CW's new billboards: Free to be mocked

rumpuso

Sidekick
Joined
May 17, 2004
Messages
1,034
Reaction score
0
Points
31
EW online posted a pretty scathing article about the CW's ad campaign and in particular pointed out Tom Welling's poster. Click on the link to read some of the comments after the article at the backlash from the fans.

http://popwatch.ew.com/popwatch/2006/08/the_cws_new_bil.html

August 10, 2006

The CW's new billboards: Free to be mocked

Chad Michael Murray ought to be ashamed of himself (and not just for what he did to Sophia Bush). Look at these ridiculous billboards for The CW. What is he doing? And why photograph him doing it, CW? And check out Tom Welling's weird, soft-focused, open-mouthed shot. Another has Alexis Bledel looking 15. It's like they're using old outtakes from promo-photo shoots.

Perhaps worse than the photos are the lame slogans: “Free to be cool,” announces Murray's ad. “Free to be super,” groans Welling's. “Free to be girlie,” chirps Bledel's. Really? That’s all you got?

Come on PopWatchers, let's help The CW put its best slogan forward. What would you have written?
 
You know, as much as I love Tom, I don't really like that image of him much.

*shrug*

Maybe it's not a bad thing that they're so awful, at least people are talking about them. Hopefully that will help ratings.

:up:
 
triplet said:
You know, as much as I love Tom, I don't really like that image of him much.

*shrug*

Maybe it's not a bad thing that they're so awful, at least people are talking about them. Hopefully that will help ratings.

:up:


My problem with Welling's promo is it looks stretched to me and his face look fat. I can't help but agree with them though, the promo's are not the best, the photography has a lot to be desired.:O
 
triplet said:
You know, as much as I love Tom, I don't really like that image of him much.
There's a reason why I haven't posted anything about that poster ... I make fun of the way Tom dresses, and his beard, and who knows what else, but I never post anything if I really, truly hate it. That's the most unflattering picture of him I've seen in a long time.
 
My complaint with that poster of him is that I cannot put a mood to the expression. I have no idea what he was going for with that look.
 
The whole campaign is kind of bad. . . . But the comments left after that article are great.
 
rumpuso said:
My complaint with that poster of him is that I cannot put a mood to the expression. I have no idea what he was going for with that look.
It sort of looks like they caught him mid-expression - like the frame between "one hot sexy grin" and a "wtf kind of photographer are you?" look.

I'm glad they're getting a little public butt-swat about those pictures though. Hopefully they'll FIRE the art director, or whoever it was that chose them.
 
Yeah, the first time I saw Welling's billboard, I had a serious "WTF?!?" moment....followed by uncontrollable laughter!
 
jas01724 said:
... but I never post anything if I really, truly hate it.

I'm so happy about that! Thanks!

I hope the CW people take notice of the reaction to their campaign.
 
Probably, but why all the fuss? It's just 1 picture, a picture that happens to be everywhere yes but who cares lol.
 
I must admit that I cant understand all the fuss. Its just an add campaign. Why do people take these things so seriously?

And just because Tom doesnt look like he usually does (gorgeous and drop dead good looking ;) ) doesnt mean that its a bad picture, iits just a little different than usual.
 
Who's this Tom guy I keep hearing about? Isn't that a picture of Superman on the billboard?:confused:
 
avidreader said:
I must admit that I cant understand all the fuss. Its just an add campaign. Why do people take these things so seriously?

I agree that there's being too much fuss about this.

Yes, the pic is a bit weird, but I like it.:)

The campaign could be better, but I'm glad that, at least, Tom is everywhere! And I'm glad that they used the word "super"! :up:
 
Whiteflag said:
The campaign could be better, but I'm glad that, at least, Tom is everywhere! And I'm glad that they used the word "super"! :up:

lol.. Good onya Whiteflag for finding the silver lining. :up:
That is a good point... Silly picture or not, it's a reminder to the general public that we do have a Superman to watch every week.
 
The ads don't bother me. I mean, they're not completely "awesome", but I don't mind them.

People seem to love to gripe about anything just for the sake of reading their griping. :o
 
cmill216 said:
People seem to love to gripe about anything just for the sake of reading their griping. :o

This is news to you, why?

;) :D
 
triplet said:
This is news to you, why?

;) :D

Oh no. It ain't breaking news in Cmill's World. I've become aware of this depressing fact over the past year here on the Hype.

The mall in my town has the CW posters up in the rafters (or whatever you call it) and I personally think they're okay. They've got a huge SV one right deadsmack in the middle of the mall, in between the food court and the carousel. Go figure.
 
Free to Gain Traction for About $50 Million
By STUART ELLIOTT
August 25, 2006

What is green, fills 13 hours a week of television in prime time and hopes to bring viewers top models, superheroes, a glib mother-daughter pair, high school basketball players, girlfriends, smackdown wrestling and runaways?

An ad for the third season of "Veronica Mars," starring Kristen Bell.
The answer is CW, the broadcast network that takes its name from its parents, CBS and Time Warner, and which will be introduced on Sept. 20. CW is the successor to UPN and WB, two smaller networks - weblets, in the parlance of Variety - that will go dark in mid-September after losing tens of millions of dollars between them in more than a decade of operation.

