Mrs. Sawyer
Avenger
- Joined
- Mar 11, 2009
- Messages
- 24,469
- Reaction score
- 2
- Points
- 31
Eesh, you guys make it feel like a crime to like both BB and TDK.
I like them both for different reasons, but I feel like TDK is the stronger movie, but it only was by sacrificing aspects of Batman, like that mystique he usually has in his movies, and him being more a character on par with the others than the de facto main character.
And I feel like of all the live action movies, the one with most failed potential is Batman Forever. I used to go on about this a lot when I was a newbie, but the script for Batman Forever was great. It didn't say anything about neon lights, buttshots or Batman being in court when Harvey Dent got hit with acid (seriously, wtf?).
Still, it's an okay Batman movie but it's potential got squandered not when they said movie needed to be family friendly (because it could have been that), but when Joel Schumacher was hired to do it and made a bunch of stupid decisions (that he to this day blames WB for but we all know that's BS).
And Batman Returns I dislike as a Batman movie because Batman comes off as an a*****e more than a hero and Burton's style started to become overbearing, but it's not a bad movie overall.
Still with all of that said, here's what I think is the defining Batman movie:
I like them both for different reasons, but I feel like TDK is the stronger movie, but it only was by sacrificing aspects of Batman, like that mystique he usually has in his movies, and him being more a character on par with the others than the de facto main character.
And I feel like of all the live action movies, the one with most failed potential is Batman Forever. I used to go on about this a lot when I was a newbie, but the script for Batman Forever was great. It didn't say anything about neon lights, buttshots or Batman being in court when Harvey Dent got hit with acid (seriously, wtf?).
Still, it's an okay Batman movie but it's potential got squandered not when they said movie needed to be family friendly (because it could have been that), but when Joel Schumacher was hired to do it and made a bunch of stupid decisions (that he to this day blames WB for but we all know that's BS).
And Batman Returns I dislike as a Batman movie because Batman comes off as an a*****e more than a hero and Burton's style started to become overbearing, but it's not a bad movie overall.
Still with all of that said, here's what I think is the defining Batman movie: