Thread Manager
Moderator
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2011
- Messages
- 0
- Reaction score
- 3
- Points
- 1
This is a continuation thread, the old thread is [split]461895[/split]
For me, it's not even being "underwhelmed". It's like I said - I prefer the X-Men as a group, and their stories as a group, over the individual stories.
Also, while the vast majority of fans have been asking for this story to be adapted, it wasn't one that I was particularly attached to. I mean, it was a good story... but Logan isn't my favorite character, he's not even a top favorite character, and this wasn't one of my favorite stories from the comics.
But man, the more and more I watch this movie, the more and more I really appreciate how good it was. And like I said, I wasn't underwhelmed the first time. I loved it originally as well. But I can appreciate it more the more I watch it.
Except for the final act lol. I'm not a huge fan of Mecha-Samurai. Not adamantium bullet bad... but still not good haha.
Agreed on the Mech thing. My biggest disappointment with the film was that they didn't keep Shingin as the main villain as he was in the comics. What I loved about the original comic is that you see Shingin beat the crap out of Wolverine (with a wooden bokan to boot), and also break him mentally and emotionally, and we get to see him slowly build his way back up to challenge Shingin again.
I wanted the film to retain that more personal/toned down feel the original 4ish mini had. And it did, except for the last fifteen minutes, which was unfortunate.
Agreed on the Mech thing. My biggest disappointment with the film was that they didn't keep Shingin as the main villain as he was in the comics. What I loved about the original comic is that you see Shingin beat the crap out of Wolverine (with a wooden bokan to boot), and also break him mentally and emotionally, and we get to see him slowly build his way back up to challenge Shingin again.
I wanted the film to retain that more personal/toned down feel the original 4ish mini had. And it did, except for the last fifteen minutes, which was unfortunate.
I watched it finally on BD tonight, the EE doesnt add a whole lot in terms of the movie itself but the little things it does add help. Its refreshing to see Logan swearing and blood gushing in a Wolverine movie.
I cant wait to see what Mangold comes up with for the sequel, it could be something really special.
Agreed, the EE is just a little bit better than the original, if I gave that 9 I would say the EE is a 9.2. Not massivly different but with some nice additional bits in it, like Shingen burying his sword in Logans neck.
Sequal will be interesting to see as is sort of a blank canvas compared to TW which was based on Logans biggest story arc pretty much.
Yeah the EE went up to an 8.5 from an 8 for the TC for me, not a huge improvement, but an improvement non the less. Some little things like the one you mentioned really did add to the movie.
As far as the sequel, didnt Mangold say he will be basing it off a comic storyline? Even so, I have faith in him like I did with this movie, the guy is a really good director.
The more I watch the film, the more I love it.
I liked it on first viewing, but it didn't really sink in.
I finally clocked the Extended Cut and honestly, this is top tier superhero film stuff all the way. I don't know what it is, but the X-Men franchise (barring a few exceptions) has always felt more measured and thoughtful with it's balance of plot, character and action. X1, X2, FC, DOFP and TW are all films that have big action set pieces, yet they never feel shoehorned or over-long or obligatory. As much as I love most MCU films, the action can sometimes feel like a necessity more than something naturally born out of the plot.
The Wolverine dares to be small, quiet and thoughtful. It grounds the characters and their motives in reality and makes the action count when it happens. Every altercation in this film is one I felt on a more visceral level than most superhero films, even the PG-13 version. And it's not just because the fights are meant to be more brutal and real, it's because the film does an excellent job of creating atmosphere and building it's characters.
The last act, which many people find tonally jarring and too "cartoony" still retains this edge imo and I personally do not see the drastic change in tone that others do. Before I saw the film I was prepared for the last act to be some kind of jokey hodge-podge of CGI silliness. And that's not whats on screen, at all. It's not more OTT or cartoony than two men fighting on top of a speeding train.
The Wolverine is a film I can see myself always coming back to, and cements the X-Franchise as the most mature and daring superhero series of all time, despite having duds like X3 and Origins.
I have a short review: I don't really like Wolverine but I really REALLY like The Wolverine. I think that's an accomplishment.
I ending is a bit weak with that huge samurai robot villain and I wasn't exactly crazy about Viper,but overall this is one of my favorite X-men films. Wolverine was a bit more badass and I liked how it wasn't this massive special effects spectacular like X3 was. Plus,I've always liked and been fascinated by Japan and Japanese culture,so I think that's one of the main reasons I enjoy watching this.