• Xenforo is upgrading us to version 2.3.7 on Thursday Aug 14, 2025 at 01:00 AM BST. This upgrade includes several security fixes among other improvements. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

Joss Whedon vs Bryan Singer vs Zack Snyder vs Marc Webb

Who would win in a fight?

  • Joss Whedon

  • Bryan Singer

  • Zack Snyder

  • Marc Webb


Results are only viewable after voting.

pr0xyt0xin

Shaper Savant
Joined
Jul 26, 2012
Messages
7,996
Reaction score
737
Points
103
Battle Royale Between Four Different Franchise Headliners!

THIS IS NOT A DEBATE ABOUT WHO IS THE BETTER FILMMAKER

This is a debate about who would win in a hand to hand fight. DO NOT vote if you are basing their success or failure based on the movies they have made or have yet to make.

joss_whedon.jpg

x5afdac8d86b22191a70f4c9d070065be.jpg.pagespeed.ic.5ZTHjgYGkY.jpg

zack-snyder-net-worth.jpg

FP990906.png


ROUND 1: FFA DEATHMATCH
All out deathmatch brawl between all four combatants. No shirt, no shoes. Four men enter one man leaves.

ROUND 2: TRIAL BY COMBAT
Each chooses a champion (no powers, just actors) from their largest grossing franchise film. LET THE GODS DECIDE THEIR FATE!
 
Last edited:
Joss whedon has the eyes of a secret mad man. There's a darkness there...a killer.
 
Joss Whedon will just head-butt everyone with that big forehead.
 
Snyder looks like the only one that works out. Webb would get his neck snapped by Snyder at the beginning of the match. Snyder then rips Singer's heart out, but out of nowhere...Whedon head-butts Snyder with his gigantic forehead knocking him out.

Snyder regains consciousness, pulls Whedon by the few remaining hairs on his head, and thrashes him into a wall - winning the match.

Too much?
 
Snyder looks like the only one that works out. Webb would get his neck snapped by Snyder at the beginning of the match. Snyder then rips Singer's heart out, but out of nowhere...Whedon head-butts Snyder with his gigantic forehead knocking him out.

Snyder regains consciousness, pulls Whedon by the few remaining hairs on his head, and thrashes him into a wall - winning the match.

Too much?

If you don't think Bryan Singer works out...
 
Bryan Singer is a hideous man, he probably gives nightmares to kids.

Maybe he pulls off his human mask and eats the other three.
 
Whedon has an ET sized head that's surely hiding the Alien creature.
 
Gotta be Snyder. Whedon would get tired, Singer would be a secret wimp and Webb may give a decent go.
 
Snyder.

He even lifts, bro.
 
Damn voted before reading the OP.

I'd change my vote to Snyder, if I could
 
Yes I can see how this fight turns out. This is how the fight goes in my mind if it wasn't beholden to pr0xyt0xin's rules and anything goes.

All the directors of the Marvel characters team up against the lone DC Hero Zack Snyder, then he turns his cap backwards and throws out 3 Pokeballs and bringing in his two boys and girl to even the odds:

tumblr_mdgv7hKUqm1ry8rcwo1_500.jpg


Ben_Main.jpg


1.jpg


By the way this music starts playing out of nowhere:
[YT]2Jmty_NiaXc[/YT]

Ok so the fight is now:

Henry Cavill vs Bryan Singer:
Henry thanks him for not casting him in Superman Returns before throwing him back to 1973. It's Super Effective!

Ben Affleck vs Marc Webb:
Batfleck uses The Kevin Conroy Batglare:
batman-glare-o.gif


It's Super Effective!

Marc Webb runs away screaming and flailing his arms for Andrew Garfield.

Gal Gadot vs Joss Whedon:
Joss Whedon, due to his admiration of strong women in fiction bows out saying that "he's not worthy for facing down Wonder Woman" after failing to get her on the big screen all those years ago.

Now with pr0xyt0xin's rules:
Snyder's dark side comes out and beats everyone by a combination of taunting Marvel characters to throw them off and of course as what Hurm said, Snyder works out.
 
The cops are called before anything cool happens and everyone scatters to avoid arrest. :o
 
It is well known that Snyder is a badass. He'd destroy all three of them especially Singer.
 
Round Two: Trial By Combat!

Each chooses their franchise champion:

Cavill vs Jackman vs Evans vs Garfield

OR

Affleck vs Fassbender vs Hemsworth vs Dehaan

OR

Gadot vs Lawrence vs Johansson vs Stone


No matter how you slice it I think the gods decree Webb is done for.
 
Round Two: Trial By Combat!

