DCEU v Arrowverse: Wonder Woman v Supergirl

[Osiris-Rex]

The movie Wonder Woman versus the TV Supergirl. Who is more powerful?
Not who do you like more, who is the better actor, who is prettier, who is better written.
Just based on raw strength, powers, and abilities who is the mightiest?

 

[brandeezy89]

Diana by far

 

[Osiris-Rex]

Diana by far

Give some examples based on what has been shown in the DCEU movies and the CW TV show.

 

[Batmannerism]

Okay, in terms of raw power - Supergirl (based on that she can fly, her strength feats include saving falling planes, and that she has heat vision, super senses and speed).

However, in a fight Diana wins, no question whatsoever - she's a million times more skillfull and strong and fast enough to harm Kara, even with her bare hands.

If Diana had her lasso and weapons, the fight would be over real quick -even in unarmed hand-to-hand Diana takes this, although with more difficulty.

From their appearances so far, I just feel that Supergirl is actually stronger, and a bit more durable (not 100% sure that WW is actually bulletproof, although she did stand her ground with Doomsday).

Having said that DCEU appears to be much more powerful than Arrowverse Superman (and until recently a lot less fun).

In JL, I think we saw just how powerful he can be - looking forward to a DCEU Supergirl.

 

[Lantern Venom]

The DCEU Wonder Woman isn't nearly as strong as her comic counterpart. She essentially lost a tug of war against Superman, who was only using one arm, then he wrecked her as they exchanged headbutts. Also, based on her statement in BvS and Bruce's admonition of her in JL, she's got to be a little rusty after doing little-to-nothing for a century.

Conversely, Supergirl went toe-to-toe with a whammied Superman and beat him in a war of attrition. I'd say the Arrowverse Kara is at a similar power level that the New 52 Kara was. Moreover, she's had plenty of training at the DEO, which would lessen Wonder Woman's tactical advantage. Supergirl would take her down.

 

[Wildcard]

Arrowverse Supergirl will inevitably begin whining at some juncture and allow Diana to land the winning strike.

 

[DrCosmic]

Superman and Supergirl have always blown away all comers in terms of power. Smallville "The Blur" would absolutely trounce the entire JLA (minus Superman) and Avengers together. His feats are just too epic.

 

[Osiris-Rex]

Arrowverse Supergirl will inevitably begin whining at some juncture and allow Diana to land the winning strike.

TV Supergirl is most powerful when she is whining. Then all the rage built up inside bursts out to the surface. Don't get in the way of an angry Supergirl. Red Tomato found that out the hard way.

 

[metaphysician]

Diana. The quoted performance in JL was an outlier and incompatible with her performances elsewhere, ergo to be discounted.

Supergirl is still stronger and tougher, sure. But not stronger *enough* to matter.

 

[Batmannerism]

The DCEU Wonder Woman isn't nearly as strong as her comic counterpart. She essentially lost a tug of war against Superman, who was only using one arm, then he wrecked her as they exchanged headbutts. Also, based on her statement in BvS and Bruce's admonition of her in JL, she's got to be a little rusty after doing little-to-nothing for a century.

Conversely, Supergirl went toe-to-toe with a whammied Superman and beat him in a war of attrition. I'd say the Arrowverse Kara is at a similar power level that the New 52 Kara was. Moreover, she's had plenty of training at the DEO, which would lessen Wonder Woman's tactical advantage. Supergirl would take her down.

Something I was meaning to point out earlier is that DCEU Superman appears to be a lot more powerful than Arrowverse Superman (based on his power feats in MoS, B v S and JL - particularly JL) .

I feel like DCEU Superman would crush Arrowverse Superman pretty easily. Even if Supergirl were as powerful as Arrowverse Superman, I feel like DCEU WW would still take her down - given that she takes a headbutt from DCEU Supes without serious injury (and she's not actually trying to harm him ), she also stood her ground against Doomsday and Steppenwolf.

Kara isn't even remotely as tough as those opponents - I can't see her being that much of a challenge for WW.

As for her DEO training - well WW trained since she could walk with the greatest fighters in history, some sparring with Alex at the DEO doesn't even begin to come close.

Again, Supergirl is probably stronger, faster and has a higher resistance to injury, but WW can clearly fight stronger, faster and tougher opponents (e.g. Doomsday, Steppenwolf ) and do very well.

Given the enormous disparity in fighting skills between Diana and Kara, (and Diana's speed, as shown in JL) I can't see Kara winning. In a hand-to-hand (no weapons) fight, Kara might last a while, but in a fight where WW has her weapons, it would be over in very short order.

I think we'll just have to agree to disagree, on this one.

 

[Lantern Venom]

Something I was meaning to point out earlier is that DCEU Superman appears to be a lot more powerful than Arrowverse Superman (based on his power feats in MoS, B v S and JL - particularly JL) .

