Spider-Man's identity not so secret?

[webhead731]

lol.

Think about it. Even though some of the people who know are dead, they still knew before.

Norman Osborn
Harry Osborn
Doc Ock
Aunt May
Robbie
ALL those people on the train
Eddie Brock (He figures it out)
Mary Jane


That's all that I can think of at the moment.

But dang. Just something funny to think about.

I wonder if someone on the train will talk. Maybe tell J.J.?

 

[DACrowe]

Well the people don't know ono the train who Peter Parker is. So it doesn't count.

As for the rest....well when you make your cast and story revolve around the Goblin Arc, the death of Aunt May and MJ....you are limiting yourself to how secret it will be. It doesn't help you introduce Venom and say "Ah **** it, let's have Doc Ock find out too."

Hopefully Sandman won't know....at the very least.

 

[Karea07]

Since Sandman is supposed to be the main villain he will probably find out and kidnap Mary Jane or something

 

[Spider-Ranger]

I don't think we can't say for sure that Aunt May and Robbie know his secret.

 

[mattsturm]

When did Aunt May figure it out? I don't remember that scene. Or Robbie for that matter...You can assume that they assume, but outside of that, theres no concrete evidence that they know.

 

[GreenMamba]

It's not like the people on the train even know who Peter Parker is.

 

[Katsuro]

When did Aunt May figure it out? I don't remember that scene. Or Robbie for that matter...You can assume that they assume, but outside of that, theres no concrete evidence that they know.

When Peter was visiting her while that kid was helping her pack, and she talked to him about Spider-Man, it kinda seemed like she might know. It's debatable as to whether or not she did, but I think so.

 

[Karea07]

Hopefully she will tell him she knows in 3, to clear that up. Maybe Peter can be friends with Robbie in 3 too - like he was in the cartoon, if Robbie finds out his secret.

 

[Spider-Ranger]

Maybe we'll get the bug surprise in sm3: Aunt may knew it all along

 

[Visionary]

I'd like to see Aunt May try on the Spidey costume, while Peter is asleep. And then the camera pans around her slowly, as we get a glimpse of her lovely lady lumps.

 

[webhead731]

The way Robbie said, "I heard Spider-Man was there" and the way he looked at Peter tells all in my opinion.

 

[Yurka]

The way Robbie said, "I heard Spider-Man was there" and the way he looked at Peter tells all in my opinion.

yeah i agree

 

[Spider-Fan83]

they, just kinda of implied that Robbie and aunt May, might know,
though you forgot about, that guy from the wrestling place (who wouldn‘t pay him), I am sure he figured it out after spider-man went public (I mean he probably didn't know his peter's name, but he would be able to point him out) I am surprised he hasn't tried to cash in on that yet, and possible, the announcer (Bruce Campbell) lol

 

[Dr.Dude]

Heh, well the amusing thing here is that either way, it's still not even half of the amount of people who know Ultimate Spidey's "secret" identity by now....

 

[gvcool2]

Maybe we'll get the bug surprise in sm3: Aunt may knew it all along

I think the big suprise will be Aunt May is pregnant

 

[Yurka]

with cletus cassidy's baby

 

[Mr.Phunk]

they, just kinda of implied that Robbie and aunt May, might know,
though you forgot about, that guy from the wrestling place (who wouldn‘t pay him), I am sure he figured it out after spider-man went public (I mean he probably didn't know his peter's name, but he would be able to point him out) I am surprised he hasn't tried to cash in on that yet, and possible, the announcer (Bruce Campbell) lol

THats actually a good popint, i never thought of that

 

[BenClueless]

Don't forget the doctor he goes to in part 2!

 

[The Shape]

I think the big suprise will be Aunt May is pregnant

great addition to the discussion.

anyway, that's just a select few people out of millions. plus, most that know his secret are close to him or are villians that end up dying anyway (in the movies).

spidey's fine.

 

[DACrowe]

Robbie is suspicious as he was for most of the comics but it was just a nod to the fans (as is the Robbie and Betty Brant characters who are just there to whet our appetites like Conners unfortunately....in retrospect I would have preferred Peter flirting with Betty than just bringing Gwen in for that....too messy, plus Elizabeth Banks is hotter than Dunst or Howard....I'm rambling now).

As for Aunt May I predict them to do an ASM #400 in the SM3 movie with her

Spoiler

death and probably revealing she knows to give him the strength to rid himself of that blasted symbiote

.

I'd also think while Sandman will have the most fights that Harry and Venom will play larger roles thematically (Venom) and emotionally (Harry), as Sandman is just there for some SFX coolness. That is my guess though.

 

[gvcool2]

great addition to the discussion.

anyway, that's just a select few people out of millions. plus, most that know his secret are close to him or are villians that end up dying anyway (in the movies).

spidey's fine.

hypocrisy's a terrible thing

 

[craigaat]

ALL those people on the train?

None of them know his secret identity, none of them know who Peter Parker is, they just know what the guy under the mask looks like.

 

[TOK]

Don't forget the doctor he goes to in part 2!

Peter tells about a friend and a dream, so the doctor doesn't know.

I had also thought about the wrestling guy. Did he lost his memory on the punch, or what?

 

[The Infernal]

I'm not sure Robbie knows Peter is Spider-man. It's hinted partly in SM2 but then again he could just believe that Peter and Spider-man are close. Whether he realises Peter is Spider-man isn't too clear. I'd like to think he does though.

I'm not too sure about Aunt May either. Does she even know it's Peter taking the Spider-man photos? If he hasn't told her then it's not unlikely that she found out by herself. Whether she's put two and two together is another thing.

I don't think that the ring announcer or wrestler know who Peter is. They never saw his face. Though the guy who shafted him for the money did. still, he didn't know who Peter was and he doesn't seem like the kind of guy who likes media or police attention.

As for the Doctor in SM2. It's strongly hinted that he just realised he was speaking to Spider-man. He did seem pretty shocked.

I wouldn't mind Spidey going public like he did in Civil War. Though it would have to be after the sixth or seventh movie. At least then we would have had a good run of classic Spidey stories (hopefuly)

 

[Gladiator]

they, just kinda of implied that Robbie and aunt May, might know,
though you forgot about, that guy from the wrestling place (who wouldn‘t pay him), I am sure he figured it out after spider-man went public (I mean he probably didn't know his peter's name, but he would be able to point him out) I am surprised he hasn't tried to cash in on that yet, and possible, the announcer (Bruce Campbell) lol

.....I couldn't imagine a guy forgeting his peter's name. Sorry, I couldn't resist.

I think that Aunt May and Robbie have a pretty good idea that Peter is Spidey but have no proof yet. And I wouldn't be surprised if John Jameson figured it out somehow.

I haven't seen anyone mention the two kids that saw him do a back-flip off of his moped over the car. But they fall into the category of not knowing who Peter Parker is.