The Amazing Spider-Man 2 Shailene Woodley COULD BE Mary Jane Watson.....in TASM3

Status
Not open for further replies.
I feel like most of the people complaining about her appearance probably just haven't watched enough porn that day.

While I agree people are acting quite shallow here but its also correct to say that they could have found a better actress.

Beats me why they didn't cast Lyndsy Fonseca
 
While I agree people are acting quite shallow here but its also correct to say that they could have found a better actress.

Beats me why they didn't cast Lyndsy Fonseca

Please allow me to expand on this shallowness; a better actress in what way?
 

That argument does actually make some pretty sound points. Keeping in mind I'm one of the skeptics.

I do really like the "she can't be hotter than Gwen because Gwen is the true love" point. MJ is essentially the plan b. But if thats the case, will they be trying to extenuate her looks in a future installment?

I don't love the "ultimate MJ" point because Gwen is the smart one in ASM1. MJ was the brainy one in USM. I don't need both girls in Peter's life to be overtly intellectual types. People of average intelligence need lovin too! Not to say they shouldn't both be fairly smart.

I'm glad it's not Megan Fox. I'm glad its not Kirsten Dunst. I still can't wait to see ASM2. But I think that's the best I can say about SW at this point, until I see her on screen.
 
That argument does actually make some pretty sound points. Keeping in mind I'm one of the skeptics.

I do really like the "she can't be hotter than Gwen because Gwen is the true love" point. MJ is essentially the plan b. But if thats the case, will they be trying to extenuate her looks in a future installment?

I don't love the "ultimate MJ" point because Gwen is the smart one in ASM1. MJ was the brainy one in USM. I don't need both girls in Peter's life to be overtly intellectual types. People of average intelligence need lovin too! Not to say they shouldn't both be fairly smart.

I'm glad it's not Megan Fox. I'm glad its not Kirsten Dunst. I still can't wait to see ASM2. But I think that's the best I can say about SW at this point, until I see her on screen.

I agree

I am getting a street smart, tomboy vibe from this Mary Jane.
It should be interesting.


I really like her attitude here. She wants to do her own stunts.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pL2Jcy7GCV0
 
Last edited:
One thing I wholeheartedly hope. More important to me than how MJ looks. Is that she doesn't fall in love with a dozen different people before she gets a shot at Peter. That was always a head shaker in Raimi's trilogy.
 
Please allow me to expand on this shallowness; a better actress in what way?

Lets face it,Woodley is neither very good looking nor too experienced.Nor does she give out the MJ vibe

They are plenty of actresses around the age who are better looking or more experienced or both

Beats me why they try to do better,especially when the other cast is damn good
 
Lets face it,Woodley is neither very good looking nor too experienced.Nor does she give out the MJ vibe

They are plenty of actresses around the age who are better looking or more experienced or both

Beats me why they try to do better,especially when the other cast is damn good

well, they obviously know something about shailene that you don't, don't they? she was cast for a reason, and i'm sure the casting directors, marc and everyone else who could've possibly have an input on who gets cast know more about their jobs and how someone fits into this universe's version of mj than anyone else does.
 
well, they obviously know something about shailene that you don't, don't they? she was cast for a reason, and i'm sure the casting directors, marc and everyone else who could've possibly have an input on who gets cast know more about their jobs and how someone fits into this universe's version of mj than anyone else does.

I hope you are right
 
Lets face it,Woodley is neither very good looking nor too experienced.Nor does she give out the MJ vibe

BaneForYouCaptioncopy.jpg
 
I wanted her to talk more about human beings...
 
what's not to get? there are shallow people and there are profound people. jeez, not even the way the girl talks is good enough for y'all.
 
omigosh how dare they not cater to your personal opinion!!111

What you don't get is that I represent the majority of fan boys. So what you are saying is how dare they not cater to the majority of the fan base. Yup, that's a smart move on their part.

They are lucky that this poor decision won't prevent us from caring or showing up. We'll still go see this in the theaters, but probably only once. Part of it is that we still care about the other characters because they did a good job casting those. Peter and Gwen are great, so we still care. Jamie as Electro will be interesting, so we care.

But if Gwen gets off'd in this movie and the 3rd is all about Peter and MJ, and it's still Woodley, I think they may have a problem...

I also like how more and more are at least starting to agree that Woodley is not right for this role! I also didn't think about how Ultimate MJ is th non-sexy, non-model, intellectual version; and we already have an intellectual with Gwen. MJ really needs to be very different from Gwen for this to work.

Maybe they realize how good they have it with the Peter and Gwen story so they won't kill her off until half way through #3, so MJ is really just a secondary character. Of course if this is their plan we should not expect a #4 or #5 movie...
 
What you don't get is that I represent the majority of fan boys. So what you are saying is how dare they not cater to the majority of the fan base. Yup, that's a smart move on their part.

show me the poll that says everyone hates Ultimate MJ
 
What you don't get is that I represent the majority of fan boys. So what you are saying is how dare they not cater to the majority of the fan base.

so you're saying that if the majority of the fanbase were racists they'd still have to cater to them, even if it's wrong?

honestly, sony KNOWS what they're doing (at least as far as casting goes), they wouldn't have cast her if they didn't see potential in her, she is going to be super big next year with the release of divergent and the fault in our stars and she's getting all sorts of award buzz for her independent films, by choosing her they're catering to the general public, who will know her as a big celebrity and the critics, who all adore her for her talent.

the comic book movie world does not revolve around fanboys, because most fanboys are insane and will complain about everything, and at the end of the day, the studio releases the movie it wants to release, whether the comics fans like what they've done with it or not.
 
