Mansell's The Fountain is still one of my favourite scores of all time.
I've heard many praise this score. Might have to check it out after I see the film.
I think Batman Begins had the best score of the last three Batman films, primarily because we had more of an orchestra and James Newton Howard's influence was stronger. He seemed to ground Zimmer well. Zimmer always tends to be strong when he collaborates - e.g. Gladiator score with Lisa Gerrard.
The highlight of this score for me is the piece that plays on the monorail with little Bruce and his parents. I also like the use of that particular theme at the end with Bruce and Rachel. You can tell JNH wrote that. I also like the piece that played when Batman was infected by Crane's fear toxin and the track Lasiurus. That's about it.
The Dark Knight is an action score. I think it works well in the film, but besides some nice moment for Harvey's theme, I feel like the emotional level is lost. I agree - a little too much sound design and slamming. I find it hard to listen to on CD without the film.
Harvey Two-Face is the highlight for me it uses the best theme ( for me) from the BB score in the middle brilliantly. Again you can tell JNH wrote that. It fit's well with this idea of Dent being the "white knight" and "a symbol of hope". Even I have to admit that "Like A Dog Chasing Cars is a pretty good action cue. I think that theme fits Nolan's Batman nicely. Other than that nothing special about this score.
Rises pretty much repeats that. I think it's the slamming sensation that I dislike the most. I still think he is a strong composer, but he needs to move on again.
I don't own TDKR score. I'll get it eventually b/c I own the other two as well as some other Batman scores from the B:TAS and some from the previous franchise. I didn't really notice anything special with this score in the context of the movie. There was a lot rehashed tracks from the last films which I must admit was a little distracting as was the sound mix. I can tell JNH was absent on this one. He was the heart of the previous two scores. This score was lacking some of that heart, imo.
But yeah I agree Zimmer is a strong composer at times, "Gladiator", "Hannibal", "Th DaVinci Code", "Angels & Demons", and "Sherlock Holmes" are all proof of that. I just think his Batman scores didn't bring the best out of him.
Hopefully we'll be pleasantly surprised by MOS. I hope he will try to create 'Kryptonian-like' music and instruments. I guess that's a big thing for me - I want more music from his score. Less effects.
Hopefully. Just would've been nice to see somebody like Don Davis or somebody bold get hired like the way Thomas Newman was for Skyfall. I know he's a regular collaborator for Mendes, but still I didn't think they'd go with Newman. Definitely curious to hear how he'll approach that.
BTW, is the Megamind score album worth purchasing? I was thinking about getting a copy. I've seen the movie a while ago. Don't recall much of the score in the movie. I was just wondering if it's any better on the album before I decide to get it.