I still feel that the Cloud City duel between Luke and Vader was the best executed, partly because it was a physical mismatch. Vader was able to batter down on Luke's defense, while he was forced to be more evasive. Added to that, the slower, more deliberate pace of the duels in the OT lent them more dramatic gravity. The colour and sound of the lightsabres gave those scenes a frisson of energy all by themselves. You lose that when your Jedi are doing cartwheels and your Sith is standing on his head.
I equate the duels in the OT to the first Bane vs Batman fight. The choreography in neither case are that special, but it is offset by cinematography, sound design and awesome dialogue. Theballetsfights in the PT share none of the cinematic artistry.
The Empire Strikes Back lightsaber duel is still the best in the series in my opinion, and I don't say that because of the reveal at the end.
There's a point at which duels can become so focused on being artistic, dance-like, and full of "cool moves" that they lose the edge of suspense and character dynamics. I mean, sure Maul's moves might look cool but he's the most two-dimensional villain ever. He's just there as a lightsaber-action setpiece, not as a character.
I think part of this had to do with the fact that in the OT the lightsabers were meant to be heavy. If i remember right Mark Hamill said in some interview that Lucas has said that the lightsabers were powerful weapons and them hitting each other exuded such power that the lightsabers had to be held with two hands. This isnt word for word what he said, but he said something along those lines. If that's the case, of course the choreography in the OT makes perfect sense. Also, u had half man-half droid, old men and the kid who learned to handle a lightsaber a little bit duel each other. I dont think something faster than what we saw would have made much sense. While i do think some of the PT choreography does look like a dance, i believe a clear differentiation from what we saw in the OT was needed. In the PT we had jedi in their prime, fully trained since childhood, the total opposite of the OT. Faster and more agile was the way to go.Every lightsaber blow should be felt, and in the OT that was the case.
To me that To add to this you need one main villain throughout the trilogy. The problem with the prequel there was never one bad guy. It gives gravity to the story, and we learn to hate/fear them more. Having one per movie and hardly being a character at all (Dooku/Maul) just does not give enough time to fear the villain. Vader fighting Luke in ESB had so much weight to it because the last time we had seen him he had killed his mentor/friend. I remember as a kid just getting so excited the first time I saw Vader/Luke fight on Bespin.
Actually, I like Nute, not really as a villian, but as a chraacter, I do. He goes from arrogant and proud in Episode I, to cowardly and even more deceitful, to finally realizing he may have been wrong all along before being killed. And he has to know he's joined the wrong side, because he clearly shows no faith in Grevious as the leader of the armies with Dooku gone. He isn't the best chraacter, but he's stupid likaeable for me.This. I think some of the villains had some bright spots to them, but constantly killing them and bringing others kinda botched it. What if Maul hadn't been killed off at the end of the movie, and we'd have gotten to see Obi Wan deal with this guy, who killed his master? What if Dooku had been built up to from Ep 1 and not just show up matter of factly in the middle of Ep 2? What if Jango Fett had held up one more movie? Outside the Emperor the only villain to last all 3 movies is
Nute Gunray. Does anyone like Nute Gunray at all? Be honest.
So I agree that some consistent villains should be at play. Doesn't have to be like, Darth Vader 2 or anything, just a threat that builds.
Here's another example of how the prequel duels were rather gimmicky in general: take General Grievous. His function in the movie was basically to give Obi-Wan something to do while Anakin goes bad. He is a walking gimmick with his four-saber fighting style which could be more interesting if coupled with a character who has more than two dimensions, but instead comes off as a quickly disposed of "cool moment." It was almost like they said "how can we top a double-bladed lightsaber? Oh, four lightsabers!" In the end Grievous was almost a joke - Obi-Wan defeated him really easily and never seemed to be in danger. Grievous was at least somewhat intimidating in the Clone Wars animated miniseries.
This is another reason why I've never understood the fascination with Boba Fett. His armor is awesomely cool of course, but in the films he is a two-dimensional character who gets defeated by a blind Han Solo. Granted, he (and many of these characters) are given a lot more story and oomph and life in the EU, but its hard for me to back-import all of that into the films with any meaningful result.
I remember in an interview on the Phantom Menace DVD Lucas says something about how in the Old Trilogy the lightsaber duels were between "an old guy, a cyborg, and an untrained Jedi" and so TPM gave him an opportunity to show how Jedi in their prime really fight. But as we've seen from Dooku, Sidious, and Yoda, age really is not an inhibiting factor for Jedi / Sith combatants. So I really would have preferred that the duels have been kept somewhat stylistically consistent between the trilogies. There are ways to make duels exciting that don't require elaborate martial arts... and that's through having a good story.
The first Ryan/Dorkman vid was better. And cut them a little slack, it was two kids making a home lightsaber vid. Although Ryan did land a job at ILM because of it.
The Phantasm's post just reminds me how pissed I was when Anakin duel-wielded lightsabers for all of 3 seconds.
I think part of this had to do with the fact that in the OT the lightsabers were meant to be heavy. If i remember right Mark Hamill said in some interview that Lucas has said that the lightsabers were powerful weapons and them hitting each other exuded such power that the lightsabers had to be held with two hands. This isnt word for word what he said, but he said something along those lines. If that's the case, of course the choreography in the OT makes perfect sense. Also, u had half man-half droid, old men and the kid who learned to handle a lightsaber a little bit duel each other. I dont think something faster than what we saw would have made much sense. While i do think some of the PT choreography does look like a dance, i believe a clear differentiation from what we saw in the OT was needed. In the PT we had jedi in their prime, fully trained since childhood, the total opposite of the OT. Faster and more agile was the way to go.
For me the beauty of the OT lightsaber duels lie in the emotional undertones of each one: i dont really see them as physical duels. It's someone trying to get inside the other's head. In ANH Vader wanted to show Kenobi his superiority, but Kenobi was just stalling so Luke would get away. In ESB we had a father reveal himself to his son in order to get him to go along with his plan; i dont believe Vader ever meant to kill Luke or he would have, the kid was not an expert. In ROTJ we have a son trying to lure a father to the light, while the father tries to hide the cracks in his armor (so to speak lol). In the PT we had Obi-Wan fighting for his life after his master got killed, and of course the duel i had been waiting for: Vader vs Obi-Wan, and how Vader ended up in the armor. Yah, i knew they wouldnt die, but i do love that duel anyways.
I love that in ANH we see a psychological duel between Vader and Kenobi that i just adore, but i also enjoyed the physical duel they had in ROTS. The sense of peril is present for me in the Maul vs Qui-Gon/Obi duel. Despite him being a new jedi, i had no idea Qui-Gon would die when i went into the movie (thank heavens i wasnt among the ones who saw the track listing in the cd LOL). For me, there's room for both styles.
I look forward to seeing what they do in the next trilogy, assuming there are lightsaber duels coming up. Should be interesting to see where Luke takes the jedi next (i'm assuming this will be the case and we'll see at least the results of Luke's jedi order lol).
I'm just responding to Viral's wish for them getting to do the choreographies in the official movies.
Apologies for the misunderstanding,