Supergirl Rank 'Em: Supergirl Season 3

[LL2K2]

We're now eight episodes into the third season of Supergirl, so it's time to discuss your favorite (and least favorite) episodes so far.

Episodes aired:

1. "Girl of Steel" (aired 10/09/17)
2. "Triggers" (aired 10/16/17)
3. "Far From the Tree" (aired 10/23/17)
4. "The Faithful" (aired 10/30/17)
5. "Damage" (aired 11/6/17)
6. "Midvale" (aired 11/13/17)
7. "Wake Up" (aired 11/20/17)
8. "Crisis on Earth-X, Part 1" (aired 11/27/17)
Arrow S6E8: "Crisis on Earth-X, Part 2" (aired 11/27/17)
The Flash S4E8: "Crisis on Earth-X, Part 3" (aired 11/28/17)
Legends of Tomorrow S3E8: "Crisis on Earth-X, Part 4" (aired 11/28/17)
9. "Reign" (aired 12/4/17; midseason finale)
10. "The Legion of Superheroes" (aired 1/15/18)
11. "Fort Rozz" (aired 1/22/18)
12. "For Good" (aired 1/29/18)
13. "Both Sides Now" (aired 2/5/18)
14. "Schott Through the Heart" (aired 4/16/18)
15. "In Search of Lost Time" (aired 4/23/18)
16. "Of Two Minds" (aired 4/30/18)
17. "Trinity" (aired 5/7/18)
18. "Shelter From the Storm" (aired 5/14/18)

Upcoming:

19. "The Fanatical" (airing 5/21/18)
20. "Dark Side of the Moon" (airing 5/28/18)
21. "Not Kansas" (airing 6/4/18)

Now that I'm caught up, here's my take:

GREAT episodes:
- Far From the Tree
- The Faithful
- Midvale (my favorite so far)
- Wake Up
- Crisis on Earth-X (the entire event)
- Reign

GOOD episodes:
- Girl of Steel
- Triggers
- Damage

 

[flickchick85]

Since we're at the mid-season finale point, the eps I enjoyed:

1. "The Faithful"
2. "Crisis on Earth-X, Part 1" (Supergirl)
3. "Midvale"
4. "Reign"
5. "Crisis on Earth-X, Part 4" (Legends of Tomorrow)
6. "Triggers"
7. "Girl of Steel"
8. "Damage"
9. "Crisis on Earth-X, Part 3" (The Flash)

The ones I didn't really care for:

10. "Wake Up"
11. "Crisis on Earth-X, Part 2" (Arrow)
12. "Far from the Tree"

 

[BH/HHH]

I count Crisis on Earth X as it’s own thing. It may be the best thing DCTV has ever done IMO.

So far this season I’ve loved one episode and liked another. So for me:

1) Midvale - it was a love letter to my favourite TV show Smallville and it was brilliant. In my top 5 episodes of the show ever I’d say.
3) The Faithful - Forgot to add this one, a good episode and the highlight for me been James story about the first time he met Superman.
3) Far From the Tree - the Mars stuff was superb

Then the rest I either didn’t like or was just bored

 

[Kelly]

My ranking thus far...

1. "Reign"
2. "Midvale"
3. "Crisis...Earth X" in total
4. "Girl Of Steel"
5. "Triggers"
6. "Wake Up"
7. "The Faithful"
8. "Far From The Tree" This one might have ranked higher had it only been the Mars stuff.
9. "Damage" This one could have been up further, but that one extremely weird scene with Alex and Maggie, the loud music and suddenly dancing was just awkward and weird. Totally took me out of the episode.

Crossover ranking just for fun.
1. "Crisis...Earth X" Part 3
2. "Crisis...Earth X" Part 1
3. "Crisis...Earth X" Part 2
4. "Crisis...Earth X" Part 4

Note: My 4 -- 7 could actually be a tie...

 

[flickchick85]

I count Crisis on Earth X as it’s own thing. It may be the best thing DCTV has ever done IMO.

So far this season I’ve loved one episode and liked another. So for me:

1) Midvale - it was a love letter to my favourite TV show Smallville and it was brilliant. In my top 5 episodes of the show ever I’d say.
2) Far From the Tree - the Mars stuff was superb

Then the rest I either didn’t like or was just bored

Aw, I thought you were a fan of “The Faithful,” b/c I remember thinking, OMG we agreed on an episode lol.

 

[BH/HHH]

Aw, I thought you were a fan of “The Faithful,” b/c I remember thinking, OMG we agreed on an episode lol.

Oh yeah that one was good actually. I forgot about it haha. Will edit my post.

 

[LL2K2]

I'll revise my list a bit:

AWESOME episodes:
- Midvale
- Crisis on Earth-X
- Reign

GREAT episodes:
- Girl of Steel
- Triggers
- The Faithful
- Wake Up

GOOD episodes:
- Far From the Tree
- Damage