Is it morally right........

Shemtov

Sidekick
Joined
Oct 20, 2008
Messages
3,840
Reaction score
1
Points
31
To kill someone if another person told you to kill him or else he would kill YOU?
I think no but i'm interested what hypesters would say.
 
No, what if the person that told you was full of it? and only telling you that to act out their wishes?

Give me a break.
 
I can easily say I'd choose my own death over killing someone else.
 
i would do is kill that guy who is putting me in that position
End Of Story.
 
Psh. I kill people for no reason. If I had a reason, well, I don't see why not.
 
Psh. I kill people for no reason. If I had a reason, well, I don't see why not.
lol the only thing you probaly kill are a few of you potential children when you..."do the right thing"
 
You have no way of knowing if he's actually going to kill you. Anyone who answered yes, bad news. The Spawn is going to kill you. You should take him out first.

Maybe then no one will have the gumption to make polls. :huh:
 
Please stop making threads with polls.

And then stop making threads.
 
Lots of pronouns. How many people are actually involved?

Is it Person #1 will kill you if you dont kill Person #2?

If so, than it would not be morally right
 
A better question would be if they were holding someone hostage strapped with what looks like a bomb with a timer. You have to ask yourself the questions. Is the bomb real? Will it really go off? etc...

It still isn't right, it's just less wrong. :huh:
 
I just read all the way down this thread..........I'd like my time back
 
I smell a reference to Nazis and the Holocaust.
 
Depends on the person I'm supposed to kill, if its a 8-year old girl, obviously not, if its a serial rapist/killer, hells yes there will be blood.
 
what about in war? i mean, no one might literally have a gun to your head, but it can be kill or be killed.
 
Right and wrong are relative concepts. It's illegal, but right or wrong?

Eh.
 
Of course it's morally wrong, well...according to my morals, it is wrong. Granted the circumstances, you are still killing another person. Hell, if a man who slaughtered my family had a gun pointed to his head by me and I pulled the trigger, it would still be morally wrong. Killing him would just be justifiable and I'd feel no remorse.
 
Morality doesn't enter into this situation. It's about self preservation and most people are willing to do anything to ensure their own survival. Would I feel good about doing it? No. Would I do it? Probably. Then again, you only has this person's word that they won't kill you if you kill this other person, so it's a no win situation but faced with your own death you wouldn't think rationally.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"