Discussion in 'Captain America: The Winter Soldier' started by Blackman, May 9, 2012.
Casting a geek-bait actress like Alison Brie would be a very smart thing for them to do.
Brie is my dream for this role! Although I'm not opposed to any of them, especially Clarke and Findlay who I adore as Sybil.
But basically, ever since the Russos were announced, I've been pulling for Brie to test as Sharon. Good lord, I'm a married woman and I have a raging girlcrush on her!
Alison Brie is amazing, no doubt.
But as Sharon? I don't see it. Janet Pym, on the other hand...
I dont get the love for Brie other than that she's hot. She's good on Community though, but not enough for me to think that she's perfect for the role.
WOuldnt be mad if she got it however
I'm a little bummed that Kendrick is apparently no longer in the running, but Alison Brie getting the role(most likely Sharon) would just be too awesome for words. She also... um... sorta shares... um... a couple of things in common with Hayley Atwell.
I rest my case!
Words cannot express how thrilled I am if Kendrick is out of the running, (reiterating that I dont dislike her as an actress but just dislike her for the role) personal opinion of course.
I say throw out Palmer and Findlay too.
I've never seen Brie in anything apart from these gif images.
I love her already. Sign her up.
She's really a good actress, very versatile too, as she appears on both Mad Men and Community, and does a number of movies, I think mostly comedies. But as Mad Men's Trudy, I think she shows a great deal of depth and range in her admittedly small screen time.
Also, she is absolutely charming and hilarious in interviews and on Twitter. I just adore her!
Okay, over it.
anyone else wondering why all these pics are really short women? ... Findlay is the only one I'm not sure about height wise. lol.. just curious.
Oh God, not THAT again... Sheesh!
Hey, it's a serious question, and curiosity from my part. Wasn't aware it was brought up before.
Big percentage of good actresses happen to be on the shorter end.
Is that really true though? I know plenty of taller ones off the top of my head.
Almost every actor in the Avengers was 2 or 3" shorter than the character they were playing, save Samuel L Jackson. I don't think it really matters if you cast a 5'8" Sharon Carter 5'4"-5'5".
Well, some of the actresses here, Brie and Clarke, are 5'3" .. they are just tiny ladies...
Also, aside from Brie, each of these ladies is 5 years younger than Evans... granted all of them are a lot younger than Rodgers.. lol
I still think Amanda Righetti is a better fit than any of the other possibilities so far. Too bad they don't have her on the list.
I'm more concerned about age, myself.
I'm more concerned with cup size and Alison is more than suitable.
Are you sure? They may just look bigger because she is so tiny.
They're all a fine age. You have to remember, Evans was playing a character 5-10 years younger than he actually is in CA: TFA. His love interest should be about 25.
at this point, despite the "traditional" comics-origin of sharon, at this point it's been 70+ years since Cap went on ice.. if sharon were simply Peggy's sibling's child, she'd likely be in her 60s herself at this point.. They might as well make sharon her granddaughter or great-granddaughter..
I really wanted her. too bad
In about 2009, Peggy was retconned into Sharon's Great-Aunt. The issue was Vol 5 #47-48...somewhere in there. It had Falcon and Sharon on the cover.
Brie or Clarke please. Pretty please?