Thread Manager
Moderator
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2011
- Messages
- 0
- Reaction score
- 3
- Points
- 1
This is a continuation thread, the old thread is [split]467489[/split]
But those films are what LEAD to DoFP in the first place.
I'm confused by what people don't get too. The only thing going on is some things have changed but some have remained just on a different path than we originally saw.
And don't you think if '73 Xavier knew about what happens in the following fifty years, he'd do what he could to right his wrongs and prevent terrible events - like the way he handled Jean's powers as a teen - from happening?
*in my William Stryker voice"
"And where did you get this information???"
This is why we so need a direct follow up with the First Class characters after this. I would love to see Professor X taking young Jean under his wing and teaching her how to control her powers. Would be so great!
Yeah, like Star Trek.
I think the Phoenix should've been created during a traumatic event as a child when her power first manifests, like when her best friend was killed. Jean in X2 felt something very dark and terrifying upon herself and the team. I believe it was the Phoenix. And part of me thinks she allowed herself to die to prevent this persona from inflicting a great evil on them, so I think it was already there.
If I recall correctly, Singer had two possible cues to the resurfacing or first appearance of the Phoenix in X1; Jean using Cerebro and the reaction she had to the radiation of Magneto's machine. I think the latter explains the mental blocks cracking and then, in X2, the continuous overexertion of her power finally shattered them by the end, releasing the Phoenix.
I think the Phoenix should've been created during a traumatic event as a child when her power first manifests, like when her best friend was killed. Jean in X2 felt something very dark and terrifying upon herself and the team. I believe it was the Phoenix. And part of me thinks she allowed herself to die to prevent this persona from inflicting a great evil on them, so I think it was already there.
If I recall correctly, Singer had two possible cues to the resurfacing or first appearance of the Phoenix in X1; Jean using Cerebro and the reaction she had to the radiation of Magneto's machine. I think the latter explains the mental blocks cracking and then, in X2, the continuous overexertion of her power finally shattered them by the end, releasing the Phoenix.
Thing of having the Phoenix created earlier in her youth is it defeats the purpose of that name.
In the books she effectively died as was reborn as the Phoenix. The name couldn't be more apt in that scenario. They could have done the same with X3, and that's certainly the impression I got from Xavier's little smile at the end of X2 when the bird shape formed under the lake, like he sensed she was somehow coming back and was happy about it (not in fear of it).*
As something that manifested first in her childhood though...It's just a name that persona chose and loses it's meaning and relevance.
*I don't know what Singer had planned for his version but I didn't think the Phoenix being a pre-existing persona was a part of that?