Redneck Woman vs. Redneck Girl

"Redneck Woman" is the debut single of American country music artist Gretchen Wilson. Released in 2004, the single served as the lead-off to her multi-platinum debut album Here for the Party. The song was also Wilson's only number one single on the U.S. Billboard Hot Country Singles & Tracks charts, and also earned her a No. 22 pop hit in the U.S.
[YT]82dDnv9zeLs[/YT]

VS.​

"Redneck Girl" is a 1982 single by The Bellamy Brothers. "Redneck Girl" was written by David Bellamy and was the sixth number one country hit for The Bellamy Brothers. The single went to number one for one week and spent a total of twelve weeks on the country chart.
[YT]IJiKE_jMbyM[/YT]

In your opinion, which is the superior song, and why?