BAH HUMBBUG!
There's an invisible man
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2006
- Messages
- 9,432
- Reaction score
- 26
- Points
- 33
Trying to start this thread back up hopefully we can get some fresh blood in here.
Here is the old thread....
So what I've done is assign a rating of X/100 based on how good I think the comic book is, now don't get all up in arms here but this is purely based on my opinion and what I've read, hence the more people vote, the more the scores will average out.
I know I haven't read a lot of the titles mentioned, but hey that's life. Also this is a work in progress and can only improve and I am going to be working on it for some time to come and really try to make this a must-go-to-list for all comic fans here.
If you guys want to just PM me your scores I will update accordingly.
http://forums.superherohype.com/showthread.php?t=186190
And this is most if not all of the comics that have been recommended. I will attempt to put some sort of scale on them as far as it being recommended on a scale of 1-10 or four stars or five to give a people of not only that it is good and you should read it but it is incredibly good and should be the thing you read next.
Here is the old thread....
So what I've done is assign a rating of X/100 based on how good I think the comic book is, now don't get all up in arms here but this is purely based on my opinion and what I've read, hence the more people vote, the more the scores will average out.
I know I haven't read a lot of the titles mentioned, but hey that's life. Also this is a work in progress and can only improve and I am going to be working on it for some time to come and really try to make this a must-go-to-list for all comic fans here.
If you guys want to just PM me your scores I will update accordingly.
http://forums.superherohype.com/showthread.php?t=186190
And this is most if not all of the comics that have been recommended. I will attempt to put some sort of scale on them as far as it being recommended on a scale of 1-10 or four stars or five to give a people of not only that it is good and you should read it but it is incredibly good and should be the thing you read next.
To people looking for recommendations: Whether you've just started reading comics and are looking for what's good, or are an old-timer who thinks he's running out of things to read, we welcome you. I hope you find the recommendations contained in this thread helpful, and I assure you I try to only recommend things I find to be at the top of the pile of quality, although our views may differ from time to time. Even if it fits into a genre you've not previously been a fan of, I encourage you to give them all a try anyway, as the books below are of the best stories comics have to offer, and the best works in any genre often transcend their genre. Also, we always recommend you start at the begining of any series, as most books are quite linear, and jumping on in the middle will sometimes ruin the surprise of great events that happened before.
if you are having difficulty finding a place to get these books, I can tell you that most Borders, Walden Books, and Barnes and Noble have small graphic novel sections, and should be able to order many graphic novels for you that they do not keep in stock. Also, www.the-master-list.com will assist you in finding your nearest comicbook stores. If you've never been to a comicbook store before or recently, I highly recommend you stop by one and hopefully will find a pleasent conversation with the clerk on duty, and may see some more things you enjoy. Lastly, graphic novels can be found at www.amazon.com, www.ebay.com, www.milehighcomics.com, www.dreamlandcomics.com, www.talesofwonder.com, and www.instocktrades.com . I hope this will all be helpful to you. Happy reading!
ORT ver 2.0 (A work in progress): http://superherohype.com/forums/showthread.php?t=235880
Index
Page 1
1-100 Bullets
2-V for Vendetta
3-Transmetropolitan [90/100](1)
4-District X
5-Preacher
6-Runaways
7-Daredevil
Page 2
8-Planetary
9-Y-The Last Man
10-Sentry
11-Books of Magic
12-Batman: The Killing Joke [86/100](1)
13-Lucifer
14-Superman: Red Son [74/100](1)
15-Marvel Team-Up
16-Camelot 3000
Page 3
17-Thunderbolts
18-Kingdom Come [84/100](1)
19-Spider-Man/Human Torch
20-Powers
21-Thor: Vikings [78/100](1)
22-Hammer of the Gods
23-Barry Ween Boy Genius
24-The Mask
25-Invincible [86/100](1)
26-The Walking Dead [85/100](1)
27-Young Avengers
28-Marvels
Page 4
29-X-Men: God Loves, Man Kills
30-Bloodhound
31-Taskmaster
32-Strangers in Paradise
33-Starman
34-Fables
35-Elfquest
36-Green Arrow
37-Green Lantern/Green Arrow
38-Green Arrow: The Longbow Hunters
Page 5
39-Daredevil: Wake Up
40-Mutant X
41-Young Justice
41-Dr. Strange and Dr.Doom: Triumph and Torment
43-The Death of Captain Marvel
44-Squadron Supreme
45-Supreme Power [78/100](1)
46-Animal Man
Page 6
47-Avengers Forever
48-Uncle Sam
49-Empire
50-Scurvy Dogs
Page 7
51-Rex Mundi
52-Wildguard
