Rank 'em: Season 5

[avidreader]

THe episode with Chloe and the dead girl was the worst i`ve seen of Smallville. Nothing to do with Superman. The writers simple forgot the basis of this show. God, how can the producers of this show greenlight episodes like this???

Could be that there are alot of fans out there who actually care about Chloe.

 

[jas01724]

'Rene requested a bump of this thread ...

 

[avidreader]

'Rene requested a bump of this thread ...

You always seem to be there just popping up when someone calls. I so love that, and I love your new web design too.

 

[Serene]

'Rene requested a bump of this thread ...

And James to the rescue...

Thanks, bud.

 

[The Sage]

My top four:

Solitude
Lexmas
Cyborg
Splinter

 

[Serene]

Since we've had 3 more eps air since this was last updated, I thought we could update our lists... and the cumulative list.

Here is the overall list that Pat posted based on all the lists posted.

I'll update this post with new episode titles as they're announced, but here's where we stand as of 2/10/06:

Aired eps
01 Arrival
02 Mortal
03 Hidden
04 Aqua
05 Thirst
06 Exposed
07 Splinter
08 Solitude
09 Lexmas
10 Fanatic
11 Lockdown
12 Reckoning
13 Vengeance
14 Tomb

The episodes to be weaved in to the above list are: Cyborg, Hypnotic, and Void.

 

[avidreader]

Since we've had 3 more eps air since this was last updated, I thought we could update our lists... and the cumulative list.

Here is the overall list that Pat posted based on all the lists posted.

The episodes to be weaved in to the above list are: Cyborg, Hypnotic, and Void.

You show me yours and I'll show you mine.

 

[KalKai]

James, you gotta change that picture, it's not that it's bad.. but he was at the party having fun.. and with his EYES CLOSED, lol.

 

[Kane]

My top three:

Solitude
Cyborg
Hidden

These are the only episodes I thought were well written for the most part and deserved to be called 'good' or 'great'.

The rest had good points and bad points.

 

[jas01724]

You always seem to be there just popping up when someone calls. I so love that, and I love your new web design too.

I'm like a bad smell ... always hanging around. And thankies.

Thanks, bud.

No problemo.

 

[avidreader]

Hidden
Reckoning
Splinter
Cyborg
Arrival
Vengeance
Mortal
Solitude
Void
Thirst
Lexmas
Hypnotic
Fanatic
Lockdown
Tomb
Exposed
Aqua

 

[Serene]

Okay.. here's my update with a tweak or two:

Hidden
Reckoning
Splinter
Mortal
Lexmas
Cyborg
Arrival
Lockdown
Void
Vengeance
Solitude
Thirst
Aqua
Fanatic
Exposed
Hypnotic
Tomb

**Reminder.. if you want your list to be incorporated into the overall list, then you have to format it as Most favorite to Least favorite. Doing by numerical ratings with "ties" won't work. Of course, you are free to do as you want.

 

[Jay1/2Dub]

My new list...

01 Solitude-10/10
02 Arrival-10/10
03 Cyborg-10/10
04 Reckoning-10/10
05 Splinter-10/10
06 Lexmas-9/10
07 Hidden-8/10
08 Exposed-8/10
09 Lockdown-7/10
10 Aqua-7/10
11 Void-7/10
12 Fanatic-6/10
13 Vengeance-5/10
14 Mortal-5/10
15 Hypnotic-4/10
16 Thirst-3/10
17 Tomb-1/10

 

[AgentPat]

My criteria for order preference is based on how apt I am to rewatch a specific episode, so my list has changed a little bit since the last time we did this. The separation gets a little fuzzy with episodes listed after Cyborg on the list below. For example, Hypnotic and Void are probably higher than they should be, but since they aired so recently, I'm more likely to rewatch them more than say episodes like Lexmas or Exposed.

I think the eps will settle into a more permanent order of preference after the season ends, but here's my list as it stands today...

01 Hidden
02 Mortal
03 Arrival
04 Splinter
05 Reckoning
06 Solitude
07 Aqua
08 Vengeance
09 Cyborg
10 Hypnotic
11 Void
12 Lexmas
13 Exposed
14 Thirst
15 Lockdown
16 Fanatic
17 Tomb

I'll do a tally through Void when more folks have posted. Should be interesting to see how much has changed.

 

[Brainiac 8]

Here we are...updated list time. And yes Pat, mine has changed some as well.

Solitude
Mortal
Cyborg
Hidden
Reckoning
Arrival
Lexmas
Splinter
Aqua
Exposed
Lockdown
Vengeance
Hypnotic
Thirst
Fanatic
Tomb
Void

 

[avidreader]

Two new episodes to add to the list. I think the next three episodes are going to be almost a 3 parter, so I rank 'em until after they're done.

