I can't wrap my head around how the "true to the character" card is pulled while simultaneously referencing Ledger. Solely judging style and physical appearance, I can't think of a more singular and unique iteration than his. Even to this day.
I get the performance was unexpectedly enthralling and re-watchable, but nearly every new aspect brought to the character was bordering on anti-Joker. You could sum him up as a "lone-wolf hobo terrorist in clownface" and wouldn't be too far off from the actual part. Who can honestly say that comes close to anyone's version of Joker?
Just look at this:
It boggles me people can rag on Leto's departure but have no problem with Ledger. I can only understand it if TDK is your primary frame of reference. But anyone else... HOW?? Am I missing some essential Joker reboot appearances? The character has remained "relatively" consistent.
Superficial tats and grills do not outweigh the blatant callback imagery that Leto's evokes of past incarnations. Even if I tried I cannot say the same for Heath.