the same)

 

[Tg11]

Ghost Rider (1995)

Johnny Blaze/Ghost Rider- Brad Pitt
Young Johnny Blaze (flashbacks)- Leonardo DiCaprio
Roxanne Simpson- Gwyneth Paltrow
Young Roxanne Simpson (flashbacks)- Sarah Michelle Gellar
Blackheart/Legion- Ralph Fiennes
Carter Slade/The Caretaker- Clint Eastwood
Mephistopheles/The Devil- Christopher Lee
Captain Dolan- Dennis Quaid
Barton Blaze (flashbacks)- Kurt Russell

 

[Tg11]

Iron Man (1994)

Tony Stark/Iron Man- Alec Baldwin
Lt. Colonel James "Rhodey" Rhodes- Laurence Fishburne
Obadiah Stane- Ed Harris
Yinsen- Tony Shalhoub
Pepper Potts- Nicole Kidman
Raza (leader of The Ten Rings)- Art Malik
J.A.R.V.I.S. (voice)- Gary Oldman
Agent Phil Coulson- Kevin Costner
Nick Fury- Lou Gossett, Jr.
Happy Hogan- John Goodman

Iron Man 2 (1996)

Tony Stark/Iron Man- Alec Baldwin
Lt. Colonel James "Rhodey" Rhodes- Laurence Fishburne
Pepper Potts- Nicole Kidman
Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow- Angelina Jolie
Justin Hammer- James Spader
Ivan Vanko- Arnold Schwarzenegger
Nick Fury- Lou Gossett, Jr.
Happy Hogan- John Goodman
Agent Phil Coulson- Kevin Costner
Senator Stern- Kevin Spacey
J.A.R.V.I.S. (voice)- Gary Oldman
Christine Everhart- Patricia Arquette

 

[Tg11]

Thor (1997)

Thor Odinson- Brad Pitt
Jane Foster- Julia Roberts
Loki- Ralph Fiennes
Erik Selvig- Udo Kier
Laufey- Jeremy Irons
Volstagg- Ray Winstone
Heimdall- Denzel Washington
Darcy Lewis- Winona Ryder
Frigga- Catherine Deneuve
Odin- Sean Connery
Hogun- Robin Shou
Fandral- Liev Schreiber
Sif- Carrie Anne Moss
Agent Phil Coulson- Kevin Costner
Nick Fury- Louis Gossett, Jr.
Hawkeye- Val Kilmer

 

[David H.]

Kenneth Branagh's Thor (1990)

Kenneth Branagh as Thor
Gary Oldman as Loki
Brian Blessed as Odin
Julie Christie as Frigga
Emma Thompson as Jane Foster
Kate Winslet as Darcy Lewis
Michael Keaton as Fandrall
Robbie Coltrane as Volstagg
Denzel Washington as Heimdall
Derek Jacobi as Laufey
with Robert De Niro as Dr. Erik Selvig

 

[Tg11]

Thor (1997)

Thor Odinson- Brad Pitt
Jane Foster- Julia Roberts
Loki- Ralph Fiennes
Erik Selvig- Udo Kier
Laufey- Jeremy Irons
Volstagg- Ray Winstone
Heimdall- Denzel Washington
Darcy Lewis- Winona Ryder
Frigga- Catherine Deneuve
Odin- Sean Connery
Hogun- Robin Shou
Fandral- Liev Schreiber
Sif- Carrie Anne Moss
Agent Phil Coulson- Kevin Costner
Nick Fury- Louis Gossett, Jr.
Hawkeye- Val Kilmer

Going chronologically as far as the MCU set-up goes and since I have already done Incredible Hulk, Iron Man, Iron Man 2 and Thor now I am going to do Captain America: The First Avenger


Captain America: The First Avenger (1997)

Steve Rogers/Captain America- Matt Damon
Col. Chester Phillips- Nick Nolte
Johann Schmidt/Red Skull- Jurgen Prochnow
Peggy Carter- Kate Winslet
James Buchanan "Bucky" Barnes- Ryan Phillippe
Howard Stark- Ethan Hawke
Dum Dum Dugan- Michael Madsen
Gabe Jones- Blair Underwood
Jim Morita- Ernie Reyes, Jr.
Jacques Dernier- Vincent Cassel
Abraham Erskine- John Hurt
Nick Fury- Lou Gossett, Jr.
Arnim Zola- Philip Seymour Hoffman
Heinz Kruger- Rufus Sewell

 

[gwynplaine]

Die Hard (1967)
​

John McCLane - Paul Newman

Hans Gruber - Sir Laurence Olivier

Holly Gennaro-MacClane - Pier Angeli

Sgt. Al Powell - Flip Wilson

Karl - Klaus Kinski

Argyle - Antonio Fargas

 

[Tg11]

Pulp Fiction (1975)

Vincent Vega- James Caan
Jules Winnfield- Fred Williamson
Mia Wallace- Diane Keaton
Marsellus Wallace- Jim Brown
Butch Coolidge- Sylvester Stallone
Ringo/Pumpkin- Mick Jagger
Yolanda/Honey Bunny- Carrie Fisher
Lance- Jeff Bridges
Jody- Susan Sarandon
The Wolf- Marlon Brando
Captain Koons- Paul Newman
Fabienne- Catherine Deneuve
Zed- Jack Nicholson
Maynard- Sam Shepard

 

[gwynplaine]

Inglourious Basterds
(1975)
​

Lt. Aldo Rayne - Robert Redford

Hans Landa - Hardy Kruger

Shosanna Dreyfus - Mireille Darc

Lt. Archie Hicox - James Fox

Bridget Von Hammer - Marthe Keller

Sgt. Donny Donowitz - Elliott Gould

Frederick Zoller - Bruno Ganz

 

[Eddie Dean]

and as Hugo Stiglitz, Arnold Schwarzenegger!

 

[gwynplaine]

^

 

[Tg11]

Die Hard (1970)

John McClane- Clint Eastwood
Holly Gennaro McClane- Jean Simmons
Sgt. Al Powell- James Earl Jones
Hans Gruber- Christopher Lee
Karl- Robert Shaw
Dwayne T. Robinson- William Shatner
Theo- Ray Charles
Thornburg- Elliott Gould

 

[Tg11]

Die Hard 2 (1972)

John McClane- Clint Eastwood
Holly Gennaro- Jean Simmons
Sgt. Al Powell- James Earl Jones
Colonel Stuart- Lee Marvin
Major Grant- Woody Strode
Captain Carmine Lorenzo- Eli Wallach
Thornburg- Elliott Gould