Most Comic Book Feel of the movies

[Lil_Flip246]

wHICH???????

 

[MaleRogue]

Well I voted X3 because of Phoenix and all and the cure plot....it was the most like of all the movies X1 wasn't because that was about Rogue and her powers and why she has a white strike...X2 isn't one also i can't name anything that looked like the comic so it's X3 to me

 

[javon]

I picked X3 too. I mean come on, Storm flying, Bobby Icing up, Dark Phoenix (not all that right though)

 

[X-Gal123]

X3 was more like the comics because it had the action, people comeing back from the dead, and a lot of power usage very quickly. It definitely had more of the comic feel compared to the other two.

 

[oneteen]

I think X1 was. Every character had their own share of screen time.

 

[javon]

I think X1 was. Every character had their own share of screen time.

LMAO!!!

 

[crappymovie]

LMAO!!!

At least the main characters at least spoke and had an action scene in X1. Each one did. X3 was full of nameless mutants, with absolutely no impact at all. Collosus could have been replaced by a strong, fat mutant named "Bertha", who's power could be to "throw Wolverine." Likewise, Callisto could have been "Speedrunner." At least in X1, the characters had SOME sembelance of their comic persona. Definitely more than the few mutants who X3 focused on.

And really, just because Storm stood around in X1, you think she didn't get her screentime. She got her deserving screentime....not the character, Halle Berry.

 

[memphisplayrr]

i agree 100% with what crappymovie said

bertha, throw wolverine
hahah
good one

 

[crappymovie]

But I just wanted to say, X3 definitely has the most comic book feel....the same way Fantastic Four did. If this is a good thing or not....it's your choice.

 

[lordofthenerds]

At least the main characters at least spoke and had an action scene in X1. Each one did. X3 was full of nameless mutants, with absolutely no impact at all. Collosus could have been replaced by a strong, fat mutant named "Bertha", who's power could be to "throw Wolverine." Likewise, Callisto could have been "Speedrunner." At least in X1, the characters had SOME sembelance of their comic persona. Definitely more than the few mutants who X3 focused on.

And really, just because Storm stood around in X1, you think she didn't get her screentime. She got her deserving screentime....not the character, Halle Berry.

I agree completely. I chose X1. I thought that it had an X-Men feel to it.

 

[livrule]

X3.

without question.

 

[XCharlieX]

Perhaps x3 has this comic feel if some think so, but it still works as the same feel of the first 2 also imo.

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

I think X1 and X3 have more of a comic feel... cause When I watched X2 without watching X1 for so long, I got bummed out cause I really wanted to see X1 again and see how each character interacted in X1. So without X1 for the time being (This was before I got both X-Men movies on DVD) I was stuck with watching X2 without knowing what happened in X1. X1 , after seeing for so long, brought me back to the X-Universe altogether. Without it, I probably wouldn't have cared so much for Jean, Scott, and Logan... and ... a few others. But I do now. I could give them little teddy bears for them to cuddle with. ... er...lol.

Anyway, X1 made me appreciate the X-World/Universe/X-Men as a whole, but without it, I wouldn't really have a comprehensive uh... feel for it within the context of how each X-Men are involved within the story and how they're connected to each other (Jean and Scott for example).

but anyway, I voted for X3...but if t here was a 4th option of 1 and 3 ... i'd vote for X1 and X3... ah who am i kidding. they're all great and awsome as a whole.

I hope u get what I mean...cause It was so long since I last saw X-Men and I thought I was missing out a lot. It wasn't until I bought the dvds, I became an X-Men myself... and became connected to Jean... through the movieverse but after watching X-Men Evolution, damn that show is good (too bad it ended ) I came to appreciate and understand her more and her powers too. Jean Grey is the 'fire' within the heart of the X-Men and the power she beholds within herself is so Intriguing. don't ya think?

 

[iamcolossus]

I would have to say X2 was the most like the comics simply for the fact that the characters just seemed to be more believable in the second movie. Though I thoroughly enjoyed having more characters in the third film, some of them just seemed to be overdone.

 

[oneteen]

At least the main characters at least spoke and had an action scene in X1. Each one did. X3 was full of nameless mutants, with absolutely no impact at all. Collosus could have been replaced by a strong, fat mutant named "Bertha", who's power could be to "throw Wolverine." Likewise, Callisto could have been "Speedrunner." At least in X1, the characters had SOME sembelance of their comic persona. Definitely more than the few mutants who X3 focused on.

And really, just because Storm stood around in X1, you think she didn't get her screentime. She got her deserving screentime....not the character, Halle Berry.

Thank you for that.

 

[Farren]

I went with X3...it just had a comic flavor too it, esp Magneto's recruitment scene at the church - there was something surreal about it, whereas X1 and X2 felt more grounded in reality.

But I agree with crappymovie:

At least the main characters at least spoke and had an action scene in X1. Each one did. X3 was full of nameless mutants, with absolutely no impact at all. Collosus could have been replaced by a strong, fat mutant named "Bertha", who's power could be to "throw Wolverine." Likewise, Callisto could have been "Speedrunner." At least in X1, the characters had SOME sembelance of their comic persona. Definitely more than the few mutants who X3 focused on.

 

[fallenAngel]

I'd say X men. It changed a lot, but it felt more like a team movie to me for some reason.

at least it feels like early X men to me.

 

[borinquenknight]

Its funny but it seems that even though the characters were new they really did have a more lasting impact in Xmen (though Nightcrawler was awesome in X2). I'm not sure if teh actors were just trying harder because they needed to establish the franchise or not but I saw it again this past weekend and it was a great foundation for the franchise. X3 was comical at best and tore apart what was established in the first 2 films in regards to the series' tone.

 

[Decay]

X3 for sure.

 

[Spoarz™]

I voted X3

 

[Warhammer]

X3 definitely felt the most comic book like.
Not as comic book as Hellboy or Sin City, but alot more comic book than X-Men or X2.

 

[Nell2ThaIzzay]

X-Men: The Last Stand feels the most like a comic book.

But X-Men and X2 feel the most like X-Men...

 

[iamcolossus]

X-Men: The Last Stand feels the most like a comic book.

But X-Men and X2 feel the most like X-Men...

So true....so true....

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

Im kinda in between. I like all of them.