Each chooses their franchise champion:

Cavill vs Jackman vs Evans vs Garfield

OR

Affleck vs Fassbender vs Hemsworth vs Dehaan

OR

Gadot vs Lawrence vs Johansson vs Stone


No matter how you slice it I think the gods decree Webb is done for.

Correct me if I'm wrong but in the original post, you said "largest grossing franchise film", doesn't this imply their best film franchise to date? I didn't know we can recruit actors from future movies that we don't know if it will do well?
 
Voted before I read the first post! I'd definitely say Snyder in a real fight. lol
 
Whedon, Singer, and Webb all look like guys that I wouldn't want to meet in a dark alley. Snyder looks the friendliest, plus he's got that connection with Gym Jones so he almost definitely has a physical advantage. :p

Plus Snyder still has hair, the other 3 have bad cases of receding hairlines and are better behind the camera instead of in front of one! Snyder practically could've been an actor with his looks. ;)
 
Last edited:
I had a dream Snyder married my Godmother and we just kept geeking out of comic books. He wins.
 
Mark Webb is the first one to budge. Even as the battle starts, with the smoke of gun powder, Webb gets on all four and takes off his white shirt as a make shift surrender flag. He reaches the recesses of his front pocket and proudly displays his SONY employment ID card. He then reaches the back pocket of his poop stained pants and holds out, even more proudly, a picture of him and Avy Arad, with what seems to be a dog collar on Webb's neck. Snyder, Joss, and Singer, fellow human beings, fellow directors with some level of respect for their craft is disgusted at this show of servitude to the studio system, and beats the hell out of Webb for stooping so low.

Out of nowhere, the devious Joss sucker punches Snyder, and then kicks Singer in the testicles. Singer goes down positively wailing. Whedon stomps as Singer lets out a continuous stream of wilheilm screams. It looks pretty sad. When, all of a sudden, two twin boys (aged no more than 17) jump the barricade in what looks to be an attempt to save Bryan Singer. Security quickly "escorts" them out as there are rules in place of no outside help, lovers or not. And Just as Whedon knocks Singer out he gets a sharp jolt from the back.

Whedon may have momentarily knocked Snyder out, but what he didn't count on was Zack's jaws of steel. See, sometimes Zack skips leg day for jaw days. He carefully caresses his jaws with copies of Frank Miller's Dark Knight Returns. He is particularly fond of the page where Batman senselessly beats Superman. He has many copies of TDKR (300 to be exact), and there are 300 pages of Batman beating the hell out of Superman lying around his bedroom like used condoms. Anyways, Zack enters the world of slowmotion, as Quicksilver did, and easily blocks and chops every one of Whedon's practical punches and kicks with his CGI limbs. Zack then utters something pretentious like out of a line from a Goyer script (with the word fear uttered 15 times), and delivers a scathing blow. A super, special, awesome heart punch.

Though Snyder is strong, he is a bit of dullard. Instead of checking to see if Joss is down for the count, Snyder contently turns back to head for the victory podium. Joss, the mad trickster that he is, was playing possum. He slowly gets up as Zack's back is turned, removes his shirt, and reveals that he was wearing feminist push up bras that cushoned Zack's super, special, awesome blow. Whedon then reconfigures the bras to something that resembles the bossom of Christina Hendricks, only iron steel in hardness, and finishes poor Zack off.

Winner: Joss Whedon.
 
Round Two: Trial By Combat!

Each chooses their franchise champion:

Cavill vs Evans

OR

Fassbender vs Hemsworth

OR

Lawrence vs Johansson


No matter how you slice it I think the gods decree Webb is done for.

Cavill, the man is not only massive which I know means nothing in a fight but man I just want to see these two big dudes go at it. I think Cavill is gonna win though due to height.

Hemsworth holds Fassbender back with one hand and brings the hammer down.

Lawrence strikes me as a woman who will cut you if you cross her, sorry scarlett you're done.

So that leaves Cavill, Hemsworth and Lawrence, as much as I want Cavill to win and he would destroy Hemsworth he would be tired and Lawrence would pull a sucker punch (ironically on Snyders champion) kick him in the nuts and he is down.

So dirty play gives it to Singer.
 
Whedon might be the worst visual director in the entire world , so he loses by default any poll. Processing an image by himself is immediately a downgrade to every creation he made.

Snyder on the other hand , is completely unable to work outside of the ipsis verbis of any script. Great visualist , but extremely limited on everything else.

Webb made a warmth good film and then succeeded to make two of the most horrific films i had the chance to see in many years.

Singer , from what i read looks like to be a scumbag and a a vile human being. It doesn't feel right to say he's the best (which he is)
 
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"