I feel like DCEU Superman would crush Arrowverse Superman pretty easily. Even if Supergirl were as powerful as Arrowverse Superman, I feel like DCEU WW would still take her down - given that she takes a headbutt from DCEU Supes without serious injury (and she's not actually trying to harm him ), she also stood her ground against Doomsday and Steppenwolf.

Kara isn't even remotely as tough as those opponents - I can't see her being that much of a challenge for WW.

As for her DEO training - well WW trained since she could walk with the greatest fighters in history, some sparring with Alex at the DEO doesn't even begin to come close.

Again, Supergirl is probably stronger, faster and has a higher resistance to injury, but WW can clearly fight stronger, faster and tougher opponents (e.g. Doomsday, Steppenwolf ) and do very well.

Given the enormous disparity in fighting skills between Diana and Kara, (and Diana's speed, as shown in JL) I can't see Kara winning. In a hand-to-hand (no weapons) fight, Kara might last a while, but in a fight where WW has her weapons, it would be over in very short order.

I think we'll just have to agree to disagree, on this one.

Yes, we'll have to disagree because I don't see the DCEU Wondy being on par with her comic roots at all. Comic Wondy has bested both Supergirl and Power Girl, so I'm not arguing that their live-actions counterparts should be the same way. However, it seems that WB intentionally toned down Diana's power level for the sake of the story. At one time, it was even unclear if she could fly, and Gadot herself suggested that the DCEU Wondy could only leap great distances.

The speed factor between the two is in Kara's favor as well. Wondy did indeed show super speed in JL (one of my favorite parts), but Kara has shown time-slowing speed on par with that of Flash. She's also shown herself to be an able tactician when she's battled other Kryptonians and even a Bizarro version of herself. So unless future DCEU installments show that Wondy's power set is greater than what we've seen so far, I think Arrowverse Kara would lay the smack down on her.

 

[Wildcard]

Superman and Supergirl have always blown away all comers in terms of power. Smallville "The Blur" would absolutely trounce the entire JLA (minus Superman) and Avengers together. His feats are just too epic.

Actually, I think Smallville's version of Clark/Superman would completely destroy DCEU Superman. Until I see DCEU Superman move an entire planet with seemingly no effort at all, he doesn't compare to SCK/S.

And built up anger or not, I don't see Arrowverse Supergirl doing anything that would throw Wonder Woman through a loop. With her thousands of years of fighting experience coupled with her immense power level, I'm pretty sure this would be close to a curbstomp for Diana.

Just my $0.02.

 

[mace1]

Superman and Supergirl have always blown away all comers in terms of power. Smallville "The Blur" would absolutely trounce the entire JLA (minus Superman) and Avengers together. His feats are just too epic.

I am not to clear on the versions you mean but if you mean canon comic versions then would I disagree with you since i know there are other characters and superheroes on par or more powerful from marvel and dc then superman and supergirl.
Smallville the blur is not on par with comic canon superman but smallville superman is i think.

Now if you talking about smallville superman(not blur)vs live action dceu justice league and mcu avengers then smallville superman is more powerful then anybody in the dceu justice league and mcu avengers so far i think (i could be wrong),but i still don't think he could beat dceu justice league or mcu avengers by himself,but who knows maybe the current dceu and mcu versions he could.
So maybe you are right about that.
The blur on smallville is less powerful then smallville superman and would be closer in power to dceu superman and mcu thor i think.

 

[mace1]

The movie Wonder Woman versus the TV Supergirl. Who is more powerful?

I would say supergirl from cw dc is stronger then dceu wonder woman.
I say dceu superman and cw dc superman and supergirl are on par,so dc cw versions are more powerful then wonder woman.


From what i seen and heard/read so far before justice league cw dc superman is are par with dceu superman,but i heard that in the DCEU JL movie superman GOT a power boost(temporary?),so i have to still see the movie to give a my clear enough thoughts.

 

[mace1]

The speed factor between the two is in Kara's favor as well. Wondy did indeed show super speed in JL (one of my favorite parts), but Kara has shown time-slowing speed on par with that of Flash. She's also shown herself to be an able tactician when she's battled other Kryptonians and even a Bizarro version of herself. So unless future DCEU installments show that Wondy's power set is greater than what we've seen so far, I think Arrowverse Kara would lay the smack down on her.

I agree.

 

[mace1]

Here some interesting debate by the way.
Wonder Woman (DCEU) vs Supergirl (CW)

https://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/battles-7/wonder-woman-dceu-vs-supergirl-cw-1880546/



CW Supergirl VS DCEU Superman

https://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/battles-7/cw-supergirl-vs-dceu-superman-1872983/


DCEU Superman vs CW Supergirl | Naruto Forums





Now donner superman and smallville superman from what i could tell are more powerful then dceu superman and cw dc superman and supergirl.
I think movie mcu thor is on par with dceu superman(mcu thor i think abit more powerful)but i have not seen justice league and thor 3 YET since i heard there have been some changes.
I will have a new clear understanding with the upgraded current movie versions once i see the new movies.


Bye.