Hidden
Reckoning
Splinter
Mortal
Fragile
Mercy
Cyborg
Arrival
Vengeance
Solitude
Void
Thirst
Lexmas
Hypnotic
Fanatic
Lockdown
Tomb
Exposed
Aqua

 

[triplet]

Hidden
Splinter
Mortal
Cyborg
Mercy
Reckoning
Solitude
Fragile
Arrival
Vengeance
Void
Thirst
Lexmas
Lockdown
Fanatic
Exposed
Aqua
Tomb
Hypnotic

 

[Serene]

I'm having a really hard time putting Mercy in above, or below, Cyborg. It's really kind of a tie.

Hidden
Reckoning
Splinter
Mortal
Lexmas
Cyborg
Mercy
Arrival
Lockdown
Void
Vengeance
Solitude
Thirst
Aqua
Fanatic
Exposed
Hypnotic
Tomb

 

[GothicPowerMix1]

My Top 3 are (not in any order)

Splinter
Cyborg
Lexmas

 

[LL2K2]

Updated through #5-19:

Let's see...

Excellent Episodes (5/5): Mortal, Hidden, Solitude, Cyborg

Above Average (4/5): Arrival, Exposed, Splinter, Lexmas, Mercy

Good Episodes (3/5): Aqua, Fanatic, Lockdown, Reckoning, Tomb, Fragile

Fair Episodes (2/5): Thirst, Vengeance, Void

Yuck! (1/5): Hypnotic

Overall rankings, most favorite to least favorite:

Hidden
Mortal
Solitude
Cyborg
Arrival
Lexmas
Splinter
Mercy
Fragile
Exposed
Aqua
Fanatic
Reckoning
Tomb
Lockdown
Thirst
Vengeance
Void
Hypnotic

 

[TKodami]

Ranked from most favorite to least favorite:

1. Reckoning (5/5)
2. Mercy
3. Hidden
4. Arrival
5. Fanatic
6. Cyborg
7. Exposed
8. Lockdown
9. Aqua
10. Splinter
11. Solitude
12. Fragile
13. Lexmas
14. Void
15. Tomb
16. Mortal
17. Vengeance
18. Hypnotic
19. Thirst (3/5)

 

[boydston_14]

#1-512/Reckoning
#2-501/Arrival
#3-508/Solitude
#4-503/Hidden
#5-507/Splinter
#6-515/Cyborg
#7-519/Mercy
#8-504/Aqua
#9-510/Fanatic
#10-502/Mortal
#11-517/Void
#12-518/Fragile
#13-511/Lockdown
#14-513/Vengeance
#15-516/Hypnotic
#16-505/Thirst
#17-514/Tomb

I still haven't seen Lexmas or Exposed yet.

 

[The Caped Knight]

Update

{SUPER EPISODES}
1. Solitude
2. Splinter
3. Exposed
4. Cyborg
5. Mercy

{Good Episodes}
6. Hidden
7. Lexmas
8. Aqua
9. Arrival
10.Vengeance

{Ok episodes}
11.Reckoning
12.Lockdown
13.Fanatic
14.Mortal
15.Tomb
16.Fragile

{Bad Episodes}
17.Hypnotic
18.Void
19.Thirst

 

[Tornado]

Thusfar:

1. 503 - Hidden
2. 512 - Reckoning
3. 501 - Arrival
4. 508 - Solitude
5. 519 - Mercy
6. 518 - Fragile
7. 515 - Cyborg
8. 510 - Fanatic
9. 509 - Lexmas
10. 513 - Vengeance
11. 507 - Splinter
12. 504 - Aqua
13. 502 - Mortal
14. 517 - Void
15. 516 - Hypnotic
16. 511 - Lockdown
17. 506 - Exposed
18. 505 - Thirst
19. 514 - Tomb

This Week: 520 - Fade
Future: 521 - Oracle and 522 - Vessel

 

[tonytr1687]

Hidden
Splinter
Mortal
Cyborg
Mercy
Reckoning
Solitude
Fragile
Arrival
Vengeance
Void
Thirst
Lexmas
Lockdown
Fanatic
Exposed
Aqua
Tomb
Hypnotic

You have Thirst and Fragile above Lexmas? Shame on you, Triplet...

Mine:

Hidden - 10
Reckoning - 10
Arrival - 9
Lexmas - 9
Solitude - 9
Splinter - 8
Mortal - 8
Cyborg - 8
Lockdown - 8
Mercy - 8
Void - 7
Vengeance - 7
Fragile - 7
Fanatic - 7
Exposed - 6
Aqua - 6
Hypnotic - 5
Thirst - 5
Tomb - 4