Favorite Spider-Man portrayal

[Adhesive Boy]

Despite that all three castings have been good, Tom Holland still smashes the competition. He's fantastic as both Peter and Spider-Man.

Garfield was a bit too cool to be Peter Parker, but he had a better Spidey than Maguire.

Maguire felt more appropriate as Peter than Garfield but he never was that good at the happy part of the character. His emo arc in SM2 always just felt dull and boring to me.

 

[Kahran Ramsus]

I was unwilling to go with Holland after his small role in Civil War, but I am now after getting a feature to himself. I still like Spider-Man 2 better than Homecoming, but for the performance as the title character, Holland is tops.

Maguire is second.

Andrew Garfield's was terrible.