To help the new network gain traction in the proverbial 500-channel universe, CBS and Time Warner are sponsoring an ambitious campaign to create an identity for CW and by extension its series, which include "America's Next Top Model," "Smallville," "Gilmore Girls," "One Tree Hill," "Girlfriends," "W.W.E. Friday Night Smackdown" and "Runaway." The campaign, created internally and by an agency named Troika, is estimated at more than $50 million. That includes the value of the commercial time on the network and on the local stations that will be part of CW if the time were being sold to outside advertisers. By comparison, $50 million is about what national marketers like E*Trade, Hertz and La-Z-Boy each spent last year on advertising in major media, according to data compiled by TNS Media Intelligence.

The CW advertising is already running on television and radio, in print, online (cwtv.com) and on signs, transit posters and billboards. The campaign carries a theme, "Free to be," intended to appeal to potential viewers for CW series, primarily viewers ages 18 to 34.

"We did a ton of research with the target audience when I got here; I didn't poke my head out of a focus group for six weeks," said Rick Haskins, who joined CW as executive vice president for marketing and brand strategy after serving as general manager for the Lifetime cable network.

"'Free to be' is about how we can fit into their world," Mr. Haskins said, referring to youthful viewers, rather than "forcing our brand on somebody."

"This audience doesn't want to be advertised to, and doesn't want to be told what to do," he added. " 'Free to be' says, 'You can be anything you want to be and you're welcome at the CW.'"

• It had long been the conventional wisdom in the television industry that viewers watch shows, not networks, and the money spent on network branding campaigns was as wasted as time spent watching "The Love Boat."

But the success of branding ads for cable networks like the sports maven ESPN, Lifetime ("Television for women") and TNT ("We know drama") has encouraged their broadcast counterparts to undertake similar efforts.

"A network is like a shopping mall, and the shows are the stores," said Jonah Disend, chief executive at Redscout, a brand strategy company in New York. "You just don't go to the stores, you go to the mall."

Branding a network is becoming increasingly important, Mr. Disend said, because of the growing ability of consumers to watch shows "in more than one place" - that is, not only on TV sets but also on the networks' Web sites like abc.com, fox.com and InnerTube (cbs.com/innertube); on video iPods; and on Web sites like aol.com, tvguide.com, video.google.com, video.yahoo.com and youtube.com.

"As we're speaking," Mr. Disend said during a telephone interview yesterday, "I'm downloading last night's 'Project Runway' on my computer."

All the CW ads, along with the network's logo, are being colored a bright green, just as during the 1990's another broadcast network, ABC, cloaked a series of cheeky campaigns in an eye-catching shade of yellow evocative of the tint used for smiley faces.

ABC executives came in for a lot of kidding over the yellow ads, which they said were intended to convey qualities like fun and playfulness to potential audiences.

Do executives at CW and Troika expect a similar barrage of catty comments about their decision to adopt the color associated with grass, envy, frogs, menthol, chlorophyll and environmental consciousness?

"I understood some of the mocking" directed at ABC, said Dan Pappalardo, partner and executive creative director at Troika in Hollywood, Calif., who worked with ABC and the TBWA/Chiat/Day ad agency on the yellow campaign.

"The green is fresh, vital, alive, the color of spring," Mr. Pappalardo said, and is meant to signal that CW is "something new, not your typical broadcast network."

"I expect some people to react to it negatively," he added, "but in focus groups, they loved it; they said, 'This is something cool.' "

• The first commercials for CW use a version of the Temptations song "Get Ready" as reimagined by two contemporary singers, Fergie and Will.i.am of the group the Black Eyed Peas. The campaign pairs the "Free to be" theme with words and phrases that relate to the network's prime-time series, which will have their premieres over a two-week period ending Oct. 3 with "Veronica Mars."

For instance, ads for "Veronica Mars," about a young female detective, carry the headline "Free to be fearless." Ads for the reality series "America's Next Top Model" depict the host, Tyra Banks, next to the headline "Free to be fierce."

The talkative stars of "Gilmore Girls" appear in ads carrying the headlines "Free to be witty" and "Free to be girlie." Ads for the sitcom "Everybody Hates Chris," created by Chris Rock, carry the headline "Free to be funny." And ads for "One Tree Hill" feature a cast member, Chad Michael Murray, and carry the headline "Free to be cool."

"We had a challenge," said Mr. Haskins, the CW marketing executive, "in that we had to put under one roof programming from UPN and WB and make it feel like one network."

The solution, Mr. Haskins said, was to focus on what the predecessor networks had in common, which was their younger viewers, "and create an environment that was relatable to their lives."

Someday, there will be an article about television in which no executive uses the word "relatable," industry jargon for something with which viewers are supposed to identify or connect. Alas, this is not that article.


http://www.nytimes.com/2006/08/25/business/media/25adco.html
 
Maybe it's better Aquaman wasn't picked up, they might have given it the slogan "Free to be Fishy.":eek: :O
 
hope that cw slogan won't play like "Free to go plonk"..
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
201,153
Messages
21,907,325
Members
45,704
Latest member
BMD
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"