What you don't get is that I represent the majority of fan boys. So what you are saying is how dare they not cater to the majority of the fan base. Yup, that's a smart move on their part.

They are lucky that this poor decision won't prevent us from caring or showing up. We'll still go see this in the theaters, but probably only once. Part of it is that we still care about the other characters because they did a good job casting those. Peter and Gwen are great, so we still care. Jamie as Electro will be interesting, so we care.

But if Gwen gets off'd in this movie and the 3rd is all about Peter and MJ, and it's still Woodley, I think they may have a problem...

I also like how more and more are at least starting to agree that Woodley is not right for this role! I also didn't think about how Ultimate MJ is th non-sexy, non-model, intellectual version; and we already have an intellectual with Gwen. MJ really needs to be very different from Gwen for this to work.

Maybe they realize how good they have it with the Peter and Gwen story so they won't kill her off until half way through #3, so MJ is really just a secondary character. Of course if this is their plan we should not expect a #4 or #5 movie...

1786050_zps3a0101a1.jpg
 
What you don't get is that I represent the majority of fan boys. So what you are saying is how dare they not cater to the majority of the fan base. Yup, that's a smart move on their part.

They are lucky that this poor decision won't prevent us from caring or showing up. We'll still go see this in the theaters, but probably only once. Part of it is that we still care about the other characters because they did a good job casting those. Peter and Gwen are great, so we still care. Jamie as Electro will be interesting, so we care.

But if Gwen gets off'd in this movie and the 3rd is all about Peter and MJ, and it's still Woodley, I think they may have a problem...

I also like how more and more are at least starting to agree that Woodley is not right for this role! I also didn't think about how Ultimate MJ is th non-sexy, non-model, intellectual version; and we already have an intellectual with Gwen. MJ really needs to be very different from Gwen for this to work.

Maybe they realize how good they have it with the Peter and Gwen story so they won't kill her off until half way through #3, so MJ is really just a secondary character. Of course if this is their plan we should not expect a #4 or #5 movie...

So many things about this post just reek of entitlement.

“What's right isn't always popular. What's popular isn't always right.”


The majority isn't always (or ever) right.

Of course you'll go see the movie in the theater. And no matter how much the rest of the fanboys complain, so will they. Why should it matter whether you go one time or 100 times? You're still supporting the film and giving Sony your business. I don't understand fanboy logic.
 
so you're saying that if the majority of the fanbase were racists they'd still have to cater to them, even if it's wrong?

honestly, sony KNOWS what they're doing (at least as far as casting goes), they wouldn't have cast her if they didn't see potential in her, she is going to be super big next year with the release of divergent and the fault in our stars and she's getting all sorts of award buzz for her independent films, by choosing her they're catering to the general public, who will know her as a big celebrity and the critics, who all adore her for her talent.

the comic book movie world does not revolve around fanboys, because most fanboys are insane and will complain about everything, and at the end of the day, the studio releases the movie it wants to release, whether the comics fans like what they've done with it or not.

That's a bingo!

if these boards are any indication, then fanboys have no idea what they want. They are cursed with literal minds and tunnel vision. In their minds, the end result of a live action film MUST look exactly like the comic book or cartoon or else it's rubbish.
 
What you don't get is that I represent the majority of fan boys. So what you are saying is how dare they not cater to the majority of the fan base. Yup, that's a smart move on their part.

They are lucky that this poor decision won't prevent us from caring or showing up. We'll still go see this in the theaters, but probably only once. Part of it is that we still care about the other characters because they did a good job casting those. Peter and Gwen are great, so we still care. Jamie as Electro will be interesting, so we care.

But if Gwen gets off'd in this movie and the 3rd is all about Peter and MJ, and it's still Woodley, I think they may have a problem...

I also like how more and more are at least starting to agree that Woodley is not right for this role! I also didn't think about how Ultimate MJ is th non-sexy, non-model, intellectual version; and we already have an intellectual with Gwen. MJ really needs to be very different from Gwen for this to work.

Maybe they realize how good they have it with the Peter and Gwen story so they won't kill her off until half way through #3, so MJ is really just a secondary character. Of course if this is their plan we should not expect a #4 or #5 movie...
You think too highly of your own opinion. Its sad.
 
So many things about this post just reek of entitlement.

“What's right isn't always popular. What's popular isn't always right.”


The majority isn't always (or ever) right.

Of course you'll go see the movie in the theater. And no matter how much the rest of the fanboys complain, so will they. Why should it matter whether you go one time or 100 times? You're still supporting the film and giving Sony your business. I don't understand fanboy logic.

300 lb pimply faced geek in mother's basement: "MJ isn't sexy enough to me! So f*** that Spidey movie!"
 
That's a bingo!

if these boards are any indication, then fanboys have no idea what they want. They are cursed with literal minds and tunnel vision. In their minds, the end result of a live action film MUST look exactly like the comic book or cartoon or else it's rubbish.

Go to any forum where comics are discussed. they can't even agree on comic canon stuff! let alone movies
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
200,548
Messages
21,758,563
Members
45,594
Latest member
Jeremija
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"