53-Girls
54-Ultra
55-Caper
56-Concrete
Page 8
57-Operation: Galactic Storm
58-The Infinity Gauntlet [88/100](1)
59-Wanted [69/100](1)
60-JLA: Tower of Babel
61-JLA: Year One
62-She-Hulk
63-Great Lakes Avengers
64-Arkham Asylum: Living Hell
65-Spectacular Spider-man: The Child Within
66-The Tick
67-Boris the Bear
68-Top Ten
69-Batman: The Dark Knight Returns [96/100](1)
70-Sleeper
Page 9
71-The Question
72-Elektra Lives Again
73-Ronin
74-Arkham Asylum
Page 10
75-Challengers of the Unknown
76-DC: The New Frontier
77-Watchmen [94/100](1)
78-Sandman
79-Invisibles (mutant, I hope you don't mind but I'm gonna re-do these later)
80-Superman: Secret Identity
81-Astro City
82-Batman: The Long Halloween
83-Daredevil: Born Again
Page 11
84-The Authority
85-Ultimates [74/100](1)
86-Judge Dredd
87-American Flagg
88-Ex Machina
89-Howard the Duck
Page 12
90-Space Ghost
91-The Ring, the Arrow, and the Bat
92-Conan (1970)
93-Conan (2003)
94-Promethea
Page 13
95-Punisher: Born
96-Batman: Year One [90/100](1)
Page 14
97-Startling Stories: Banner [72/100](1)
98-Tilting at Windmills
99-The Losers
100-Lone Wolf and Cub
101-The Coffin [86/100](1)
102-Deep Sleeper
103-The Atheist
Page 15
104-Nightwing: Year One
105-Pedro and Me
Page 16
106-Squee's Big Giant Book of Unspeakable Horrors
107-The Golden Age
Page 17
108-Wolverine: Enemy of the State [82/100](1)
109-Alias
110-Star Wars Tales
111-The Flash: Blitz
112-Shaolin Cowboy
113-Doc Frankenstein
Page 18
114-Superman:Exile
115-Black Panther by Christopher Priest
116-Captain America: The New Deal
117-Daredevil: Guardian Devil
118-Fantastic Four: Unthinkable
Page 19
119-Earth X
Page 20
120-Sandman
121-Bone
Page 21
122- Akira
123-MAUS
Page 22
124-JSA: Justice Society America
125-Batman: The Man Who Laughs
Page 23
126-Murder Mysteries
127-Batman: Ego
128-Batman: Venom [83/100]
129-Captain America: To Serve and Protect
130-Captain America: The New Deal
131-Captan America: Lives Again
Page 24
132-A Contract With God:
133-The Official Handbook of The Marvel Universe
134-Captain America: Streets of Poison[TPB]
Page 25
135-The Knights of Pendragon [Mini]
136-What If The Punisher Became Captain America [SI]
Page 26
137-Deadpool [1992 Mini]
138-Deadpool [1994 Mini]
139-Deadpool [1992 OG]
Page 27
140-Blankets [GN?]
Page 29
141-The Thanos Quest [Mini] [82/100]
Page 32
142-300 [GN]
143-Sandman Mystery Theatre [GN]
Page 35
144-Testament [OG]
page 36
145-It's A Bird [GN]
146-The Dead boy Detectives [TPB?]
147-The Little Endless story book [TPB?]
Page 40
148-Grendel: Red, White, & Black [GN]
149-Planet Hulk [OG/TPB] [84/100]
Page 41
150-torso: a true crime graphic novel [GN]
151- Fire [GN]
Page 43
152-Batman: The Cult [TPB] [83/100]
page 45
153-Loveless: A King of Homecoming [TPB?]
Page 46
154-New X-men Vol 1: E is for Extinction
Page 47
155-Chosen [Mini]
Page 48
156-Captain America: Winder Soldier [TPB]
157-Ultimate Spider-Man Collection [OG/TPB/HC] [80/100]
Page 50
158-Adam Strange [TPB?]
159-Astonishing X-Men [OG]
Page 51
160-100% [GN]
161-Gotham Central [OG]
162-Fray [TPB]
163-Helloboy: Seed of Destruction [TPB]
Page 52
164-Lex Luthor: Man Of Steel [Mini]
165-Superman: Birthright [Mini]
166-Marvel: 1602 [Mini]
167-Exiles [OG/TPB]
168-Arrowsmith
169-Astro City
170-Captain Marvel Vol.4 [72/100]
171-We3
Page 53
172-The Mighty Thor (Dan Jurgens run)
173-JLA: Obsidian Age [TPB]
174-Justice League (Keith Giffen)
175-Batman: Hush [75/100]
176-Identity Crisis
Page 57
177-The Boys
178-Give Me Liberty
Page 60
179-Stray Bullets
180-What If ? Impossible Man Got The Infinity Gauntlet [75/100]
Page 61
181-Moon Knight (Huston run0
182-Dark Blue [84/100]
Page 63
183-The Other Side
184-The Comical Tragedy or Tragical Comedy of Mr. Punch
Page 64
185-Hawkman (Geoff Johns)
Page 70
186-The Incredible Hercules [82/100]
Ok, so we get people asking for recommendations at least once a month. Now, instead of us each responding to each of these requests with lists of what we all suggest, let's just have an official recommendation thread we can point them too.
Now, I've long had issues with people simply making lists of good books. I think it's important to pitch books to people, tell them what they're about instead of just giving them a title. Show some artwork That way, they can judge for themselves a little better. Cause let's face it, there's a LOT of books out there we could all recommend. Let people pick what sounds interesting to them, and let them judge that by more than just the name of the book.
So what I'd ask you all to do is if you want to recommend something here, at least give a short paragraph or so about what the books is about and why you like it. Also tell them where they should start, how many books are in the series and such. Post images from the book, too. As a general policy, let's try and have it be stories that are avalabe in trade, not just arcs from in the middle of a book that will never be reprinted. Then, just link people here whenever they ask for something
Last edited: