Live-Action ("Raimiverse") Movies vs. The Spectacular Spider-Man

[TMC1982]

Note that I'm basing this on overall portrayal, not necessarily just who gave the better performance (that would be awfully hard since we're dealing with two distinctively different mediums) or who would win in a fight:
*Peter Parker/Spider-Man: Tobey Maguire vs. Josh Keaton

*Uncle Ben Parker: Cliff Robertson vs. Edward Asner

*Dr. Curt Connors: Dylan Baker vs. Dee Bradley Baker

*Captain George Stacy: James Cromwell vs. Clancy Brown

*Gwen Stacy: Bryce Dallas Howard vs. Lacey Chabert

*Betty Brant: Elizabeth Banks vs. Grey DeLisle

*Sandman: Thomas Haden Church vs. John DiMaggio

*Eddie Brock/Venom: Topher Grace vs. Benjamin Diskin

*Robbie Robertson: Bill Nunn vs. Phil LaMarr

*Flash Thompson: Joe Manganiello vs. Joshua LeBar

*Doctor Octopus: Alfred Molina vs. Peter MacNicol

*Mary Jane Watson: Kirsten Dunst vs. Vanessa Marshall

*J. Jonah Jameson: J.K. Simmons vs. Daran Norris

*John Jameson: Daniel Gillies vs. Daran Norris

*Norman Osborn: Willem Dafoe vs. Alan Rachins

*Aunt May Parker: Rosemary Harris vs. Deborah Strang

*Harry Osborn: James Franco vs. James Arnold Taylor

 

[brianbuck]

Spectacular Spider Man wins this hands down.

 

[Tacit Ronin]

Voice acting vs acting. Glourious.

 

[Blitzkrieg Bop]

How about something fair to debate, like how the characters were written?

 

[El Payaso]

Voice acting vs acting. Glourious.

That's how Mark Hammill always wins.

 

[TMC1982]

How about something fair to debate, like how the characters were written?

I guess you didn't read my first sentence stating that I was basing this more on portrayal than simply performance per se.