But popular were those shows in Japan? Heck how people in Japan even watch cartoon Network? besides its certainly not a sure thing that Spec spidey would be dubbed in Japan or be on a channel people actually watch. I bet way more people watch Animax then cartoon network in Japan.
Like I said, much as America imports Japanese cartoons (and has in some form since the 70's), Japan imports some American cartoons. I don't know how popular they were over there, aside for the 90's X-Men which I know was fairly popular (as was TMNT in the 80's).
Besides the Japanese do stuff like this all the time. they made their own versions of witchblade, powerpuff girls, anne of green gables. This is hardly a new thing.
True. There was even a 3 episode OAV of TMNT back in the late 80's early 90's. It had...guess...the Turtles using gemstones to transform into giant sentai warriors. It was stock.
Come on, that show was funny, spider-man with a giant robot is so silly its fun.
I can appreciate "so campy it is fun". After all, I made an entire topic in the SPIDEY-WORLD section declaring that the 70's Nicholas Hammond series wasn't that bad (if not taken seriously). What I have seen of the 70's Japanese Spider-Man, though, makes him virtually unrecognizable as anything beyond a stock sentai character. The Spidey costume itself looked great, but that was about it. It seemed cliche even by Japanese standards. Just chasing the trend of what was "in" at the time.
Interesting question, but then again different markets sometimes reacquire different approaches.
Is the anime Witchblade less valid then the American comic one?
I don't know. I hear it is somewhat more faithful to the original comic mythology than the 70's Spider-Man Sentai, but that is just a second hand account. Granted, trends in Japan have changed somewhat since the 70's and while mecha is still a staple, it isn't quite as "huge" as it was even a decade ago.
The comic market is dying because of its design, super heroes are interesting concepts, but saddle them with decades of continuity and they lose their luster, but it also gives them a timeless quality that can used to market them in different forms through out the decades. The concepts are more important then the comics.
There can be a hearty debate about whether comics are "dying" that is had every few years. Comic sales are down this year, but that is only because we are comparing them to the CIVIL WAR highs that broke most ten year records in sales. The 90's were a sales peak but there still are thousands of comics on the shelves every month.
With movies strip mining the comics for ideas, one could argue the comics have never been more important. Granted, almost nothing past 1997-1998 is usually transfered into big screen lore, which should cause some concern for the Big Two.
An argument that has stronger ground is the American comics overrealiance on the superhero genre, while Manga has a wide range of genres. Granted, as a comic fan who almost never reads any American comic that isn't a superhero yarn in some regard, I am likely part of the problem.
That's because we don't care about cartoons in America, unless they are doing comedy aimed at frat boys. Kids in Amerca don't really watch cartoons much anymore, hannah monatah will often crush whatever cartoon it goes against, there are a few exceptions to the rule, but that usually the case now.
At this point live action movies based on comics are our verison of anime, they often take the source material seriously and take it to a wider audience.
That is true; animation is not as appreciated in America as it is in Japan. While the Japanese have merchandising deals tied with cartoons and always have just like the U.S., they are understand that older audiences also crave that sort of thing and offer products for the teen and adult crowd (even Hentai porn for the "adult" crowd). Much as superheros dominate the U.S. comic scene because that is where most modern comics first gained mainstream popularity, Disney and Warner Bros. were the forefathers of major animation and that legacy, or perception of it, still dominates animation today.
Even today, when a rare DTV is rated PG-13 or even UNRATED, it usually is not due to anything "mature" besides gorey violence.
That said, there still are animation projects being made by America (or at least produced there and contracted to be animated overseas before airing here). Just they are getting fewer and fewer as it becomes cheaper to just dub and import. I must say as a fan who got into anime when it first started getting a major U.S. hold in the early-mid 90's, I am appalled that instead of being galvanized and inspired by anime to produce "better" animation projects, U.S. companies simply buy rights and dub.
Maybe that is why the 80's, the last real decade of balls to the wall U.S. animation creativity (or even Hollywood creativity), is so constantly rehashed and rebooted.
Not my point, my point is these movies clear hundreds of millions dollars, making far more moneyt then
True.
Hit or miss isn't bad you can always enjoy the hits, its better then being god awful.
We have no clue as to the story quality. And we won't until more production info is achieved. Modern anime trends usually are less about animal robots and more about over the top angst. And taking 15 episodes to cross a bridge (gotta love NARUTO, taking the decompression torch from DBZ and running with it).
Its not a matter of need, its a matter of want, marvel wants more money, so if madhouse says turning wolverine into a samurai will give them more money, they will do it. Consider comic book heroes are often about interpretations, considering they are written by different people who have different views on the characters, so this is just another interpretation. Again different markets require different approaches.
Yeah, money is the bottom line, unfortunately. Quality sometimes is an afterthought.
To be fair Iron man didn't get a push till recently.
True enough, plus they wouldn't like Captain America, he would likely become some gaijin stereotype, that's a character that just wouldn't sell over there.
Iron Man is a shoe in, considering he is similar to the type of characters otakus like. Ditto with spider-man considering how well his movies do over there. wolverine is another shoe in, marvel knows which of its characters are the most marketable.
Iron Man fits in perfectly, a guy with emotional problems and a suit of armor fighting simularly empowered bad guys.
Again, Spider-Man, Wolverine, Iron Man, all the big names are naturals to be translated. When the anime versions come back here, though, you have to fear oversaturation.
i would actually like it they tried a character who hasn't had any movie exposure and actually release it in theaters. I'm an advocate that animation isn't a genre, and that an animated film can be just as serious and dramatic as any other movie, some of my favorite directors being Hayou Miyazaki and brad bird.
It would be good of Madhouse saw potential in lessor franchises. A HEROES FOR HIRE series could operate very much like, say, an OUTLAW STAR or TRIGUN in some ways. BLADE almost screams for a VAMPIRE HUNTER D esque treatment. Step outside the ninjas and shiney robots and there is an entire genre in anime that represents dark sci-fi horror, like DEMON CITY SHINJUKU, CYBER CITY ODEO, and supernatural horror type tales like DEVILMAN and even NINJA SCROLL to some degree. GUYVER of course is the easiest example I could think of a dark superhero-ish show in anime.
In anime, superheroes like 8-MAN or GATCHAMAN or HURRICANE POLYMAR or CASSHAN are often seen nostalgically from the 70's and beyond some 90's reboot attempts, usually are left aside for other anime genres.
But, that won't happen. Madhouse will run with what will make the most money. I just hope that in the "transfer" to another country, they don't just fall into anime cliches.