Poll: Whose fault was it?

[Barry Allen]

If you didn't like the movie, where do you think blame should be placed?

 

[Blackpanther22]

I liked the movie, but i feel it was too short & rushed. I blame the studio & some of the producers.

 

[uknowho]

The movie wasn't perfect, but I enjoyed it... a lot.

 

[Avalanche]

Well, I liked it on the whole.

As for the faults, I think everyone can take a portion of the blame. Ratner wanted a shorter movie, FOX made some stipulations, the writers made some silly choices, and the actors had a couple of bad deliveries.

I don't think the faults are any one person's onus.

 

[Secret_Riddle]

i liked the movie it was rushed yes and didnt have as much depth or emotion but i still loved it even if it wasnt as good as x2

 

[WTFimVENOM]

Blame the FX team, they really messed up collossus (although iceman looked amazing)

 

[chaseter]

I liked the movie, but i feel it was too short & rushed. I blame the studio & some of the producers.

Me too.

 

[Avalanche]

Blame the FX team, they really messed up collossus (although iceman looked amazing)

I thought Colossus looked better than Iceman.

 

[Odin's Lapdog]

ourselves for having too high an expectation of it....

and also press release for leaking too much footage but then again this comes down to ourselves again for viewing it all...

 

[Odin's Lapdog]

I thought Colossus looked better than Iceman.

they were both below par...

 

[WTFimVENOM]

I thought Colossus looked better than Iceman.

Colossus didn't look as good as he did in X2, he was perfect there

 

[Avalanche]

and also press release for leaking too much footage but then again this comes down to ourselves again for viewing it all...

This is true. I regret watching so many clips. They spoiled those scenes for me. By far the best scenes were the ones I was viewing for the first time at the cinema.

 

[Avalanche]

Colossus didn't look as good as he did in X2, he was perfect there

I disagree. He looked far from perfect in X2 in my opinion. He needed a bit more shine. He was very dull-looking for a metallic being.

 

[Nathan]

Where's the option "All of them"?

 

[PhePhe112]

i blame fox.....
thanks a lot for messing this up!

 

[Steelsheen]

FOX -- for not giving this film enough time to prepare properly

for some reason FOX never seem to care much for this franchise regardless of how well it does financially.

 

[WTFimVENOM]

I disagree. He looked far from perfect in X2 in my opinion. He needed a bit more shine. He was very dull-looking for a metallic being.

Maby ur right about that, but at least he had white eyes, black hair, and a really cool texture (although not as metalic) in X2

 

[Nibune]

1. I blame the lack of time and the decision no to add a Phoneix Firebird on RATNER






simon an zak due however fall into certain blame for misleading about certain things and for not developing more dialogue

Cyclops fans well that was no doubt FOX

 

[DACrowe]

Fox but Ratner and definetly Kinberg and Penn deserve some of the blame.

Alas.

 

[Iceman]

Well, I liked it on the whole.

As for the faults, I think everyone can take a portion of the blame. Ratner wanted a shorter movie, FOX made some stipulations, the writers made some silly choices, and the actors had a couple of bad deliveries.

I don't think the faults are any one person's onus.

I also liked the film but I'd agree that the blame for the flaws has to be shared with all those involved.

 

[WTFimVENOM]

He needed a bit more shine. He was very dull-looking for a metallic being.

I dunno man, I think this is pretty metallic if u ask me. I like it better than the X3 look

 

[Kroc1138]

Ultimately the Studio for not ultilizing Script quality control and for being heavy handed in the editing process. But that's the simplified version. There's blame to pass around.

I and for the record, I was very disappointed with the movie. I enjoyed aspects of it. The after-credits scene saved the movie in my opinion.

 

[nightbringer]

The movie did have a rushed feel to it. How hard would it have been to add another 10-20 minutes to elaborate on a few things.

 

[Cyclops]

I dunno man, I think this is pretty metallic if u ask me. I like it better than the X3 look

That's... um.... what's being said. Colossus looked lame in X3 compared to X2.'

Anyway, for me, the ruination was at the fault of everyone. The scriptwriters, the director, the studio, the actors... all of it.

 

[Odin's Lapdog]

x2 collosus actually looks more dull than x3 collosus which a good thing

i had problems with the shine and with his hair turning as well...although i can't remember if it does in the comics...