Discussion in 'Captain America: The Winter Soldier' started by Thread Manager, Feb 14, 2013.
I'm really glad Hayley Atwell is coming back in some capacity.
Is she? Last I heard she didn't expect to come back.
Did you not just read the press release?
Plus, Stanley Tucci kind of spilled the beans in an interview at some award show or movie premiere when discussing relationships with past costars.
What he last heard trumps the press release.
Regarding Agent 13, I think it might be meant as a surprise. But it's be weird, as even Hawkeye is referred to as Hawkeye only once and Barton all the time.
Why do people say Van Camp looks average? She doesn't look "striking" but she doesn't look average either. She looks very unique.
Marvel announced her as being in the movie. That's official. She's in the movie in some capacity likely as flashbacks.
I doubt she will play old Peggy even though Peggy is still alive.
Not really. I read the responses that said Sharon Carter was announced. lol
In retrospect I probably should have taken the time to read through that.
This is probably the best way to do the whole Sharon/Peggy thing without having Atwell play both roles: Just get someone that closely resembles her.
I really don't see it. They have somewhat similar jawlines but they still look like two completely different people with no relation whatsoever.
Who says that? I don't hear anyone around here saying that.
She's very pretty.
Eh, I don't know that she resembles Atwell at all. She's probably closer to someone like Maria Sharapova than Hayley.
And why should someone's niece or even grandniece really resemble their aunt/ great aunt, especially when there have been all these other people introduced into the lineage?
I can't help but think of a certain site. I don't even need to go there to know there will be posters posting crap like that. Some people just seem to say that for 90% of female comic book casting.
I agree, she is very pretty.
I just don't see how you can say that. They have enough similar features to be believably related and it's obvious that's what Marvel was going for. What more do you need to be able to see a resemblance? Hayley Atwell to play Sharon herself?
They look completely different bro. A jawline and eye color do not make them look similar. Their eyes are completely different, complexion completely different, nose completely different, hair color completely different, cheeks completely different...they're completely different.
We're not saying Emily Van Camp looks just like Hayley Atwell. We're saying they could be believably related.
For story purposes.
Weren't you against the whole idea of Sharon and Peggy looking alike in the first place?
The fact of the matter is Emily looks more like Hayley than I do with my family. They're not supposed to look identical, even though it's that way in the comics, but are you honestly going to sit here and tell me they look "completely different?"
I've got to admit. I don't see a resemblance myself. I have to wonder how JB's seeing it considering he's adamant they look virtually alike.
I truly don't see any resemblance whatsoever, but I also don't care. I don't think they need to look alike since they're not mother/daughter or sisters or any immediate relation.
I said they could be believably related. I never said they look "virtually alike." Before she was mentioned at all I actually wanted Imogen Poots to play Sharon even though she looks nothing like Hayley, but when Van Camp got the role I instantly noticed a resemblance.
True. It's hardly a concern (in reply to Flickchick, I meant).
No, but that's the impression you give with saying they look more alike than you do with your own relatives and seemingly scoffing at Mr. Dent saying he saw no resemblance. I'm just saying I'd like hear your thinking on how they look alike since some of us are struggling to find any resemblance.
I said that because it's the truth. Hayley and Emily look more alike to me than I do with my family.
There's no "thinking" involved. It's just something I see. I don't necessarily "want" to see it that way, it happened instantaneously with when I first saw her picture. I'm not the only one who sees it just as you're not the only one who doesn't.
If Emily VanCamp and Hayley Atwell look related, then couldn't Scarlett Johansson and Hayley Atwell look related? Or really any of the other Marvel females? Natalie Portman, Kat Dennings, etc.
Look at Kat, for example:
She looks more like Hayley Atwell than Emily does, especially in the boob deparment.
She's average compared to the usual types of actresses they get for this role. I figured that went without saying. She's obviously an attractive woman.
A subjective truth from your point of view. That's hardly fact.
It's possible you could be seeing it because that's what you want to see.
Oh that's where I went wrong. I should have looked there instead.