I finished reading Gone Girl on the plane home from New York, and wow... what a book. Venomous, acerbic, jet-black neo-noir with a rich vein of sadistic humour running throughout. It's been a long time since I've so impulsively read a novel, willing myself to rush through it faster because I just had to see what happened next. The whole thing is plotted out like an intricate clockwork, all the cogs slipping into place in this grand, horrible tapestry. And that ending... it made my skin crawl, I still get shudders thinking about it.
And now that I've read the book, I can say that the two leads in this film are perfectly cast. Knowing about the casting of Ben Affleck in the adaptation beforehand may have informed me picturing him in my mind's eye as I read about Nick Dunne, but really, you read this book and Affleck's probably the first guy you'd cast to play him. The whole "working class kid cursed with the looks and demeanour of a *****ey jock fratboy" thing? Hell, they even mention him having a cleft chin! And it's just the kind of role that Affleck has traditionally done best at: a curdled, eroded subversion of his All-American nice guy image, with a sense of blighted goodness. And this has those elements pushed up to 11. It'll be a challenging role for him: Nick is a difficult, thorny figure who the viewer will have to remain sympathetic towards even as we learn worse and worse things about him. But this has the potential to be a career-best performance for him.
I don't think it's the kind of role that will woo Oscars though. Nick is such a withdrawn character, and so much of his arc is about what he doesn't give away. No, if anyone has a chance to get awards glory out of this, it's going to be Rosamund Pike as Amy Elliott Dunne. Rosamund Pike is an actress I've rated for quite some time, but it seems like big stardom never really happened for her. But just when it seemed like her ship had sailed she's enjoyed a resurgence lately, doing well in this summer's The World's End, and now nabbing what must have been one of the most coveted female roles in Hollywood. She beat out some MAJOR names to get the part, and honestly, Pike fits the part so much better than the other names being bandied about. She has that extremely brittle quality that is perfect for Amy, capable of having the hardness and aloofness that Nick sees in his wife and the broken-down vulnerability that Amy presents in herself. It makes for a fascinating puzzle box of a character with many different facets and dimensions, the kind of role someone like Rosamind Pike should really be able to sink her teeth into.
It's a cracking story, and one that already unfolds like a movie in your head, so it should be pretty hard to screw up. And with someone as talented as David Fincher at the helm that possibility seems even more remote. This seems like as close to a sure thing as you can get in cinema these days, and I'm expecting one of the standout films of 2014.